There are only two biblical offices for local churches in Scriptures, elders and deacons, and they are ideally supposed to exist in plurality in each local church. The office of elder exists to teach, administrate, and preserve the doctrinal purity of a local church, while the office of deacon exists to carry out the will of the elders and to serve the congregation. In short, elders are gifted to meet the spiritual needs of a local church, while deacons are gifted to meet the physical needs of a local church. When qualified men perform these divinely appointed roles, the local church runs smoothly. I intentionally say qualified men, because there are some who propose that women can be elders and deacons. All Bible-loving, inerrancy-affirming Christians affirm that only men can be elders, but even among these Christians there is a debate concerning the office of deacon. Can women be deaconesses? Biblically, the answer is no (and we’ll see that in the near future), but the historical answer is also no.
Therefore, appoint for yourselves overseers [elders] and deacons worthy of the Lord, meek men and not lovers of money and truthful and approved, for they minister to you the ministry of the prophets and teachers. Therefore, do not despise them, for they are your honorable men together with the prophets and teachers.
The Didache (1st century) 15:1-2
I have never ordained deaconesses and sent them to other provinces, nor have I done anything to cause a schism in the church.
Epiphanius of Cyprus (4th century), Letter to John of Jerusalem, section 2, paragraph 1
It has also been suggested by some persons that, contrary to the Apostolic church order–unheard of until this time–women have been admitted to the Levitical ministry. I don’t know in what place. This, however, is something church order does not allow, because it is indecent. Since such an ordination has been performed against reason, it should be undone. Moreover, steps should be taken to ensure no one else will anymore presume to do such a thing.
Synod of Nimes (396), canon 2
By “Levitical ministry,” everyone in the fourth century understood this referred to the deacons. In the Old Testament, the priests oversaw the worship in the temple, while the Levites served behind the scenes to make sure the temple was in good order. In similar fashion, elders are in charge of overseeing worship in the gathering of the saints, while the deacons are in charge of serving behind the scenes to make sure everything is in good order. Therefore, when the Synod of Nimes says some place women in the “Levitical ministry,” they are condemning the practice of ordaining women as deaconesses. It is very important to note that the practice of ordaining women was “unheard of until this time” according to the Synod of Nimes. This demonstrates that deaconesses were a new concept in the fourth century, which is confirmed by those who affirmed ordaining women as deaconesses.
To be fair, there are ancient Christian writings that affirm the office of deaconess, such as the Council of Nicaea (325), Basil of Caesarea (329-379), the Apostolic Constitutions (375), and the Council of Chalcedon (451). However, since there is no instance of a woman being ordained before the fourth century according to the Synod of Nimes, and since the earliest non-inspired Christian writing (the Didache) specifically says to ordain men as elders and deacons in churches while failing to mention anything about deaconesses, it is best to see the office of deaconess as an ancient historical novelty.
While the office of deaconess may enjoy a better historical pedigree than most errors in the Christian Church, history still stands in opposition to the practice of ordaining women as deaconesses. The earliest non-inspired Christian text specifically says to ordain men as elders and deacons. Apparently, the debate over the validity of the office of deaconess began in the fourth century, because there is a sudden explosion in the number of Christian writers and councils that addressed the topic, and because the Synod of Nimes says no one had done such a thing until then. This makes the practice of ordaining deaconesses untenable historically. We know when the debate started, and we know that until that point, the church fathers had only practiced ordaining men for leadership. Therefore, it is best to reject the office of deaconess as a-historical and, more importantly, a-biblical, as we’ll see in the near future. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments