They say there’s nothing new under the sun, and that’s an unfortunately true concept in the realm of Church history. Modalists are just modern Sabellians (more on them later). Jehovah’s Witnesses are just modern Arians (also more on them later). Interestingly, the modern Charismatic Movement would appear to be a revival of an ancient group of people known as the “Montanists” or “Phrygians,” a group of “Christians” led by a man named Montanus that existed almost 2,000 years ago primarily in the land of Phrygia. Tell me if this description of the Montanists sounds familiar today:
Besides women’s prominence in the beginning of this prophetic movement, they continued to be important in [Montanism’s] later development and held church offices not allowed to them by the orthodox.
Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 101
Montanism was a religion of emotional exuberance and less rigid organizational structures, and it offered a direct revelation.
Church History: From Christ to the Pre-Reformation, page 102
Critics objected that Montanist prophecy involved some kind of possession and speaking in frenzied ecstasy.
Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 100
Montanism claimed a succession of prophets.
Church HIstory: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 108
Montanists saw prophecy and spiritual gifts as the hallmark of apostolic Christianity. They promised Paraclete (Holy Spirit) of the Gospel of John was regarded as speaking in them.
Church History: From Christ to the Pre-Reformation, page 100
[Montanus] considered the churches and their leaders spiritually dead and called for a ‘new prophecy’ with all the signs and wonders of the halcyon days of the early church of Pentecost.
The Story of Christian Theology, page 31
[Montanus] referred to himself as ‘the mouthpiece of the Holy Spirit’ and accused the standard church leaders of chasing the Holy Spirit into a book by trying to limit divine inspiration to apostolic writings. He strenuously opposed any such limitation of restriction and seemed to emphasize the continuous power and reality of inspired utterances such as his own.
The Story of Christian Theology, page 31
To summarize, Montanists:
- Considered contemporary church leaders to be spiritually dead,
- Considered contemporary church leaders to be limiting the Holy Spirit,
- Looked for divine revelation outside of Scripture,
- Allowed women to preach and hold offices in local churches,
- Were generally unorganized in their local church gatherings,
- Believed the office of prophet continued after the first century,
- Believed the ability to work miracles continued after the first century, and
- Spoke in frenzied, unintelligible ecstasies.
Does that sound familiar? Every single one of those descriptions for the Montanists could also double as a description for the modern Charismatic Movement. Interestingly, the early church did not tolerate the Montanists and swiftly condemned them for various reasons.
[The Montanists’] opposition and their recent heresy, which has separated them from the Church, arose in the following account. There is said to be a certain village called Adarbau in that part of Mysia, which borders upon Phrygia. There first, they say, when Gratus was proconsul of Asia, a recent convert, Montanus by name, through his unquenchable desire for leadership, gave the adversary an opportunity against him, and he became beside himself, and, being suddenly in a sort of frenzy and ecstasy, he raved and began to babble and utter strange things, prophesying in a manner contrary to the custom of the Church handed down by tradition from the beginning.
Eusebius (AD 260-339), Church History, book 5, chapter 16, sections 6-7
The faithful in Asia met often in many places throughout Asia to consider this matter [Montanism] and examined the novel utterances and pronounced them profane and rejected the heresy, and thus, these persons were expelled from the Church and barred from communion.
Eusebius, Church History, book 5, chapter 16, section 10
Persons converted from the heresy of those who are called ‘Phrygians,’ even should they be among those reputed by name as clergymen, and even should they be called the very chiefest, are with all care to be both instructed and baptized by the bishops and elders of the church [when they repent].
Synod of Laodicea (c. AD 350), Canon 8
Montanists (who are here called ‘Phrygians’) and Sabellians (who teach the identity of the Father and Son and do sundry other mischievous things) and all other heresies—for there are many such here, particularly among those who come from the country of the Galatians—all these, when they desire to turn to orthodoxy, we receive as heathens.
Council of Constantinople (AD 381), Canon 5
The early church did not tolerate people claiming to speak new revelation on behalf of God, and they did not tolerate people claiming to be prophets of God while uttering unintelligible gibberish. They also rejected women as ordained clergy who spoke in in the gathering of the saints. They say there’s nothing new under the sun, and they say you don’t have to reinvent the wheel. The Charismatic Movement today is just a repackaged form of the ancient Montanists, and the early church condemned them. Perhaps we can learn to value to the sufficiency of Scripture and the orderliness of God’s church when she gathers by studying how the early church dealt with the Montanists. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments