Church History: Immortality and Eternal Conscious Torment, Part 3

Church History: Immortality and Eternal Conscious Torment, Part 3

As we’ve seen, the early church fathers either used biblical, albeit debatable, language concerning the final judgment of the wicked, or they explicitly taught eternal conscious torment. It wasn’t until a man named Arnobius in the fourth century that anyone who claimed to be a Christian explicitly taught annihilationism. However, Arnobius was anything but an actual Christian. After all, he affirmed many heretical doctrines.

He seemed at least sympathetic toward the concept of reincarnation and taught the pre-existence of souls:

If that too, which is said in the more hidden mysteries, is true, that the souls of wicked men, upon leaving their human bodies, pass into cattle and other creatures, it is even more clearly shown that we are allied to them [animals] and not separated by any great interval, since it is on the same ground that both we and they are said to be living creatures and to act as such.

Arnobius (4th century), Against the Heathen, book 2, section 16

Let us hear from you how you say that the soul, upon being enwrapped in an earthly body, has no recollection of the past. While, after being actually placed in the body itself and rendered almost senseless by union with it, it holds tenaciously and faithfully the things which many years before, eighty if you choose to say so or even more, it either did or suffered or said or heard, for if, through being hampered by the body, it does not remember those things which it knew long ago and before it came into this world, there is more reason that it should forget those things which it has done from time to time since being shut up in the body than those which it did before entering it, while not yet connected with men.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 28

He also taught polytheism, that there are other legitimate lesser deities than the God of the Bible.

If we all agree that there is one Father of all, who alone is immortal and unbegotten, and if nothing at all is found before Him which could be named, then it follows as a consequence that all these whom the imagination of men believes to be gods have either been begotten by Him or produced at His bidding. Are they produced and begotten? They are also later in order and time.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 35

The gods are said to be immortal, not by nature, but by the good will and favor of God, their Father. In the same way, then, in which the boon of immortality is God’s gift to these who were assuredly produced will He design to confer eternal life upon souls also, although death seems to cut them off and blot them out of existence in utter annihilation.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 36

So, too, some utterly deny the existence of the gods. Others say that they are lost in doubt as to whether they exist anywhere. Others, however, say that they do exist, but do not trouble themselves about human things. Nay, others maintain that they both take part in the affairs of men and guide the course of earthly events. While, then, this is the case, and it cannot but be that only one of all these opinions is true, they all nevertheless make use of arguments in striving with each other—and not one of them is without something plausible to say, whether in affirming his own view or objecting to the opinions of others.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, sections 56-57

Arnobius was also an unashamed Gnostic, teaching that God did not create humanity.

If by chance you knew it not, and because of its novelty it was unknown to you before, now, though late, receive and learn from Him who knows and has made it known, Christ, that souls are not the children of the Supreme Ruler and did not begin to be self-conscious and to be spoken of in their own special character after being created by Him. Rather, some other is their parent, far enough removed from the Chief in rank and power, of His court.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 36

However, you say, ‘If God is not the parent and the father of souls, then by what sire have they been begotten, and how have they been produced?’ If you wish to hear unvarnished statements not spun out with vain ostentation of words, we, too, admit that we are ignorant of this and do not know it. We hold that to know so great a matter is not only beyond the reach of our weakness and frailty, but also of all the powers which are in the world and which have usurped the place of deities in man’s belief. But are we bound to show whose they are because we deny that they [souls] are God’s? That by no means follows necessarily.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 47

Here, too, in like manner, when we deny that souls are the offspring of God Supreme, it does not necessarily follow that we are bound to declare from what parent they have sprung and by what cause they have been produced.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 48

You laugh at our reply, because, while we deny that souls are of Royal descent, we do not, on the other hand, say in turn from what causes and beginnings they have sprung. But what kind of crime is it either to be ignorant of anything, or to confess quite openly that you do not know that of which you are ignorant?

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 51

Since this, then, is the case, we do nothing out of place or are foolish in believing that the souls of men are of a neutral character, inasmuch as they have been produced by secondary beings, made subject to the law of death and are of little strength and are perishable.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 53

Do we alone not know who is the creator, who the former of souls is, what cause fashioned man, whence ill have broken forth, or why the Supreme Ruler allows them both to exist and be perpetrated, and does not drive them from the world?

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 58

‘What business of yours is it,‘ He says, ‘to examine to inquire who made man, what is the origin of souls, who devised the causes of ills?’

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 61

Can you, I say, know that which could have been learned through Christ’s teaching, whether the ages are unlimited in number or not since the human race began to be on the earth, when souls were first bound to bodies, who contrived that binding, nay, rather, who formed man himself? … Lay aside these cares, and abandon questions to which you can find no answer.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 63

Arnobius was a Pelagian, denying original sin by teaching that souls are by nature neutral.

‘But,’ say my opponents, ‘if souls are mortal and of neutral character, then how can they from their neutral properties become immortal?’

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 35

Not only was Arnobius a Pelagian for denying original sin, he was also a Pelagian by teaching that people can be good, even perfect, of their own libertarian free will. In fact, he would’ve considered what Augustine, John Calvin, and the Reformers taught to be blasphemy.

[Condemning predestination] The cause of all [sin] is none other than Himself since He allowed them [Adam and Eve] to have freedom to wander, whom He foresaw would not abide by their state of innocence. Thus, it is brought about that it does not matter whether they [Adam and Eve] came [to eat the fruit] of their own accord or obeyed His command, since in not preventing what should have been prevented, by His inaction He made the guilt His own and permitted it before it was done by neglecting to withhold them from action.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 44

Let this belief, so monstrous and impious, be put far from us, that God, who preserves all things, the Origin of the virtues and Chief in benevolence, and to exalt Him with human praise, most wise, just, making all things perfect, and that permanently, either made anything which was imperfect and not quite correct, or was the cause of misery or danger to any being, or arranged, commanded, and enjoined the very acts in which man’s life is passed and employed to flow from His arrangement. These things are unworthy of Him and weaken the force of His greatness. So far from His being believed to be their author, whoever imagines that man is sprung from Him is guilty of blasphemous impiety.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 46

‘But,’ you will say, ‘there are good men also in the world—wise, upright, and of faultless and pure morals.’ We raise no question as to whether there ever were any such, in whom this very integrity which is spoken of was in nothing imperfect. Even if they, who are very honorable and have been worthy of praise, have reached the utmost height of perfection, and if their life has never wavered and sunk into sin, yet we would have you tell us how many there are or have been.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 49

‘Can, then, anything be made,’ someone will say, ‘without God’s will?’ We must consider carefully and examine with no little pains and test, while we think that we are honoring God by such a question, we fall into the opposite sin, doing despite to His supreme majesty. In what way? On what ground? Because, if all things are brought about by His will, and if nothing in the world can either succeed or fail contrary to His pleasure, it follows of necessity that it should be understood that all evils, too, arise by His will.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 54

‘To all,’ He says, ‘the fountain of life is open, and no one is hindered or kept back from drinking.’ If you are so fastidious as to spurn the kindly offered gift, nay, more, if your wisdom is so great that you term those things which are offered by Christ ridiculous and absurd, why should He keep on inviting you, while His only duty is to make the enjoyment of His bounty depend upon your own free choice? Plato say, ‘God does not cause anyone to choose his lot in life, nor can another’s choice be rightly attributed to anyone, since freedom of choice was put in His power who made it.’ Must you be even implored to deign to accept the gift of salvation from God, and must God’s gracious mercy be poured into your bosom while you reject it with disdain and flee from it? Do you choose to take what is offered and turn it to your own advantage? You will in that case have consulted your own interests. Do you reject with disdain, lightly esteem, and despise it? You will in this case have robbed yourself of the benefit of the gift. God compels no one and terrifies no one with overpowering fear.

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 64

‘Nay,’ my opponent says, ‘if God is powerful, merciful, and willing to save us, then let Him change our dispositions and compel us to trust in His promises.’ This, then, is violence, not kindness nor the bounty of the Supreme God, but a childish and vain strife in seeking to get the mastery, for what is so unjust as to force men who are reluctant and unwilling, to reverse their inclinations, to impress forcibly on their minds what they are unwilling to receive and shrink from, to injure before benefiting, and to bring another way of thinking and feeling by taking away the former?

Arnobius, Against the Heathen, book 2, section 65

It’s no coincidence that the first “Christian” to teach annihilationism also taught a vast array of other heresies. It’s a common trend. Heretics often delve into annihilationism, or annihilationists delve into other heresies. It’s evidence that heresy breeds more heresy. Jesus Christ is central to all doctrine, and any misunderstanding concerning Christ and what He saves us from starts a Domino effect for the rest of our doctrine. He’s that central. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *