Yesterday, we saw the resounding testimony in favor of eternal conscious torment from the early church fathers who spoke clearly on the subject. However, there are more ambiguous quotes from early church fathers as well that we must address.
Therefore, let us not be insensible to His kindness, for were He to reward us according to our works, we would cease to be.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to the Magnesians, chapter 10
While the phrase “cease to be” might seem unambiguous to the annihilationist, the phrase is much more ambiguous than one might realize. The phrase ouketi esmen in Ignatius’ Letter to the Magnesians is best translated, “We are undone” or “we are lost,” because while it does literally mean “We are not,” Jerry Shepherd identifies this phrase as a euphemism for despair and ruin, not cessation of existence, in light of pages 208-209 in Apostolic Fathers: Greek Texts and English Translations. Therefore, this is not an affirmation of annihilationism, and neither is Ignatius’ use of the phrase “immortality.”
For this end did the Lord allow the ointment to be poured upon His head, so that He might breathe immortality into His Church.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to the Ephesians, book 17
The beloved Prophets announced Him [Jesus Christ], but the gospel is the perfection of immortality.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to the Philadelphians, chapter 9
Be sober as an athlete of God. The prize set before you is immortality and eternal life, of which you are also persuaded.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to Polycarp, chapter 2
As we saw yesterday, the opposite of “immortality” in the minds of the church fathers was not death and annihilation, but rather eternal suffering. “Immortality” was an experiential, not existential, word to them. This is evidenced by Ignatius’ use of the word “immortality” in reference to the Lord’s Supper and submission to church leadership.
Be united with your bishop and those that preside over you [the elders], as a type and evidence of your immortality.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to the Magnesians, chapter 6
Obey the bishop and the elders with an undivided mind, breaking one and the same bread, which is the medicine of immortality and the antidote to prevent us from dying, but that we should live forever in Jesus Christ.
Ignatius (2nd century), Letter to the Ephesians, chapter 20
Clearly, no one, not even annihilationists think that partaking of the Lord’s Supper and submitting to the church’s leadership is the means of becoming existentially immortal. Therefore, we can deduce that “immortality” in the mind of Ignatius is not an existential reality, but rather an experiential reality, just like the rest of the church fathers. Immortality describes your relationship with God (which is strengthened by submitting to your leaders in the church and partaking of the Lord’s Supper), not whether you are allowed to continue to exist after the final judgment. This is consistent with the biblical use of the phrase “eternal life,” especially in Johannine literature.
The same is true of Clement of Rome, who often uses more ambiguous, biblical lingo to describe the wicked’s experience in the future. For example:
Let us be good one towards another according to the compassion and sweetness of Him that made us, for it is written, ‘The good shall be dwellers in the land, and the innocent shall be left on it. However, they that transgress shall be destroyed utterly from it.’
Clement (1st century), 1 Clement 14:3-4
Whenever you read the church fathers, you need to not read your theology into their writings. We must not import a whole slew of theological definitions into words like “destroy,” which again can experientially mean “ruin,” rather than existential cessation of existence. This concept is important when reading another early letter from the church, the Epistle of Barnabas.
The way of the Black One is crooked and full of a curse, for it is a way of eternal death with punishment wherein are the things that destroy men’s souls—idolatry, boldness, exhalation of power, hypocrisy, doubleness of heart, adultery, murder, plundering, pride, transgression, treachery, malice, stubbornness, witchcraft, magic, covetousness, and absence of the fear of God.
Epistle of barnabas (1st-2nd century) 20:1
Notice the tenses of the verbs used by Barnabas or pseudo-Barnabas. The list of sins are “the things that destroy [present tense] men’s souls.” Obviously, “destroy” cannot refer to cessation of existence in this context. Otherwise, our sins would have destroyed our souls from existence in the present, an absurd notion. Clearly, to Barnabas/pseudo-Barnabas, the word “destroy” is experiential, not existential. Our sins ruin us spiritually speaking in the present, not annihilate us. Since the destruction/ruin of our souls is paralleled with the eternal death of the wicked at the final judgment, it is best to see “eternal death” as an experiential phrase as well.
To the early church fathers, words like “immortal,” “death,” “eternal life,” and “destruction” did not carry annihilationist definitions. These words are experiential, not existential. Immortality and eternal life refer to bliss and harmony with God. Death and destruction refer to ruin and torment from God. This is an especially sound conclusion in light of yesterday’s quotes, which often contrasted immortality and eternal life with eternal conscious torment, not annihilation. Let this be a lesson to not ever import our theology into another’s words, whether we’re reading Scripture, church history, or anything else. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments