Church History: The Pope

Church History: The Pope

The Roman Catholic Church would have you believe that Peter was the first Pope. They say he was the Bishop of Rome and the Vicar of Christ on earth, and they would have you believe that there has been an uninterrupted line of papal succession from Peter to Francis. In Roman Catholic theology, these individuals have ultimate authority over the church on earth, as their Catechism enumerates.

The Pope, Bishop of Rome and Peter’s successor, is the perpetual and visible source and foundation of the unity both of the bishops and of the whole company of the faithful, for the Roman Pontiff, by reason of his office as Vicar of Christ and as pastor of the entire Church, has full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church, a power which he can always exercise unhindered.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, part 1, section 2, chapter 3, article 9, paragraph 4, point 882

While the Catholics would have you believe the Church has always submitted to the absolute authority of the Bishop of Rome–the Pope–from Peter until today, church history tells another story. A long time ago, in the third century, there was a debate over what to do when a heretic genuinely repents of his heresy and believes the true gospel. There was a man named Cyprian who threw his hat into this debate, and he and dozens of other pastors met together in approximately AD 255 in Carthage to discuss this issue. Their conclusion was this: if someone was baptized by known heretics, and if that person converts to the true faith, then that person should be baptized by the Church. However, the Bishop of Rome, a man named Stephen, took exception with their conclusion. Stephen believed that those who were baptized by known heretics should not be baptized by the Church, since they had already been baptized. Cyprian saw heretical baptisms as illegitimate, while Stephen insisted they were legitimate. Consequently, Stephen openly rebuked the Council of Carthage’s conclusion, and in response, Cyprian called another council a year later in approximately AD 256. Their conclusions were shocking if you believe the Church has always submitted to the authority of the Bishop of Rome.

Cescens of Cirta said, ‘In such an assembly of most holy fellow priests, as the letters of our most beloved Cyprian to Jubaianus and also to Stephen have been read, containing in them so much of the holy testimonies, which descend from the divinely-made Scriptures, that with reason we ought (all being made one by the grace of God) to consent to them. I judge that all heretics and schismatics who wish to come to the universal Church shall not be allowed to enter without having first been exorcised and baptized.’

Third Council of Carthage (AD 256)

The council read the correspondence between Stephen, Cyprian, and Jubaianus, and then they unanimously concluded that Cyprian was correct. The Church should baptize those who convert from heresy to Christianity, even if they had been baptized by a heretic in the past. This was in blatant disregard to what Stephen, the Bishop of Rome, had said. Clearly, Stephen did not have “full, supreme, and universal power over the Church.” To drive the nail in the coffin, the Third Council of Carthage repudiated the notion that any bishop had authority over another bishop.

None [of us] has set himself [to be] bishop [of bishops] or attempted with tyrannical dread to force his colleagues to obedience to him, since every bishop has, for the license of liberty and power, his own will, and as he cannot be judged by another, so neither can he judge another.

Third Council of Carthage

Church history repudiates the idea of a Pope, the Bishop of Rome, having absolute authority over the Church. At the Third Council of Carthage, dozens of pastors gathered and rejected the verdict of the Bishop of Rome, Stephen, contrary to Catholic theology. Stephen had said heretics who had been baptized by other heretics should not be baptized if they repented and joined the true Church. Stephen insisted their heretical baptisms were legitimate. On the other hand, Cyprian and the bishops who gathered in Carthage determined that heretics should be baptized when they convert. Moreover, in their council canons, they determined that a bishop in one city has no authority over another bishop in another city. This flies in the face of the papacy and Roman Catholic theology. Consequently, church history actually supports local autonomy. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *