Thankfully, when we meet Jehovah’s Witnesses and full-bore practicing charismatics, we don’t need to reinvent the wheel. The early church already addressed and refuted their progenitors, the Arians and the Montanists, respectively. While Jehovah’s Witnesses and charismatics are organized corporately as denominations and theologically, there is another ancient heresy that can appear today in much less organized forms.
Apollinarius of Laodicea was born in AD 315 and was a prominent teacher in the fourth century. However, what he taught eventually came to be known as Apollinarism, and the early church condemned it as well. Specifically, they condemned Apollinarism for denying the genuineness and completeness of Jesus’ humanity.
According to Apollinarius, Jesus Christ was divine in that the eternal Logos—Son of God—took the place of the rational soul in him. His body and animating soul (life force) were human, but his spirit (mind, consciousness) was not. It was divine.
The story of Christian Theology, page 189
[Apollinarius] explained that the divine Logos took the place of the human soul or spirit in Jesus Christ. In other words, Jesus had a human body in which dwelled a divine spirit.
Church History: From Christ to the Pre-Rreformation, page 258
If I asked the average American Christian today to explain how Jesus is both divine and human, I wouldn’t be surprised if he spouted Apollinarism. I wouldn’t consider him a heretic outright, simply because the average American Christian probably hasn’t put much thought into the subject. At face value, Apollinarism seems logical, but there are dire ramifications to saying Jesus was simply “God in a bod.” To deny Jesus’ human spirit is to deny Jesus’ humanity, and to deny Jesus’ humanity is to pervert substitutionary atonement, a fundamental tenet of the gospel. If Jesus wasn’t human in the same sense that we are (physical body and rational soul), then He could not be our representative on the cross and, consequently, could not be our Savior (cf. Hebrews 2:17). Consequently, the early church condemned Apollinarism.
[Apollinarius’] only error, according to the orthodox Alexandrians and even Gregory himself, was that he denied the human rational soul of Jesus Christ and replaced it in him with the Logos.
The Story of Christian Theology, page 207
Every heresy shall be anathematized, particularly that of the Eunomians or Eudoxians and that of the semi-Arians or Pneumatomachians and that of the Sabellians and that of the Marcellians and that of the Photinians and that of the Apollinarians.
Council of Constantinople (AD 381), canon 1
Those who turn from heresy to orthodoxy and to the portion of those who are being saved, we receive according to the following method and customs: Arians and Macedonians and Sabbatians and Novatians (who call themselves Cathari or Aristori) and Quarto-decimans or Tetradites and Apollinarians, we receive them upon their giving a written renunciation and anathematizing every heresy which is not in accordance with the holy, universal, and apostolic Church of God.
Council of Constantinople, canon 5
It’s a shame that we don’t put more emphasis on systematic theology and church history today in American churches. If we did teach systematic theology and church history, then Apollinarism wouldn’t rear its ugly head today. If we taught systematic theology, our churches would know not only why Jesus is a singular person with a divine nature with a divine spirit, but also why He has a human nature with a physical body and a rational spirit. Furthermore, if we taught church history, we would know how serious of an error Apollinarism is and how to handle it today. The early church correctly rejected Apollinarism, and in order to have the correct gospel today, we must do the same. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments