When we discuss the sinlessness of Jesus Christ, we’re like a car approaching a busy intersection, because we are discussing how Jesus’ two natures (human and divine) interact with one another. That means like a car approaching a yield sign at a busy roundabout, we must proceed cautiously. If we place too much emphasis on one nature or the other, we could end up in a theological car wreck. So, let’s start by discussing the easiest aspect of Jesus’ sinlessness, specifically that He never sinned during His whole life on earth.
We know that Jesus was born without a sinful nature and without original sin because of the virgin birth, and Scripture teaches that Jesus maintained that sinlessness throughout His entire life.
[The Father] made [Jesus], who knew no sin, to be sin for us, so that in Him we might become the righteousness of God.
2 COrinthians 5:21
We do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin.
Hebrews 4:15
[Jesus] committed no sin, neither was deceit found in His mouth.
1 Peter 2:22
You know that [Jesus] appeared in order to take away sins, and in Him there is no sin.
1 John 3:5
Peter, Paul, John, and the author of Hebrews all describe Jesus with similar words: “in Him there is no sin,” “He committed no sin,” He is “without sin,” and He “knew no sin.” Jesus and sin are antithetical, which makes sense since He is divine. However, it is not sufficient to merely say that Jesus did not sin. No, we must also affirm that Jesus fulfilled all righteousness too.
When Jesus told John the Baptist to baptize Him, John responded in an understandable way. John knew Jesus was sinless, so Jesus had no need to be baptized for the forgiveness of sins. Consequently, John asked Jesus to baptize him, a sinner, instead. Nevertheless, Jesus insisted on being baptized, and His reason is very important.
Jesus answered [John], ‘Let it be so now, for thus it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness.’ Then, he consented.
Matthew 3:15
It was good for Jesus to fulfill all righteousness. Jesus did every good deed a human could possibly do, at least categorically speaking. Jesus didn’t merely avoid stealing candy bars and murdering people. No, He also obeyed everything the Law commanded, even the ceremonial aspects like avoiding pork and going to Jerusalem three times per year. He always loved God and His neighbor, and He may have even walked a grandma across the street too, because He fulfilled all righteousness. That’s why He was baptized, because it is righteous to declare your allegiance to the Father publicly in the baptismal waters. Jesus didn’t merely avoid sin; He also did every good deed possible on a categorical level. That’s why it is accurate to say Jesus is not only sinless, but truly righteous and good. He is God after all.
This brings us to the trickiest aspect of Jesus’ sinlessness and goodness. As the God-man, could Jesus have sinned? We know that His human will was genuinely tempted (cf. Matthew 4:1-11; Hebrews 2:18; 4:15). However, could Jesus have sinned? To answer that question, we must delve deep into theology and carefully make clear distinctions between Jesus’ two natures.
Jesus’ human nature was genuinely tempted, because Satan appealed to Jesus’ human will in the wilderness. Jesus’ human will desired food (which He needed), adoration (which He deserved), and authority (which He deserved), so it made sense for Satan to tempt Jesus to fulfill these good desires in sinful, selfish ways outside of the Father’s will. Had Jesus’ human will desired to sin in these ways, it theoretically could have. After all, Jesus’ untainted human will was the same as Adam’s untainted human will, and Adam’s untainted human will was capable of sinning and did sin when tempted. Therefore, theoretically, Jesus’ human will was capable of sinning if it so desired when tempted. There’s the key phrase though, “If it so desired.” The human will of Jesus could not desire to sin more than to obey the will of the Father, because Jesus’ human will was in constant submission to His divine will. That’s why Jesus consistently said that He came to do the Father’s will, not His will (cf. John 6:38; 8:29; 15:10).
Since Jesus’ human will was always in submission to His divine will, and since the divine will was always in submission to the Father’s will, it was impossible for Jesus to sin. This makes sense, since Jesus’ divine nature is immutable and righteous. Since Jesus is one person with two natures, and if Jesus had sinned as the God-man, then the divine nature would have sinned alongside the human nature. However, if the divine nature had sinned, then it would no longer be righteous and, ergo, would no longer be immutable or divine. Since Jesus’ divine nature cannot change and cannot sin, we can conclude that Jesus the person, the God-man, could not have sinned, even when tempted. There was no scenario where it was even possible for the human will to desire to sin more than to submit to the Father, thereby making Jesus “impeccable.”
Immediately, someone will respond by saying that Jesus cannot sympathize with us sinners if He is impeccable. They will say that Jesus’ temptation was nothing like ours if He couldn’t fail, and therefore, our high priest can’t relate to us. First off, we must affirm that Scripture does teach that Jesus was tempted like us and can sympathize with us (cf. Hebrews 2:18; 4:15). However, I believe the truth of Jesus’ sympathy as our High Priest and His impeccability are compatible. Let me prove it by asking a question: Who is tempted worse, the sinner who succumbed after five minutes of temptation, or Jesus, who never succumbed to constant temptation throughout His whole life? Clearly, Jesus suffered under the weight of temptation more than you or me. When tempted, we frequently sin, at which point we get a reprieve. We get a break, because we gave in. Jesus never gave in though. Consequently, He never got a reprieve. He never received a break from temptation. Instead, He endured it His whole life without any respite, yet He never sinned. When we view Jesus’ temptation that way, we can truly say that Jesus can sympathize with us, even though He is impeccable. To the person who says, “Jesus can’t sympathize with me when I’m tempted because He couldn’t sin,” He would probably say something like, “You don’t even know what temptation is.” That’s how we can reconcile Jesus’ impeccability and sympathy as our High Priest.
Jesus was born without a sin nature or original sin because of the virgin birth, and He maintained that sinlessness by never sinning during His time on earth. Moreover, He not only refused to sin, but also did every righteous deed that can categorically be done. He was able to be perfectly righteous and never sin because He is truly God, yet He was able to be truly tempted because He is truly man. Jesus’ human will was tempted, but His human will was in submission to His divine will, which cannot sin. Therefore, Jesus is impeccable, incapable of sinning, yet He is also capable of sympathizing with us as our High Priest. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments