Sometimes, entire denominations resurrect ancient heresies, like Oneness Pentecostalism resurrecting Sabellianism, and Jehovah’s Witnesses resurrecting Arianism. Other times, ancient heresies survive in the background of churches, in the untrained and unlearned, like Apollinarism and Marcionism. We’re going to look at another one of those “behind-the-scenes” heresies that has survived for thousands of years, unfortunately. Specifically, let’s look at the ancient heresy of Macedonianism, also known as Pneumatomachianism, which is similar to Semi-Arianism and Spirit Christology/Binitarianism.
Each of these terms ends up teaching the same heresy: the Holy Spirit isn’t a divine person. The Macedonians/Pneumatomachians taught the Holy Spirit isn’t a divine person by saying He’s only a force. The Semi-Arians taught the Holy Spirit isn’t a divine person by saying He’s a created person. The Spirit Christologists/Binitarians taught the Holy Spirit isn’t a divine person by saying He’s the same person as the Son. Thankfully, I’m not aware of any Spirit Christologists/Binitarians today, and they were so rare in church history that they didn’t garner that much attention. However, the Macedonians and Semi-Arians did gain traction in the visible church about 1,700 years ago, and unfortunately, people regurgitate their teachings today. First, we must understand what exactly they taught.
The Holy Spirit is the most honorable of all the beings brought into existence through brought into the Word, the chief in rank of all beings originated by the Father through Christ.
Origen of Alexandria (AD 185-254), Commentary on John book 2, chapter 10, paragraph 75
This is just one example of how ancient “Christians” denied the deity of the Holy Spirit. Just as the Arians taught the Word was the first person created by the Father, so too did the Semi-Arians teach that the Spirit was the first person created by the Father and the Word. This teaching became popular during the life of Macedonius of Constantinople, who lived in the first half of the fourth century. In fact, he became so prominent that those who denied the deity of the Holy Spirit became known as the Macedonians, after Macedonius before them. Unfortunately, there are many unwitting Macedonians today, who deny the deity of the Spirit either by saying He’s a created person, or by saying He’s not a person, but rather a force.
According to Ligonier’s “The State of Theology Survey” in 2020, of the over 3,000 participants who self-identify as Christians and completed the survey, 32% of them strongly agreed with the statement, “The Holy Spirit is a force, but is not a personal being.” Another 27% somewhat agreed with this statement, and 17% were unsure. That means 59% of professing Christians who completed this survey believe some form of Macedonianism—that the Holy Spirit isn’t a divine person—and another 17% are on the fence. Only 24%—less than a quarter—agreed or strongly agreed that the Holy Spirit is a divine, personal being. Unfortunately, Macedonianism is alive and well today in churches, and I don’t think it’s a result of false teachers in our congregations teaching this ancient heresy. I think it’s a result of pastors not teaching their congregations good theology, leaving the laypeople to their own devices. If pastors taught theology and church history, this belief that denies the Holy Spirit’s personhood and divinity would be quashed quickly, just like it was in the ancient church. After rising to prominence in the first half of the fourth century, the early church anathematized those who denied the Holy Spirit’s personhood and divinity by the end of the fourth century,
Every heresy shall be anathematized, particularly that of the Eunomians or Eudoxians and that of the Semi-Arians or Pneumatomachians and that of the Sabellians and that of the Marcellians and that of the Photinians and that of the Apollinarians.
Council of Constantinople (AD 381), canon 1
Those who turn from heresy to orthodoxy and to the portion of those who are being saved, we receive according to the fellow method and customs: Arians and Macedonians and Novatians (who call themselves Cathari or Aristori) and Quarto-decimans or Tetradites or Apollinarians, we receive upon their giving a written renunciation and anathematization of every heresy which is not in accordance with the holy, universal, and apostolic Church of God.
Council of constantinople, canon 5
The early church rightfully affirmed the Trinity and drafted the Athanasian Creed to settle the matter once for all, that the Father and the Son and the Spirit are all coequal, coeternal, and coexistent as three distinct divine persons. In doing so, they anathematized the Macedonians, who denied the deity of the Holy Spirit.
Unfortunately, studies have found that over half of professing Christians in America deny the deity of the Holy Spirit, whether knowingly or unknowingly. If we taught our congregations and children church history—and more importantly, Scripture—the ancient heresy of Macedonianism would not be allowed to thrive in our churches. The Holy Spirit is truly God. He is the third person of the Trinity. He is of the same divine essence as the Father and the Son. He is equal and eternal with them and has coexisted as a person—not a force—with them since before all time. Without the divine Spirit, there is no salvation, because He is the one who reveals the Son to the lost and causes salvation in the heart of the sinner, which makes this topic of utmost importance. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments