I’ve already covered John 3:16 as a difficult passage before, and if you read that previous post, then you’ll know most of what I’m going to say here, just in the context of unconditional election rather than the extent of the atonement, which I’ll cover here. When discussing the extent and intent of the atonement, one of the most cited verses in support of an unlimited extent/intent is John 3:16.
God loved the world in this way, that He gave His only Son, so that everyone believing in Him would not perish but have eternal life.
John 3:16 [my translation]
When cited during a discussion about the extent and intent of the atonement, here’s how many interpret John 3:16: “God the Father loves every single individual without exception so much, that He sent Jesus to atone for the sins of every single individual without exception.” Thus, in this interpretation the extent and intent of the atonement is unlimited in order to save everyone without exception. However, this interpretation of John 3:16 is entirely dependent on the meaning of the word “world” being “everyone without exception.” Contextually, this cannot be the definition of “world,” especially in light of John 3:17.
God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through Him.
John 3:17
At face value, this verse might not automatically change your definition of “world” from “everyone without exception” to something else. However, when you understand a unique construction in Greek, you are left with only two choices. You must either be a universalist, or you must recognize that God the Father did not send God the Son to atone for the sins of everyone without exception, but rather the sins of everyone without distinction. The key construction is what’s called a hina clause in Greek.
The word hina in Greek denotes purpose and is usually translated as, “that,” “so that,” or, “in order that.” It’s a relatively frequent word in the New Testament, and every time an author uses the word hina to denote the purpose of God, it is assumed that God will successfully fulfill His purpose. While hina clauses also include subjunctive verbs (which denote possibility), that’s not because it’s up for debate whether or not God will accomplish His purposes. Rather, the Greek language simply uses the subjunctive mood in hina clauses as an unwritten rule. My point is this: every time Scripture describes God’s purposes with a hina clause, that purpose is always accomplished. Let me give an example from John’s Gospel.
I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me. This is the will of Him who sent Me, that I should lose nothing of all that He has given Me, but raise it up on the last day. This is the will of My Father, that everyone who looks on the Son and believes in Him should have eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day.
John 6:38-40
I’ve bolded the hina clauses to prove my point. Does anyone think it’s up for debate whether Jesus will lose someone that the Father has given Him? Does anyone think it’s up for debate whether someone who believes in Jesus will have eternal life? Does anyone think it’s up for debate whether someone who has been given by the Father to the Son and has believed on the Son will be resurrected to glory on the last day? Of course it’s not up for debate. We understand that Jesus will guaranteed not lose anyone that the Father has given Him. We understand that those who believe in Jesus will guaranteed have eternal life, and we understand that those who have been given by the Father to the Son and have believed on the Son will be resurrected to glory on the last day. There’s no question whether God will accomplish His purposes as denoted by the hina clauses in John 6:38-40, and the same is true of John 3:17.
In John 3:17, we are told that God’s purpose is that Jesus would save the world. Is there any debate whether or not Jesus will save the world? In light of John 6:38-40, there can be no doubt. Jesus will guaranteed save the world. At this point, we are at a crossroads. We must now define the word “world.” Does “world” refer to everyone without exception? If so, then you must be a universalist. After all, God always accomplishes His purposes when denoted by a hina clause, and John 3:17 says God’s purpose is to save the world in Jesus. Therefore, if you define “world” as “everyone without exception,” then you must be a universalist. You must believe that Jesus died for and will save everyone without exception. This presents problems though because universalism is a different gospel. Therefore, what does “world” really mean in John 3:16-17?
The simplest definition for “world” in John 3:16-17 is “everyone without distinction.” In short, the word “world” refers to people of all tribes, tongues, peoples, and nations. Jesus isn’t just the Savior of Jews only. He’s the Savior of Jews and Gentiles without distinction. Anyone who believes in Him will have eternal life because Jesus came to save all kinds of people, no exceptions. This is the only consistent way to interpret “world” in a way that doesn’t result in the heresy of universalism.
What does this have to do with the intent and extent of the atonement though? Well, if “world” does not mean everyone without exception, but rather everyone without distinction, and if “world” does not refer to every single Jew and every single Gentile without exception, but rather to Jews and Gentiles who believe without distinction, then we can conclude that John 3:16 does not teach an unlimited intent and extent of the atonement. If anything, John 3:16 teaches a limited intent and extent of the atonement. God the Father sent God the Son to die, so that those who believe (a limited amount of people) would be saved. If Jesus didn’t die on the cross, then those who believe would still be lost because no one satisfied justice on their behalf. However, the Father sent the Son to die in the place of those who would believe, so that they would have eternal life. Simply put, John 3:16 does not teach that Jesus’ death atoned for the sins of everyone who’s every lived without exception. Rather, John 3:16 teaches that Jesus’ death is sufficient to save everyone who believes without distinction. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments