Church History: Marcionism

Church History: Marcionism

We often look at the past with rose-colored glasses. That’s true of society and the Church. We assume things were better back in the 50s in America, and we assume things were better back in the first century of the Church. However, every era has its issues, and the first century of the Church is no different. One of the shockingly prominent errors of the early Church is something called Marcionism.

Marcion of Sinope was born in approximately AD 85 and died around AD 160. He was the originator of the heresy known as Marcionism, and despite his teachings being outlandish, he gained a surprising amount of traction in the Church. One of his most outlandish teachings is that there are two Gods—the evil god of the Old Testament, and the gracious God of the New Testament.

There are two gods—the Creator and the Redeemer.

Church History: From Christ to Pre-Reformation, page 86

Law and judgment belong to the Creator, and redemption is the work of the Father.

CHURCH HISTORY: FROM CHRIST TO PRE-REFORMATION, PAGE 86

The Old Testament is the revelation of the Creator. It predicts the Jewish Messiah. Jesus is not the fulfiller of the Old Testament. The Old Testament god worked evils, contradicted himself, and delighted in wars.

CHURCH HISTORY: FROM CHRIST TO PRE-REFORMATION, PAGEs 86-87

Marcion’s duotheism might sound absurd, but many joined his cause until he was rightfully condemned as a heretic by the early Church. Furthermore, while I’m not aware of anyone who would call himself a Marcionite, there are many practical Marcionites today, because Marcion rejected the Old Testament as authoritative Scripture for the Church.

[Marcion] rejected the Old Testament as Scripture for the Church.

CHURCH HISTORY: FROM CHRIST TO PRE-REFORMATION, PAGE 86

There are many today who are practical Marcionites. While they wouldn’t say that the Old Testament is evil and pertaining to a different god, they practically treat the Old Testament the same way as Marcion. This is especially true of New Covenant Theology, which is a theological system that doesn’t see the Law of Moses as a morally binding code of ethics for the Church today. However, Marcion didn’t just belittle the practicality of the Old Testament. He also belittled select sections of the New.

[Marcion] issued a New Testament consisting of edited versions of the Gospel of Luke and ten Pauline epistles, lacking the pastoral epistles. He omitted or even changed verses, often on a dogmatic basis.

CHURCH HISTORY: FROM CHRIST TO PRE-REFORMATION, PAGE 86

Paul was the only true Apostle. The Twelve ‘Judaized,’ so the Father had to call Paul to restore the true gospel.

CHURCH HISTORY: FROM CHRIST TO PRE-REFORMATION, PAGE 87

Again, there are many today who are practical Marcionites. Hyper-dispensationalists are a small group who believe that the Church didn’t begin until Acts 9 with Paul, the gospel of Peter is a gospel of works, Paul alone taught a gospel of grace, and Paul alone is the Apostle of the Gentile Church. That’s a perfect parallel to what Marcion taught concerning the New Testament Church, just repackaged and toned down slightly.

There really is nothing new under the sun. Satan can repackage error, but there are only so many errors that he can throw at the wall and hope will stick. One such error is Marcionism. The more we study church history, the more equipped we are to deal with errors like Marcionism. There has only ever been one God, the God of the Old and New Testaments. Therefore, all of Scripture is for us, because all of it points to Christ. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *