Now that we’ve seen the historical argument against the office of deaconess, let’s address the biblical argument. What does the Bible say about the office of deacon (which simply means “servant”), and who can fill this office biblically? Ultimately, there are only two passages that one could appeal to in order to defend the practice of ordaining women as deacons. Let’s start with the most obvious of the two, 1 Timothy 3.
Likewise, deacons must be dignified, not double-tongued, not addicted to much wine, and not greedy for dishonest gain. They must hold the mystery of the faith with a clear conscience, and let them also be tested first. Then, let them serve as deacons if they prove themselves blameless. Likewise, their wives [women] must be dignified and not slanderers, but sober-minded and faithful in all things. Let deacons each be the husband of one wife, managing their children and their own households well, for those who serve well as deacons gain a good standing for themselves and also great confidence in the faith that is in Jesus Christ.
1 Timothy 3:8-13
The debate over deaconesses hinges on the word gunaikas, which can be translated as “women” or “wives.” If Paul intended gunaikas to mean “wives,” then 1 Timothy 3:11 describes the necessary character of a deacon’s (and elder’s by extension) wife. However, if Paul intended gunaikas to mean “women,” then 1 Timothy 3:11 describes the necessary character of a woman aspiring to be a deacon herself. In order to determine the correct meaning of gunaikas, we must study the surrounding context.
Those who affirm the office of deaconess will say, “The word hōsautōs means ‘likewise,’ and Paul used it in 1 Timothy 3 to introduce a list of qualifications for the three church offices: elder, deacon, and deaconess. Therefore, the office of deaconess is legitimate.” The premise of their argument is true to a point. The word hōsautōs does introduce a list of qualifications for an individual, but the conclusion of their point goes too far and is actually illogical. If hōsautōs is intended to introduce the qualifications for a distinct office in the church, then the office of deacon would be a different office than deaconess, even though they are functionally the exact same office. Therefore, it would seem odd to say Paul saw deacons and deaconesses as entirely different offices, which is fundamentally what those who affirm the office of deaconess are proposing. Instead, it is best to see the word hōsautōs as introducing the qualifications for an individual, but their status as an ordained leader in the church should not be assumed.
Furthermore, if hōsautōs is intended to introduce the list of necessary qualifications for an entirely new office (as proposed by those who affirm the office of deaconess), rather than to introduce the list of necessary qualifications of a deacon’s wife as a subset of the deacon’s qualifications (as proposed by myself and many others), then why would Paul abruptly go back to describing the necessary qualifications of deacons after shifting to the entirely different office of deaconess? After all, 1 Timothy 3:12-13 goes back to describing the qualifications that a man must meet in order to be a deacon. This would be very jarring if Paul was describing the qualifications of a deaconess in verse 11, rather than the qualifications of the deacon’s wife in verse 11. It’s also especially jarring because verse 12 says deacons must be “a husband of one wife,” something a woman obviously could not be. Therefore, it is best to see verse 11 as describing the character quality of the deacon’s wife, especially when we look at the list of qualifications for the woman.
When we read the qualifications of a deacon in 1 Timothy 3:8-10, 12-13, we see a fairly lengthy and stringent list:
- Dignified
- Not double-tongued
- Not addicted to alcohol
- Not greedy
- Tested
- Has a clear conscience
- Blameless
- A husband of one wife
- Manages his household well
- Manages his children well
Again, I would ask how a woman could be a husband of one wife. This qualification would preclude any woman from serving as a deacon, but the retort to this objection would be, “The qualifications for a deaconess are only found in 1 Timothy 3:11, so being a ‘husband of one wife’ isn’t a necessary qualification for deaconesses.” To this, I would retort that this makes 1 Timothy 3:8-13 very jarring (going from the qualifications of deacons in verses 8-10, then the qualifications of deaconesses in verse 11, then back to the qualifications of deacons in verses 12-13), and I would also say that the list of qualifications for deacons is extremely similar to the list of qualification for elders. This makes it all the more surprising that the list of qualifications for the gunaikas is so short:
- Dignified
- Not slanderous
- Sober-minded
- Faithful
If gunaikas is intended to be its own separate office, then why are the necessary qualifications so lax? Why does God demand men be blameless, the husband of one wife, not love money, manage his house well, and manage his kids well, and be tested before they can fill an office in the church, but not women? Why would God be so strict for men, but not women? Again, the best answer is that 1 Timothy 3:11 isn’t describing the necessary qualifications of an entirely new office of deaconess, but rather the qualifications of a deacon’s (and by extension an elder’s) wife. That’s why the list is so much shorter, because we all understand that the responsibilities of an elder and a deacon are exponentially higher than the responsibilities of their wives, hence the stricter qualifications.
With all of this said, it is best to see 1 Timothy 3:11 as describing the qualifications of an elder’s or a deacon’s wife, not a deaconess. It doesn’t make sense for Paul to shoehorn the qualifications of deaconesses into the middle of the qualifications of deacons, especially if the word “likewise” is intended to communicate an entirely different office is in view. It also doesn’t make sense for a qualification of deacons to be “a husband of one wife” if women can also be deacons. Furthermore, since the list of qualifications for women in 1 Timothy 3:11 is so short, it is best to see these qualifications as applying to men’s wives, not women deacons. 1 Timothy 3 does not permit the office of deaconess, and neither does Romans 16:1.
I commend to you our sister, Phoebe, a servant [deacon] of the church at Cenchreae.
Romans 16:1
Many will say, “Phoebe is described as a diakonon in Romans 16:1. Diakonos means ‘deacon.’ Therefore, Phoeboe is a deacon, thereby validating the office of deaconess.” First, I would point out that the term diakonos simply means “servant.” There is nothing intrinsically religious about the word. Even secular governments are called “deacons” in Romans 13. The term usually does not refer to the office, but rather to someone who performs a service, especially when we recognize the context of Romans 16. Romans 16 is Paul’s salutation to the Romans. In all of Paul’s letters, he ends with some form of salutation, and when he describes someone in these salutations, he never uses a formal office to describe anyone. He never calls someone an “apostle.” He never calls someone an “elder” or “overseer” or “pastor.” He never calls someone a “prophet,” and he never calls someone a “deacon,” except in this context. Therefore, it is best to simply see Paul’s use of the word diakonos in Romans 16:1 as describing the selfless character quality of Phoebe, rather than her formal ordination.
Now that we’ve looked at the arguments used to defend the office of deaconess, let’s look at the arguments I would use to refute the office of deaconess. First, I would point out that the office of deacon is a leadership position, and that women are forbidden from having authority in the church. We know service is what makes someone a leader, and since “deacon” simply means “servant,” we know that deacons are leaders, thereby precluding women from the office, lest they be leaders in the church over men.
Whoever would be great among you must be your servant.
Matthew 20:26
I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she must remain quiet, for Adam was formed first, then Eve, and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor.
1 Timothy 2:12-14
Paul just finished saying that women cannot have authority in churches in 1 Timothy 2. Therefore, it would be counterintuitive for him to immediately follow that by saying in 1 Timothy 3 that women can be deacons, which by nature are the greatest leaders in the church according to Jesus. I believe when we read 1 Timothy as a cohesive letter, the idea of ordaining women to any position in the church shouldn’t even be an option. However, the strongest argument against the idea of letting women be deacons is the institution of the office in Acts 6.
In Acts 6, we see a problem in the church in Jerusalem. Not all the women were getting food, and the Apostles were asked to fix the problem. Instead of fixing the problem themselves (thereby detracting from their time to preach, teach, and evangelize), this is what the Apostles said to do:
Therefore, brothers, pick out from among you seven men of good repute, full of the Spirit and of wisdom, whom we will appoint for this duty.
Acts 6:3
Almost everyone would agree that Acts 6 describes the creation of the office of deacon, but did you notice the first qualification for the very first deacons? No, it’s not being “of good repute.” It’s being a man, because they said to “pick out from among you seven men.” If someone was a woman, they were immediately disqualified from filling the position, even if she was “of good repute.” Acts 6 introduces the office of deacon, and it says only men are possibilities. Only those with XY chromosomes and who meet the character qualifications can be deacons.
When we read 1 Timothy 2 and 3 in context, we see that Paul is not condoning the practice of ordaining women as deaconesses. Instead, he precludes women from leadership in the church and describes what an elder’s or deacon’s wife must be like. It doesn’t make sense for Paul to divide the office of deacon from deaconess if they have the same function as servants. It doesn’t make sense for Paul to have such loose qualification standards for deaconesses, but strict qualification standards for deacons and elders. It doesn’t make sense for Paul to say deacons must be “a husband of one wife” if women can be deacons. It doesn’t make sense for Paul to abruptly switch to describing deaconess’ qualifications in verse 11 but then switch back to deacons’ qualifications in verses 12-13. It simply doesn’t make sense to say that deaconesses are in view in 1 Timothy 3:11. Likewise, Romans 16:1 merely says Phoebe was selfless, not that she was ordained, especially when we recognize that ordination is reserved for men, including deacons. This is confirmed by the Apostles statement to only consider men to be deacons in Acts 6 when the office was created. We must take the topic of deaconess seriously because it is a gateway to egalitarianism. If someone can jump through all of these hoops to justify ordaining women as deacons, then there is only one more hoop to jump through before justifying ordaining women as elders. That’s the trend of church history, but it is not the teaching of Scripture, which only allows men to be elders and deacons and to have authority in the church. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments