Church History: Marcionism

Church History: Marcionism

The first question we must ask when someone teaches us is this: Is what I’m hearing biblical? The second (much less important) question we must ask is this: Is what I’m hearing historical? Sometimes, the answer to the second question will be “yes,” but not in a good way. Sometimes, when people—like Jehovah’s Witnesses—teach from Scripture, their interpretation of Scripture mirrors an ancient heretic from church history. They’re merely parroting the same arguments as Arius, a fourth-century heretic. Another example of this concept is Marcion and what we now call “Marcionism.” Here is how one church history text describes Marcion’s theology:

There are two gods—the creator god and the redeemer god.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 86

Law and judgment belong to the creator, and redemption is the work of the Father.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 86

The Old Testament is the revelation of the creator. It predicts the Jewish Messiah. Jesus is not the fulfillment of the Old Testament. The Old Testament god worked evils, contradicted himself, and delighted in wars.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, pages 86-87

With how shockingly unbiblical Marcion’s teachings were, it’s unsurprising to read that the early church condemned him and his followers.

There is currently also [an epistle] to the Laodiceans and another to the Alexandrians, forged in Paul’s name to further the heresy of Marcion.

Muratorian Fragment (c. AD 170), lines 63-65

All of these heretics, ensnared by frauds of demons which they ought to have foreseen and guarded against, by their carelessness lost the name and worship of God, for when they are called Phrygians or Novatians or Valentinians or Marcionites or Anthropians or Arians or by any other name, they have ceased to be Christians, who have lost the name of Christ.

Lactantius (AD 250-325), Divine Institutes, book 4, chapter 30

These words are found in the third book of the work Against Heresies and again in the first book. [Irenaeus] speaks as follows concerning Cerdon, ‘A certain Cerdon, who had taken his system from the followers of Simon and had come to Rome under Hyginus, the ninth in the episcopal succession from the Apostles, taught that the God proclaimed by the Law and the Prophets was not the Father of our Lord, Jesus Christ, for the former was known, but the latter unknown, and the former was just, but the latter good. Marcion of Pontus succeeded Cerdon and developed his doctrine, uttering shameless blasphemies.’

Eusebius (AD 260-339), Church History, book 4, chapter 11, section 2

[Justin Martyr] speaks as follows, ‘There is a certain Marcion of Pontus, who is even now still teaching his followers to think that there is some other God greater than the Creator, and by the aid of the demons he has persuaded many of every ethnicity of men to utter blasphemy and to deny that the Maker of this universe is the Father of Christ and to confess that some other greater than He was the Creator. All who followed them are, as we have said, called “Christians,” just as the name of philosophy is given to philosophers, although they may have no doctrines in common.’ To this, he adds, ‘We have also written a work against all the heresies that have existed, which we will give you if you wish to read it.’

Eusebius (AD 260-339), Church History, book 4, chapter 11, section 9

My favorite response to Marcion definitely came from Polycarp of Smyrna in the second century.

Polycarp himself, when Marcion once met him and said, ‘Do you know us?’ replied, ‘I know the firstborn of Satan.’

Eusebius (AD 260-339), Church History, book 4, chapter 14, section 7

Clearly, the early church condemned Marcionism without hesitation. In fact, the condemnation was so universal that the early church didn’t even dedicate a council to the subject. His theology was that bad. However, while I don’t know of any Christians today who would agree with Marcion theologically, I could point to many, many, many, many, many neo-Marcionites who would agree with Marcion on a practical level.

He rejected the Old Testament as Scripture for the church.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 86

Paul was the only true Apostle. The Twelve ‘Judaized,’ so the Father had to call Paul to restore the gospel.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 87

When we understand the full teaching of Marcion, we can see that Marcionism is alive and well today in the form of mid-Acts dispensationalism, more properly known as hyper-dispensationalism. Dispensationalism is an orthodox belief. However, once someone becomes a hyper-dispensationalist, he has resurrected Marcion’s theology from the dead. Anyone who says the Old Testament has no moral authority over Christians under the New Covenant is a Marcionite in practice. Anyone who says Paul is the only Apostle for Gentile Christians is for all intents and purposes a Marcionite. Anyone who who says Paul’s gospel is different from Jesus’ gospel, Peter’s gospel, or the gospel of the Old Testament is a modern Marcionite. Marcionism thrives in the minds of those who see Scripture as a disjointed mishmash, rather than a unified and cohesive story culminating in the glorification of God in the Son’s redemptive death and resurrection. When we understand that there has only ever been one moral law and one saving gospel all throughout Scripture, we properly see Jesus Christ as the subject of every passage. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *