Systematic Theology: Original Sin

Systematic Theology: Original Sin

Last week, we looked at the Bible’s description of how humanity fell into sin and what curses God immediately put on Satan, men, women, and humanity in general. However, there was another result of the Fall, one that has dire ramifications on every single one of us born the old-fashioned way. Of course, I’m referring to the often-denied doctrine of original sin.

The doctrine of original sin or, as I like to call it, imputed sin rises or falls with Romans 5:12-21. There are plenty of verses that teach humans are sinners from conception, and I’ll present them briefly, but the theological foundation of this doctrine is Romans 5. First, though, let us look at a few verses from the Old Testament that demonstrate the fact that from conception humans are sinners.

Yahweh saw that the wickedness of mankind was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.

Genesis 6:5

Mankind’s thoughts are only evil continually in our natural state. Children, even babies, fall into the category of mankind. Therefore, their thoughts are only evil continually too by logical demand. God’s words after the Flood confirm this.

Yahweh said in His heart, ‘I will never again curse the ground because of man, for the intention of man’s heart is evil from his youth.’

Genesis 8:21

Mankind’s thoughts in their minds are only evil continually, and mankind’s intentions in their hearts are evil, even as babies. This sin is even present in the womb.

The wicked are estranged from the womb. They go astray from birth, speaking lies.

Psalm 58:3

Yes, from birth, children are deceptive. Anyone who has children knows that babies do not need to be taught how to be deceptive. They know that inherently, because they are sinners, even in the womb.

Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin did my mother conceive me.

Psalm 51:5

David considered himself a sinner while in his mother’s womb. Some have proposed that the phrase, “in sin did my mother conceive me,” merely refers to David being born in an adulterous union between his mother and a man who was not her husband. However, this has grave implications. David’s brothers are the sons of Jesse. Therefore, it should be obvious that David is the son of Jesse. This is important, because Scripture not only refers to the Messiah as “the Son of David,” but also Jeremiah 33:15 and Isaiah 11:1 both refer to the Messiah as “the branch of Jesse.” If David was born of an adulterous affair, then his father is not Jesse. If Jesse is not David’s father, then Jesus, who is descended from David, would not be descended from Jesse and, thereby, would not be the branch of Jesse. Therefore, when David says, “in sin did my mother conceive me,” he can’t be referring to his mother being an adulterous woman. Rather, he’s referring to his own sinfulness in the womb.

With all of that said, let’s work through Romans 5:12-21, where the doctrine of original sin is put on full display.

Therefore, just as sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin, so death spread to all men, because all sinned.

Romans 5:12

Sin came into the world when Adam (and Eve) ate the fruit. Adam takes the blame theologically because he had the duty to lead his wife and stop her from eating, but he failed. Since the wages of sin is death (cf. Romans 6:23), by bringing sin into the world, Adam also brought death into the world. That’s not controversial. What’s controversial is the second half of verse 12, which introduces the concept of original sin. Death spread to all humans, because all humans sinned. When did they sin? They sinned when Adam sinned, and therefore, they deserve to die from the moment of conception. Many would object to that interpretation, but it’s the only way to make sense of verses 13-14.

Sin indeed was in the world before the Law was given, but sin is not counted [literally: imputed] where there is no law. Yet, death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over those whose sinning was not like the transgression of Adam, who was a type of the One who was to come.

Romans 5:13-14

When we read about the world between the Fall in Genesis 3 and the Flood in Genesis 7, there is nothing but evil for about 1,500 years. Cain murdered Abel. In fact, the first verse I cited from Genesis 6:5, that humans’ thoughts are only evil continually, is a description of the antediluvian (pre-Flood) world. Clearly, people were sinning before the Flood occurred. However, did these antediluvian people have a didactic presentation of God’s righteous standard given to them? No, they did not, and that’s why verse 13 says, “sin is not counted where there is no law.”

The actions of the antediluvian humans were evil, but they couldn’t be held accountable for them. After all, they had no law from God. Their sinning “was not like the transgression of Adam.” When Adam sinned, he explicitly and knowingly violated a direct command from God. God told Adam, “Don’t eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil,” but Adam ate. His sin was belligerent. However, did the antediluvian humans have such clear commands to violate? No, they did not. They did not have a law over them from God. Therefore, their sins couldn’t be counted against them, because “sin is not counted where there is no law.” However, if you’re thinking critically, then you’d be asking yourself this question, “If the antediluvian humans didn’t have their sins imputed/counted against them, then how did they die? After all, the wages of sin is death, right?” You are correct to ask that question, and Paul makes that same observation.

In verse 14, Paul says, “Yet, death reigned from Adam to Moses,” even over the antediluvian people who did not violate an explicit command from God, like Adam did. At this point, we have to ask this question: Why did they die if their sins weren’t counted against them? The answer is not, “Because they violated their consciences.” Here’s how I know. The answer to the question, “Why did the antediluvian humans die?” is the same answer to this question: Why do babies die?

Many people would have you believe that babies are conceived innocent, and that they only become sinners as children when they intentionally violate an expressed command that they understand, like Adam. Many people would have you believe that babies are conceived as “a second Adam,” in a morally good and neutral state. However, there is a massive elephant in the room when discussing this subject, one that breaks our hearts. That elephant is this question: Why do babies die?

Miscarriages are a tragic thing. I know many mothers who have miscarried babies, and it is tragic, especially in America where people don’t like to talk about death. In the tragedy of the death of a baby in the womb or a newborn, we have to ask the theological question, “How can this happen?” The answer is hard but simple. The wages of sin is death. If a baby dies, then the baby must’ve been a sinner. All of us, like David said, are conceived in sin. Therefore, all of us are conceived with a death threat. We might die the day after conception, or we might die a hundred years after birth. We will all die though, and this is a testament to our sinfulness.

At this point, someone might object by saying, “That’s not fair! How can God hold a baby responsible for Adam’s sin?” To that, I would reply that you can’t have your cake and eat it too, because the doctrine of imputed sin is intimately linked to the doctrine of imputed righteousness in Romans 5:15-17.

The free gift is not like the trespass, for if many died through one man’s trespass, then much more have the grace of God and the free gift by the grace of that one man, Jesus Christ, abounded for many. The free gift is not like the result of that one man’s sin, for the judgment following one trespass brought condemnation, but the free gift following many trespasses brought justification. If, because of one man’s trespass, death reigned through that one man, then much more will those who receive the abundance of grace and the free gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man, Jesus Christ.

Romans 5:15-17

The free gift of Jesus Christ’s righteousness is not like Adam’s sin. When Adam sinned, many died, specifically, all of humanity that is born in Adam, which includes all of us excepting Jesus, who was born of the virgin and the Holy Spirit. If Jesus had a human father, then He would’ve been sinful and disqualified from being our Savior. However, since His biological father was God Himself (just like Adam), Jesus is free to be the second Adam, the second representative of humanity. Adam’s sin brings death to everyone he represents, but Jesus’ righteousness brings life to everyone He represents. Not only that, but Jesus’ righteousness covers an infinite number of sins, not just the one sin of Adam. Jesus’ righteousness doesn’t just return those He saves to a morally neutral state, but rather makes them justified.

Here’s the point though: you can’t have imputed righteousness without imputed sin. We all love the doctrine of imputed righteousness, the truth that God credits Jesus’ perfection to those in Him, so that they are righteous in His sight. However, that doctrine is only true because the opposite is also true. God credits Adam’s sinfulness to those in him, so that they are condemned in His sight. If you deny original sin, then you must by logical necessity deny imputed righteousness. This is why the Church has considered the doctrine of original sin to be a fundamental doctrine to the gospel and the Christian faith. To deny original sin is to deny imputed righteousness, because they are linked in verse 18.

Therefore, as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men.

Romans 5:18

Now, before anyone even thinks the word “universalism,” you must understand the theology of “headship.” When Paul says Adam’s sin brought condemnation to all men, he’s referring to all men who have Adam as their head, as their representative. When Paul says Jesus’ righteousness brought justification and eternal life to all men, he’s referring to all men who have Jesus as their head, as their representative. If you are “in Adam,” then you have Adam’s sin imputed to you and are condemned. However, if you are “in Christ,” then you have Jesus’ righteousness imputed to you and are justified. The issue is whether you are in Adam or in Christ, and this concept is found in a parallel passage to Romans 5:12-21.

As all in Adam die, so also all in Christ shall be made alive.

1 Corinthians 15:22

Therefore, we can conclude that Romans 5:12-21 does in fact teach that when Adam sinned in the Garden of Eden, everyone who would be born from him sinned in him. He represented humanity in the Garden, and he sinned. Therefore, since Adam is our head, everyone born of Adam is born a sinner. Everyone conceived by a sinful human father (all of us except Jesus) is conceived guilty. That’s why babies can die. That’s why the pre-Law antediluvian humans could die. That’s why no one deserves heaven. Think about it. If babies are conceived innocent, when they die, they would go to heaven, but not based on Jesus’ righteousness. I propose to you that no one will be in heaven for any other reason than Jesus’ righteousness. If God elects to save babies that die in the womb—and in my personal opinion, I believe He does—it’s only because of His grace and Jesus’ righteousness, not because the babies are inherently innocent. They’re not. They have Adam’s sin imputed to them, just like the rest of us.

Scripture teaches the doctrine of original sin, that Adam’s sin is imputed to everyone born in him. Therefore, everyone is guilty of sin in the eyes of God from the moment of conception. You don’t have to teach a baby how to sin. They come preprogrammed by nature, because they’re just like their father, Adam. Experience and, more importantly, Scripture proves that humans are sinners from conception and guilty in the eyes of God. However, we need not stay that way. For those who trust in Jesus to save them as the crucified and resurrection Savior and Lord, they are no longer in Adam. They have been born again with Jesus as their new representative. Therefore, with Jesus as their head, all of us Christians have Jesus’ righteousness and perfection imputed to us. Therefore, we are justified in the sight of God, and we have eternal life before him. You either have Adam or Jesus as your head, and only those who turn and follow Jesus are in Him. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *