Church History: Arianism

Church History: Arianism

Just as I said last week, and just as I read today in my Bible reading from Ecclesiastes, “there is nothing new under the sun.” Last week, we saw that church history has repeated itself in the form of the Charismatic Movement, which is simply a repackaged from of Montanism. This week, we’ll see that church history has repeated itself in the form of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, who simply repackaged Arianism. In order to see this parallel, we have to understand what Arianism is. Arius of Alexandria was born in AD 250 and died in AD 336, and his teachings pervaded the early church. Unfortunately, those teachings were dangerous and damning.

Arius and his followers exploited the argument that if Jesus is the incarnation of the Logos, and if the Logos is divine in the same sense that God the Father is divine, then God’s nature would be changed by the human life of Jesus in time, and God would have suffered in him. But that is impossible. Therefore, the Logos who became incarnate in Jesus Christ must not be fully divine, but rather must be a great exalted creature.

The Story of Christian Theology, pages 143-144

Arius rallied his Christian followers, and they began marching through the streets of Alexandria past the great church and the bishop’s house carrying placards and chanting slogans such as, ‘There was when the Son was not.’

The Story of Christian Theology, page 144

Understanding ‘begetting’ as equivalent to ‘creating,’ Arius taught that Jesus Christ was not derived from the substance of the Father, but, as the first and highest of God’s creation, became the instrument of all the rest of creation.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 192

We can summarize Arius’ view this way:

  • The Son is not eternal,
  • The Son was the first creation of the Father, and
  • The Son is divine, but not of the same divinity as the Father.

If you’ve ever interacted with a Jehovah’s Witness, then you’ve actually heard Arianism taught before. The Arians and the Jehovah’s Witnesses are almost identical, at least in their Christology. Thankfully, Jehovah’s Witnesses are relatively uncommon, at least compared to the Arians, who were so prevalent in the late-2nd and early-3rd centuries that hearing people debate the deity of Christ in the marketplace was just as common as hearing people ask what the price of bread was in the marketplace according to one early church historian. However, eventually and inevitably, the true Church prevailed in the ancient Arian debate. The greatest warrior for truth was Athanasius, who also was prominent on the frontlines in Alexandria, and the efforts of the true Church resulted in universal condemnation of the Arians’ heresy.

This subject has been most pressing since our brother and fellow minister, the dearly beloved Alexander, bishop of Alexandria, has expelled certain priests of Arius’ party because of the blasphemy which they raised against our Savior. Unfortunately, they were able to deceive others with their ungodly teaching and were even received into fellowship by them. So, it seemed best to our holy synod to set this matter in order first, so that once we had clarified the chief point of God’s mystery, all the other points could be set in order consecutively.

Synod of Antioch (AD 325), line 6

We anathematize those who say or think or proclaim that the Son of God is a creation, has come into being, was made, was not truly begotten, or that there was a time when He did not exist, for we believe that He was and that He is Light. Still, also, those who think He is unchangeable only by His free will, as with those who think that He did not exist before He was begotten and that He is not unchanging by His nature as the Father is. He has been proclaimed as the Father’s image in every respect, especially in this respect, that He does not change.

Synod of Antioch, line 13

First of all, then, in the presence of our most religious sovereign, Constantine, investigation was made of matters concerning the impiety and transgression of Arius and his adherents, and it was unanimously decreed that he and his impious opinion should be anathematized, together with the blasphemous words and speculations in which he indulged, blaspheming the Son of God and saying that He is from things that are not, and that before He was begotten He was not, and that there was a time when He was not, and that the Son of God is by His free will capable of vice and virtue, saying also that He is a creature. All these things the holy synod has anathematized, not even enduring to hear his impious doctrine and madness and blasphemous words.

Council of Nicaea (AD 325), The Synodal Letter

In fact, for an Arian’s repentance to be considered legitimate, the early church required the former Arian to write a formal renunciation of their former heresy.

Those who turn from heresy to orthodoxy and the portion of those who are being saved, we receive according to the fellow method and customs: Arians and Macedonians and Sabbatians and Novatians (who call themselves Cathari or Aristori) and Quarto-decimans or Tetradites or Appolinarians, we receive upon their giving a written renunciation and anathematization of every heresy which is not in accordance with the holy, universal, and apostolic Church of God.

Council of Constantinople (AD 381), canon 5

The early church took Arianism so seriously that they drafted an entire creed as a test of orthodoxy, in order to weed out the Arians from any congregation where they might be hiding.

We believe in one God, the Almighty Father, maker of all things visible and invisible, and in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the Son of God, the begotten of the Father, the only-begotten—that is, of the essence of the Father—God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father, by whom all things were made both in heaven and on earth, who for us men and for our salvation came down and was incarnate and was made man. He suffered and on the third day rose again, ascended into heaven, from which He will come to judge the living and the dead. [We believe] also in the Holy Spirit. However, those who say, ‘There was a time when He was not,’ and, ‘He was not before; He was made,’ and, ‘He was made out of nothing,’ or, ‘He is of another substance or essence,’ or, ‘The Son of God is created or changeable or alterable,’ they are condemned by the holy, universal, and apostolic Church.

Nicene Creed

The early church did not tolerate people who taught the Son is not eternal, but rather was created by the Father. They also did not tolerate people who taught the Son is not the exact same essence as the Father, but rather is a lesser deity. They say there’s nothing new under the sun, and when we understand church history, we see that the Jehovah’s Witnesses that exist today are merely modern-day Arians. The early church fought this Christological battle almost 1,700 years ago for us, and we would be remiss to not use their wisdom in our defense of the deity of Christ. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *