Church History: Immortality and Eternal Conscious Torment

Church History: Immortality and Eternal Conscious Torment

Yesterday, I had the privilege of debating whether or not annihilationism (the belief that at the final judgment, the wicked will be killed and annihilated from existence forever) is heresy. In that debate, me and my opponent threw around quotes from the church fathers, but we didn’t have time to really delve into their quotes in context. That’s what I hope to do here and now.

The fact of the matter is, no one clearly taught annihilationism in the Church until the polytheistic Pelagian Gnostic, Arnobius, in the 4th century. That being said, the early church affirmed both that the soul is immortal and can never cease to exist, and that God will torment the wicked forever in hell.

All souls are immortal, even those of the wicked, for whom it would be better that they were not deathless, for punished with endless vengeance of quenchless fire and not dying, it is impossible for them to have a period put to their misery.

Clement of Rome (1st century) or Clement of Alexandria (2nd century), depending to whom you ascribe Fragments, collection 6, fragment 2

Clearly, this is an affirmation of eternal conscious torment. Clement even recognized that annihilationism would be better for the wicked than what they will really experience: eternal conscious torment.

He shall raise the bodies of all men who have lived and clothe those of the worthy with immortality and shall send those of the wicked, endured with eternal sensibility, into everlasting fire with the wicked devils.

Justin Martyr (2nd century), First Apology, chapter 52

This is clearly an affirmation of eternal conscious torment. The wicked are able to sense forever the fire, which will torment them and the demons forever. It’s also worth noting that the opposite of “immortality” in Justin Martyr’s mind isn’t death and annihilation, but rather “eternal sensibility in everlasting fire.”

We are persuaded that when we are removed from the present life, we will live another life better than the present one. … If they fall with the rest, they will endure a worse life, one in fire, for God has not made us as sheep or beasts of burden, who are mere byproducts, for animals perish and are annihilated.

Athenagoras (2nd century), Apology, chapter 31

Athenagoras went out of his way to deny that humans are annihilated by contrasting us with animals. Animals cease to exist at death, but humans will live forever, either in a “better life” or in a “worse life, one in fire,” which is clearly an affirmation of eternal conscious torment.

They say of things, which it is manifest to all, do remain immortal, such as the spirit and the soul and other things, that they are quickened by the Father.

Irenaeus (2nd century), Against Heresies, book 5, chapter 4, section 1

What then are mortal bodies? Can they be souls? No, for souls are incorporeal when put in comparison to mortal bodies, for God ‘breathed into the face of man the breath of life, and man became a living soul.’ Now, the breath of life is an incorporeal thing. Certainly, they cannot maintain that the very breath of life is mortal. Therefore, David says, ‘My soul also shall live to Him,’ just as if its substance were immortal.

Irenaeus (2nd century), Against Heresies, book 5, chapter 7, section 1

Paul says that ‘mortality may be swallowed up of life. He who has perfected us for this very thing is God, who also has given us the earnest of the Spirit.’ He uses these words most manifestly in reference to the flesh, for the soul is not mortal, neither is the spirit.

Irenaeus (2nd century), Against Heresies, book 5, chapter 17, section 3

Irenaeus clearly affirmed the immortality of the soul and said that the soul cannot die, unlike the body. This immediately precludes him from being an annihilationist since annihilationists do believe the soul can die like the body. Also, notice that Irenaeus argued in the final quotation that God will make bodies immortal at the resurrection since the soul has always been immortal. If the bodies of the resurrected (righteous or wicked) become immortal at the resurrection in the last day—as Irenaeus taught—then clearly this is a denial of annihilationism.

[God is] about to at the end of all to judge His worshipers to everlasting life and the wicked to the doom of fire at once without ending and without break, raising up again all the dead from the beginning, reforming and renewing them with the object of awarding either recompense.

Tertullian (2nd century), Apology, chapter 18

Therefore, after this there is neither death nor repeated resurrections, but we shall be the same that we are now and still unchanged—the servants of God, ever with God, clothed upon with the proper substance of eternity. However, the profane and all who are not true worshipers of God, in like manner shall be consigned to the punishment of everlasting fire—that fire which, from its very nature indeed, directly ministers to their incorruptibility.

Tertullian (2nd century), Apology, chapter 48

Tertullian clearly taught eternal conscious torment, but it’s noteworthy that the opposite of “everlasting life” and “the proper substance of eternity” is not death and annihilation, but rather “punishment of everlasting fire” that “ministers to their incorruptibility.”

Being present at His judicial decision, all, both men and angels and demons, shall utter one voice, saying, ‘Righteous is Your judgment!’ Of which voice the justification will be seen in the awarding to each what is just since to those who have done well shall be assigned righteously eternal bliss, and to lovers of iniquity shall be given eternal punishment. The fire which is uniquely capable and without end awaits these latter, and a certain fiery worm which does not waste the body, but continues bursting forth from the body with unending pain. No sleep will give them rest. No night will soothe them. No death will deliver them from punishment.

Hippolytus (3rd century), Against Plato, section 3

Hippolytus explicitly said that the final judgment is not “death,” in the physical and annihilationist sense, but rather eternal conscious torment.

I am not ignorant that many, in the consciousness of what they deserve, rather desire than believe that they shall be nothing after death, for they would prefer to be altogether extinguished rather than be restored for the purpose of punishment. … There is neither measure nor termination of these torments. There, the intelligent fire burns the limbs and restores them, feeds on them and nourishes them, just as the fires of the thunderbolts strike upon the bodies and do not consume them.

Felix Municius (3rd century), Octavius, chapters 34-35

Felix is a perfect referent for the discussion of annihilationism. He acknowledges that annihilation would be a lot more pleasant than eternal conscious torment, but nevertheless, he affirmed eternal conscious torment.

An ever-burning Gehenna and a punishment with living flames will burn up the condemned, nor will there be any source whence at any time they may have either respite or end to their torments. Souls with their bodies will be reserved in infinite tortures for suffering.

Cyprian (3rd century), To Demetrian, paragraph 24

O what and how great will that day be at its coming, beloved brethren, when the Lord shall begin to count up His people and to recognize the deservings of each one by the inspection of His divine knowledge, to send the guilty to Gehenna and to set on fire our persecutors with the perpetual burning of a penal fire, but to pay us the reward of our faith and devotion!

Cyprian (3rd century), Epistle 55, paragraph 10

Cyprian was a staunch teacher of eternal conscious torment.

We add a further point to complete our demonstration for the benefit of those who shamelessly take refuge in denial of reason. How is it, that whereas the body is mortal by nature, man reasons on the things of immortality and often, where virtue demands it, courts death? Or how, since the body lasts but for a time, does man imagine of things eternal, so as to despise what lies before him and desire what is beyond? The body could not have such thoughts about itself spontaneously, nor could it think upon what is external to itself, for it is mortal and lasts but for a time. It follows that that which thinks what is opposed to the body and against its nature must be distinct in kind. What then can this be, save a rational and immortal soul?

Athanasius (4th century), Against the Heathen, part 1, section 32

That the soul is made immortal is a further point in the Church’s teaching which you must know, to show how idols are overthrown. But, we shall more directly arrive at a knowledge of this from what we know about the body and from the difference between the body and soul, for if our argument has proved [the soul] to be distinct from the body, while the body is by nature mortal, then it follows that the soul is immortal because it is not like t he body.

Athanasius (4th century), Against the Heathen, part 1, section 33

According to Athanasius, the immortality of the soul and its eternal nature are both in contrast to the body’s mortal and temporary nature. Athanasius explicitly said we humans can only think of eternal things because we have eternal souls, and having an eternal soul is antithetical to annihilationism.

The sacred writings inform us in what manner the wicked are to undergo punishment. Because they have committed sins in their bodies, they will again be clothed with flesh, so that they may make atonement in their bodies. Yet, it will be that flesh with which clothed man, like this our earthly body, but indestructible and abiding forever, so that it may be able to hold out against tortures and everlasting fire. … The same divine fire, therefore, with one and the same force and power, will both burn the wicked and will form them again and will replace as much as it shall consume of their bodies and will supply itself with eternal nourishment. … Then, they whose piety shall have been approved of will receive the reward of immortality, but they whose sins and crimes shall have been brought to light will not rise again, but will be hidden in the same darkness with the wicked, being destined to certain punishment.

Lactantius (4th century), Divine Institutes, book 7, chapter 21

Lactantius not only affirmed eternal conscious torment, but also, yet another church father contrasted “immortality” with “darkness” and “punishment” and “tortures” and “everlasting fire,” not death and annihilation.

We shall be raised, therefore, all with our bodies eternal, but not all with bodies alike, for if a man is righteous, then he will receive a heavenly body, so that he may be able to worthily hold conversation with angels, but if a man is a sinner, then he shall receive an eternal body fitted to endure the penalties of sins, so that he may burn eternally in fire nor ever be consumed.

Cyril of Jerusalem (4th century), Catechetical Lectures, lecture 18, paragraph 19

Yet again, another church father explicitly affirmed eternal conscious torment. Are you noticing a trend? The church fathers who spoke clearly on this subject (Clement of Rome/Alexandria, Justin Martyr, Athenagoras, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Hippolytus, Felix, Cyprian, Athanasius, Lactantius, and Cyril) all affirmed the immortality and eternality of human souls, the eternality of the resurrected wicked’s bodies, and eternal conscious torment. Many of them also demonstrated that the opposite of “immortality” and “eternal life” was not “death” and “annihilation” in their minds, but rather “punishment” and “torment” and “fire.” This will be important when we look at some of the more debatable church fathers, who used more ambiguous lingo, tomorrow. The fact remains, however, that the clear historical teaching of the church fathers (and all of church history) is eternal conscious torment. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *