Systematic Theology: Extent of the Atonement

Systematic Theology: Extent of the Atonement

Now that we know why Jesus died–specifically, to take the punishment that sinners deserve in order to satisfy divine justice and to defeat Satan–we can discuss the identity of those for whom Jesus died. I propose that Jesus is not a potential Savior. I do not believe Jesus’ death made all men and women savable if they would cooperate, but rather secured the salvation of some men and women. I base this conclusion on Scriptural, logical, and covenantal reasons. In my experience, people often say there isn’t a verse that says Jesus only died for certain people and excluded others, but that assertion is untrue. There is an instance where Jesus said He only died for some and not for others.

I am the good shepherd. I know My own, and My own know Me, just as the Father knows Me and I know the Father. I lay down My life for the sheep, and I have other sheep that are not of this fold. I must bring them also, and they will listen to My voice. So, there will be one flock, one Shepherd. … You do not believe because you are not among My sheep.

John 10:14-16, 26

It is incredibly important that Jesus identified His opponents in the audience as “not among My sheep,” because He already identified those who are His sheep earlier in John 10. Those who are Jesus’ sheep in John 10 are not merely those who already believe in Him. Rather, they are those who believe in Him in the present and will believe in Him in the future. He said He has “other sheep that are not of this fold.” The sheep of “this fold” are Jews who have already believed in Him, and the “other sheep” are Gentiles who will guaranteed believe in Him. After all, He used the future tense when describing the future salvation of Gentiles. This is not insignificant.

When Jesus said the words, “you are not among My sheep,” He had already identified every single person who would ever believe in Him. He had already identified “the sheep” as being everyone–Jew or Gentile–who would be saved. Jesus also said that He laid His life down for “the sheep.” Therefore, when Jesus also said that His opponents are not “among My sheep,” He was in essence saying to them, “I don’t lay My life down for you.” Therefore, we can conclude that Jesus did not lay His life down for everyone without exception. Rather, He laid His life down for a limited amount of people. He died to save His sheep, the elect, and His death sealed and guaranteed those sheep’s salvation. After all, Jesus said all of His sheep will (not might) hear His voice and come to Him. Jesus’ death didn’t make salvation possible for humanity in general. Jesus’ death made salvation secure for the elect specifically. This is the doctrine of limited atonement taught in Scripture, and logic supports this conclusion.

One of the key words when discussing penal substitutionary atonement is “propitiation,” which means, “satisfaction of divine wrath.” Therefore, when Jesus is identified as the propitiation for sin in Scripture, we know He is the satisfaction of divine wrath. However, if Jesus is the propitiation for every single person who has ever lived without exception, then the only logical conclusion is universalism (everyone without exception will be saved in the end). There is no room for Jesus to satisfy the Father’s wrath against a sinner, but then for the Father to turn around and pour out His wrath on the same sinner for all eternity. Either Jesus satisfied the wrath of the Father against everyone and thereby saved everyone, or Jesus satisfied the wrath of the Father against a limited group and thereby saved them only. Since Scripture clearly denies the former option of universalism, we are left with only the latter option, that Jesus died to save a limited group. This fits with Scripture’s concept of covenantal mediation.

In the Old Covenant, the high priest offered a sacrifice on the Day of Atonement as a propitiation. However, did the high priest offer this sacrifice as a mediator for everyone without exception? No, he only offered it as a mediator for the covenant people of God. The Day of Atonement was only intended for the covenant nation of Israel. This prefigured Jesus, who is the Mediator of the New Covenant. Therefore, since the Old Covenant’s sacrificial extent was limited to the physical covenant people of Israel, it only makes sense the New Covenant’s sacrificial extent is limited to the spiritual covenant people of Israel. This logic is the basis of a beautiful conclusion in Hebrews.

Therefore, [Jesus] is the Mediator of the New Covenant, so that those who are called may receive the promised eternal inheritance, since a death has occurred that redeems them from the transgressions committed under the First Covenant.

Hebrews 9:15

Everyone for whom Jesus mediates will be called to salvation. Everyone for whom Jesus mediates will receive the promised inheritance of eternal life. Those two statements are only factual because everyone for whom Jesus died has been redeemed from sin. At each step (call, mediation, redemption, inheritance), the scope of Jesus’ work is limited. Therefore, the only Scriptural, logical, and covenantal conclusion is that Jesus’ death was only intended to save a limited number of people.

When we discuss the extent of the atonement, we must recognize that we’re not debating the sufficiency of Jesus’ atonement. Jesus’ death is sufficient to save anyone. Instead, we’re discussing the intent of the atonement, which according to Scripture was limited. Jesus only intended to lay His life down for His sheep, whom He identified as the elect, in contrast with those who reject Him. This makes sense since, if Jesus propitiated the sins of every individual who’s ever existed, then everyone would be saved. Instead, Jesus propitiated the sins of those in the New Covenant only, thereby securing their salvation and eternal inheritance. This makes Jesus a powerful Savior, not a potential Savior. Of course, there are many texts that people cite to defend the idea that Jesus died to save everyone without exception, and I encourage you to read my thoughts on those texts here: Isaiah 53:6, John 3:16, John 12:32, 2 Corinthians 5:14-20, 1 Timothy 4:10, Hebrews 2:9, 2 Peter 2:1, 1 John 2:2. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *