“Theodicy” is a compound word meaning, “the justification of God,” from “theos” and “dikaioō.” Specifically, “theodicy” addresses what is often called “the problem of evil.” If you’ve ever interacted with an atheist, you’ve probably heard the argument, which goes something like this: “If God is all-powerful and all-loving, then He would not allow evil to happen. Since evil happens, God must be too weak to prevent evil, too cruel to prevent evil, or non-existent.” This argument assumes that if God the Father had His way, then evil would never have occurred. However, this is a false assumption. Here is how Scripture justifies God with regard to the problem of evil: God the Father intends for sin to happen for good purposes, and therefore, He is not evil, but good.
The usual explanation for the problem of evil is appealing to libertarian free will, but this explanation creates more problems than it solves. Usually, when discussing theodicy, Christians say something along these lines, “God gave us free will, so when evil happens, it’s our fault, not His. Free will and the possibility of evil are necessary realities in order for love to be genuine. Therefore, God is all-powerful and all-loving, but because He is so loving, He gave us free will, which resulted in evil entering this world when Adam and Eve sinned.” I’ve heard that explanation multiple times from multiple sources, but again, this theodicy creates more problems than it solves.
First, if the possibility of sin and libertarian free will are necessary prerequisites for love to be genuine, then apparently Christians’ love for God in eternity will not be genuine. After all, once glorified, Christians will not be able to sin anymore. Our wills won’t be “free,” if “free” means able to sin. This, of course, is absurd. Christians’ love for God in eternity won’t be less genuine because they can’t sin. Their love for God will be more genuine because they can’t sin. The possibility of sin and libertarian free will are not necessary prerequisites for genuine love. Therefore, that argument for theodicy frankly falls flat on its face.
Second, even if libertarian free will and the possibility of sin are necessary prerequisites to genuine love, that doesn’t explain why God gave humanity the opportunity to sin against Him in the first place. Why did God create the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? Would Adam and Eve’s love for God have been less genuine if that tree didn’t exist? Also, why did God allow Satan to tempt Adam and Eve? Furthermore, why didn’t God intervene and tell Adam and Eve to not listen to Satan? If the argument that God didn’t want sin to happen, but it was a necessary possibility for Adam and Eve’s love to be genuine, is true, then why didn’t God do more to prevent them from sinning? If God didn’t want evil to enter the world, as the free will theodicy posits, then God did a poor job of preventing it. After all, He created the means of sinning (the tree of the knowledge of good and evil), He allowed the means of sinning (temptation from Satan), and He did nothing to discourage sin in the moment of Adam and Eve’s temptation.
Third, we know that God can prevent people from sinning. The free will theodicy proposes that God is a gentlemen who will not violate your free will. However, this is not the case in Scripture. God does actively prevent people from sinning. A good example is Abimelech.
Then, God said to [Abimelech] in the dream, ‘Yes, I know that you have done this in the integrity of your heart, and it was I who kept you from sinning against Me. Therefore, I did not let you touch her.’
Genesis 20:6
If God can prevent a fallen man like Abimelech from sinning, then how much more could He have prevented non-fallen people like Adam and Eve from sinning? God can and does interfere with people’s wills, but even if He couldn’t, couldn’t God have prevented Adam and Even without even interfering with their wills? Couldn’t God have broken Adam and Eve’s arms when they tried to lift the fruit to their mouths? After all, God just yoinked a rib out of Adam to make Eve, so I think He can do whatever He wants with their bones. Of course, I’m being facetious. These three facts (that the possibility of sin and libertarian free will are not prerequisites to genuine love, that God created the means of sin in the Garden of Eden, and that God can prevent sin from occurring but chose not to in the Garden of Eden) demonstrate that the free will theodicy theory falls short. Thankfully, there is a biblical theodicy, which is what I said above. God the Father is just in the existence of sin because He predestined it to occur for good purposes.
We saw last week that God predestined many (in fact, all) sins that occur. We looked at three biblical examples: Joseph’s brothers selling Joseph into slavery, Assyria slaughtering Judah, and Herod and Pilate and the Romans and the Jews murdering Jesus. God predestined all of those sinful actions, but He predestined them for good purposes. It was good to predestine Joseph’s brothers to sell Joseph into slavery, because that was the means by which God spared the nation of Israel from starvation. It was good to predestine Assyria to slaughter Judah, because that was the means by which God brought revival on the nation of Israel. It was good to predestine Herod, Pilate, the Romans, and the Jews to murder Jesus, because that was the means by which God atoned for sin and redeemed His people. In light of this, the correct theodicy is that God is sovereign, so evil exists because He has a good purpose for it. That is true for Adam and Eve’s sin as well.
While God is omnipotent, He is also logical. He cannot create a square circle, because that is logically absurd. Likewise, He can’t create a rock so big that He can’t move it. God’s logical nature is a self-restraint for what He can and cannot do, just as His truthful nature is a self-restraint that prevents Him from lying (cf. Titus 1:2). Therefore, logically, God had two options in eternity past. He could create, or He could not create. God did what was wise by creating a creation, especially Adam and Eve, to appreciate His glory. At that point, God logically had two options. He could never allow sin to happen (at which point no one would see demonstrations of His grace, mercy, justice, and wrath, all of which require sin as a prerequisite), or He could allow sin to happen. God did what was wise and allowed sin to happen in order to demonstrate His attributes. At that point, God logically had three options. He could save no one (at which point no one would see demonstrations of His grace, mercy, and love), He could save everyone (at which point, no one would see demonstrations of His justice, wrath, and power), or He could save some (at which point, all of His attributes would be on display). God did what was wise and predestined to save many people, but not all. Lest the reader decry unfairness and injustice in God, let’s all look at Paul’s preemptive argument in Romans 9.
You will say to me then, ‘Why does [God] still find fault? Who can resist His will?’ O man, who are you to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, ‘Why have you made me like this?’ Has the potter no right over the clay to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use? What if God, desiring to show His wrath and to make His power known, has endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, in order to make known the riches of His glory for vessels of mercy, which He has prepared beforehand for glory—even us whom He has called, not from the Jews only, but also from the Gentiles?
Romans 9:19-24
Romans 9 puts theodicy on display. Why did God allow evil to happen? He allowed Adam and Eve to sin because that was the means by which He could lavish grace and love and mercy on vessels of mercy, on some people, but it was also the means by which He could pour out His wrath and power and justice on vessels of wrath, on the rest. That is how God the Father glorifies Himself and the rest of the Trinity. His plan is perfectly wise and holy, because it accomplishes the greatest good.
The greatest good is not the prevention of evil. The greatest good is the glorification of God. God is a wise God, and therefore, He must do the wisest thing possible. The wisest thing God can do is not create a greenhouse of perfection for His creatures. In the same way it would be absurd for a human to devote his entire life to creating a greenhouse of perfection for a colony of ants in an attempt to make sure that no predators ever come their way or to make sure they have all of their needs met or to make sure no rain ever washes away their colony, so too would it be absurd for God to devote His entire existence to creating a greenhouse of perfection for His creatures at the expense of His own glory. God is most glorified when all of His attributes are on display, and therefore, He has chosen out of wisdom, not out of necessity, to have evil happen. It is a means of His own self-glorification, and lest anyone accuse God of self-centeredness, I would ask, “Who should God devote His efforts to glorifying? You?” Of course not. It is good that God the Father has planned everything that occurs to glorify Himself, the Son, and the Spirit, because they alone are deserving of such honor.
I would be remiss if I did not mention that God’s purpose for evil is not just for His own glory, but also for His people’s own good. We are given a hopeful promise in Romans 8:28 to that end.
We know that all things work together for good for those who love God, for those who are called according to His purpose.
Romans 8:28
For God’s elect, for those whom He has called and justified, everything is for our good, even evil. When someone sins against you, God planned it for your good and His glory. If someone murders your spouse, then it happened because God planned it for your good and His glory. If a drunk runs a red light and kills your child, then it happened because God planned it for your good and His glory. If you lose your job because of identity politics and critical race theory, then it happened because God planned it for your good and His glory. Long before Paul ever wrote Romans 8:28, Job understood this truth.
[Job] said, ‘Naked I came from my mother’s womb, and naked shall I return. Yahweh gave, and Yahweh has taken away. Blessed be the name of Yahweh.’ In all this, Job did not sin or charge God with wrong.
Job 1:21-22
[Job] said to [his wife], ‘You speak as one of the foolish women would speak. Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?’ In all this, Job did not sin with his lips.
Job 2:10
Theodicy is a serious topic, but it is a topic that every Christian must be prepared to address. Here is how God is justified in the existence of evil: God the Father predestined sin to occur because it is the means by which He glorifies Himself and His attributes, and He predestined sin to occur because it is always for the good of His people. That answer glorifies God far more than any appeal to libertarian free will, and it magnifies the Father’s name to its rightful place, above all others. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments