Church History: Pelagianism

Church History: Pelagianism

I believe Pelagianism and its offshoot, Semi-Pelagianism, are the most pervasive of the resurrected heresies of old. The Arians are alive today in the Jehovah’s Witnesses, but they are a fringe group. The Sabellians are alive today in the Oneness Pentecostals, but again, they are a fringe group. The Marcionites are alive today in the Hyper-Dispensationalists, but they are really a fringe group. However, Pelagianism is alive today in innumerable churches of all stripes. Not only that, but their error is intentionally alive. When people are confused about the hypostatic union and accidentally affirm Apollinarism, I understand that they are simply untaught. The hypostatic union is a lofty concept after all. However, Pelagianism is not so much an error of ignorance, but rather an error of arrogance. With all that said, what is Pelagianism and its close sibling, Semi-Pelagianism?

‘We confess that man always has free will.’ God, the Father of all justice, makes no exception of persons, and he does not demand the impossible. Human perfection is possible; therefore, it is obligatory.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 280

Two points were particularly singled out [when Pelagius was denied ordination]: his teaching that the sin of Adam and Eve injured themselves alone; and his teaching that a newborn child is in the same state as Adam before the Fall.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 280

Pelagius (AD 360-420) and his theology can be summarized thus:

  • Humans have libertarian free will
  • Humans are born in a morally perfect state
  • Humans are capable of remaining morally perfect for their entire life

Semi-Pelagianism arose after the Church pushed back against Pelagianism. They attempted to repackage Pelagianism in a milder form. They no longer affirmed that a human could remain morally perfect in life, but they continued to affirm that humans have libertarian free will and are born in a morally perfect state. Furthermore, they pushed a teaching that would become a watershed issue for the Church. Specifically, they taught that for a sinner to be justified, he had to believe the gospel, but in order to believe the gospel, the sinner did not require any internal grace imparted by the Spirit of God on his soul. Rather, they taught that sinful humans are capable of taking the initiative to believe the gospel on their own. These two issues—original sin and prevenient grace—were the primary objects of scorn in the Church, which held multiple councils to condemn the Pelagians and Semi-Pelagians. First, Pelagius and his immediate followers were quickly condemned.

The North Africans were of a different mind, and a council at Carthage in 416 called on the bishop of Rome to condemn Pelagius. Innocent I in 417 confirmed their condemnation.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 280

The Council of Ephesus in 431 in its letter to Pope Celestine confirmed the depositions of Celestius, Pelagius, Julian, and other Pelagians.

CHurch History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 282

Semi-Pelagianism, however, took longer to receive its formal condemnation, but its formal condemnation was thorough and unapologetic.

If anyone denies that it is the whole man, both body and soul, that was changed for the worse through the offense of Adam’s sin, but believes that freedom of the soul remains unimpaired and that only the body is subject to corruption, he is deceived by the error of Pelagius and contradicts the Scripture, which says, ‘The soul that sins shall die,’ and, ‘Do you not know that if you yield yourselves to anyone as obedient slaves, then you are the slaves of the one whom you obey?’ and, ‘Whatever overcomes a man, to that he is enslaved.’

Council of Orange (521), canon 1

If anyone asserts that Adam’s sin affected him alone and not his descendants also, or at least if he declares that is is only the death of the body which is the punishment for sin and not also that sin, which is the death of the soul, passed through one man to the whole human race, he does injustice to God and contradicts the Apostle, who says, ‘Therefore, as sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin, so death spread to all men, because all men sinned.’

Council of Orange, canon 2

If anyone says that the grace of God can be conferred as a result of human prayer, but that it is not grace itself which makes us to pray, then he contradicts the prophet Isaiah or the Apostle, who says the same thing, ‘I have been found by those who did not seek Me. I have shown Myself to those who did not ask for Me.’

Council of Orange, Canon 3

If anyone maintains that God awaits our will to be cleansed from sin, but does not confess that even our will to be cleansed comes to us through the infusion and working of the Holy Spirit, he resists the Holy Spirit Himself, who says through Solomon, ‘The will is prepared by the Lord,’ and the salutary words of the Apostle, ‘God is at work in you, both to will and to work for His good pleasure.’

Council of Orange, canon 4

If anyone says that God has mercy upon us when, apart from His grace, we believe, will, desire, strive, labor, watch, study, seek, ask, or knock, but does not confess that it is by the infusion and inspiration of the Holy Spirit within us that we have the faith, the will, or the strength to do all these things as we ought, or if anyone makes the assistance of grace depend on the humility or obedience of man and does not agree that is is a gift of grace itself that we are obedient and humble, then he contradicts the Apostle, who says, ‘What have you that you did not receive?’ and, ‘By the grace of God, I am what I am.’

Council of Orange, canon 6

If anyone affirms that we can form any right opinion or make any right choice which relates to the salvation of eternal life, as it is expedient for us, or that we can be saved, that is, assent to the preaching of the gospel through our natural powers without the illumination and inspiration of the Holy Spirit, who makes all men gladly assent to and believe in the truth, he is led astray by a heretical spirit and does not understand the voice of God, who says in the Gospel, ‘Apart from Me, you can do nothing,’ and the word of the Apostle, ‘Not that we are competent of ourselves to claim anything as coming from us; our competence is from God.’

Council of Orange, canon 7

If anyone maintains that some are able to come to the grace of baptism by mercy, but others through free will, which has been manifestly corrupted in all those who have been born after the transgression of the first man, it is proof that he has no place in the true faith, for he denies that the free will of all men has been weakened through the sin of the first man, or at least holds that it has been affected in such a way that they have still the ability to seek the mystery of eternal salvation by themselves without the revelation of God. The Lord Himself shows how contradictory this is by declaring that ‘no one is able to come to Him unless the Father who sent Me draws him,’ as He also says to Peter, ‘Blessed are you, Simon, son of Jonah, for flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but My Father, who is in heaven,’ and as the Apostle says, ‘No one can say, “Jesus is Lord,” except by the Holy Spirit.’

Council of Orange, canon 8

Thus, according to the passages of the Holy Scripture quoted above or the interpretation of the ancient Fathers, we must, under the blessing of God, preach and believe as follows: The sin of the first man has so impaired and weakened free will that no one thereafter can either love God as he ought or believe in God or do good for God’s sake unless the grace of divine mercy has preceded him.

Council of Orange, Conclusion

Thus, the Church condemned Pelagianism/Semi-Pelagianism, because they denied original sin and the necessity of prevenient grace. In my experience, there are scores of American Christians today who deny original sin. When someone says, “Babies who die go to heaven because they are innocent,” that person is actually affirming Pelagianism. Babies who die do not go to heaven because they are innocent. Babies who die go to heaven because God is merciful and gracious and forgives them. When someone refers to the age of accountability, and when someone says the age of accountability is the moment when a child becomes a sinner, that person is actually affirming Pelagianism. Children do not become sinners when they reach a certain mental capacity. Children become sinners at the moment of conception because of original sin.

The Council of Orange also did not affirm libertarian free will. In fact, they repudiated the concept. They repudiated anyone who would say he believed the gospel because of his free will. The Church affirmed that faith is a gift, and the reason anyone believes is because of God’s efficacious grace. This is why I say that Pelagianism is not a heresy of ignorance, but rather of arrogance. People want to be free. They want to say they have libertarian free will. They want to be able to claim they took God up on His offer of salvation, and that’s why they are saved. That couldn’t be further from the truth though. The reason anyone believes is because of a gracious act of God, whereby He granted the individual faith. Prevenient grace isn’t only necessary, but also efficacious.

Pelagianism/Semi-Pelagianism is alive today all over churches in America in those who deny original sin and the necessity of prevenient grace. Thankfully, the early church dealt with this heresy in the Council of Orange in AD 529. Scripture teaches that libertarian free will is a phantom. Instead, all of humanity fell into sin, death, and condemnation the moment Adam sinned in the Garden. Scripture also teaches that salvation is entirely the work of God and His grace. No one can take credit for his faith. Instead, God deserves all the credit as the One who graciously drew the sinner to Him and graciously granted to the sinner the ability to believe the gospel. Anything less is a denial of the doctrine of grace alone. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *