One of the more unique features of the Roman Catholic religion is the mandatory celibacy of its clergy. All Catholic priests, bishops, and even the Pope must remain single and celibate for life. Ironically, Catholics put themselves in a Catch 22 because of their view of church history. They (erroneously) presume that Peter was the first Pope of the Church, and they also (erroneously) believe that the clergy must remain single and celibate. Ironically, in this spree of a-historical theology, Catholics have condemned their supposed first Pope, because Scripture and church history plainly tell us that Peter had a wife.
When Jesus entered Peter’s house, He saw his mother-in-law lying sick with a fever.
Matthew 8:14
Clement, indeed, whose words we have just quoted, after the above-mentioned facts, gives a statement on account of those who reject marriage, of the Apostles that had wives. ‘Or will they,’ he says, ‘reject even the Apostles? For Peter and Philip begot children, and Philip also gave his daughters in marriage’
Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History, book 3, chapter 20, section 1
Peter had a mother-in-law, which necessitates having a wife, and they were together long enough that they had children together. Lest someone say that Peter’s wife died before he became Pope, thus allowing Peter to be single and celibate during his time as the bishop of Rome, church history also teaches that Peter and his wife died together under the Neronic persecution in Rome.
They say, accordingly, that the blessed Peter, upon seeing his wife led to death, rejoiced on account of her call and conveyance home and called very encouragingly and comfortingly, addressing her by name, ‘Remember the Lord!’ Such was the marriage of the blessed and their perfect disposition toward those dearest to them.
Clement of ALexandria, Stromata, book 7, chapter 11, paragraph 10
Since Peter and his wife both died under Nero Caesar’s persecution, we know that Peter was never single for any length of time. Therefore, Roman Catholics are put in a difficult predicament. Either they must deny that Peter was the first Pope, because he was not celibate, or they must deny that the clergy must remain celibate, because their supposed first Pope wasn’t even celibate.
Church history and Scripture do not support the Roman Catholic practice of clergy celibacy. Peter not only had a wife and children, but they also had the privilege to die one after the other under persecution. They spent their entire lives together, and Peter’s wife was very likely a source of encouragement and support during his ministry. Therefore, there is no basis for clergy celibacy. Even our Apostles weren’t celibate, other than Paul. Clergy celibacy is an extrabiblical, a-historical practice of the Roman Catholic Church, and it should be rejected. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments