Difficult Passage: 2 Samuel 24/1 Chronicles 21

Difficult Passage: 2 Samuel 24/1 Chronicles 21

Now that we’ve completed the series about the Old Testament and how the New Testament interprets it, let’s take a look at a similar concept. Parallel passages are wonderful things in Scripture. I love it when two books of the Bible tell the same story, because they often clarify one another and add nuance to the story. That’s why I love the Synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke), because they seamlessly come together to tell a uniform and powerful story about Jesus. The same is true of the books of 1 Samuel, 2 Samuel, 1 Kings, 2 Kings, 1 Chronicles, and 2 Chronicles. Samuel and Kings tell a very detailed story concerning Israel’s history, and they include all the negative historical events. Chronicles however focuses on the positive, and when we compare the two accounts (Samuel and Kings with Chronicles), we often see nuances and clarifications. One great example of this concept is 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21. In true Samuel fashion, a negative historical event is recorded.

Again, the anger of Yahweh was kindled against Israel, and He incited David against them, saying, ‘Go; number Israel and Judah.’

2 Samuel 24:1

God was angry with Israel because of their sin, so He tested David. If David trusted God, then he would not have held a census. It wouldn’t have mattered how many soldiers he had available, because God had promised to protect Israel when they trusted Him to defend them. However, David did not trust God in that moment and, consequently, held a census. He failed the test, and the consequences were dire. God killed 70,000 Israelites for David’s arrogance, because David had failed God’s test. That’s how 2 Samuel records this historical event, but 1 Chronicles paints a slightly different picture.

Then, Satan stood against Israel and incited David to number Israel.

1 Chronicles 21:1

Many Christians have raised their eyebrows upon reading these two parallel passages. 2 Samuel 24 says God incited David to number Israel, while 1 Chronicles 21 says Satan incited David to number Israel. How can this be? Is God the same as Satan? Obviously, God is not Satan, but this parallel passage does shed light on exactly how God tested David. We know that God doesn’t tempt anyone according to James 1:13. However, God allows Satan to tempt people in order to test their faithfulness. He did this to Job when He allowed Satan to take everything away from Job in order to test his faithfulness. He also did this to David when He allowed Satan to tell him to number Israel’s soldiers in order to test David’s faithfulness. Ultimately, God is doing the inciting, because David and Job could not have been incited unless God willed it. However, Satan is the secondary cause and the agent of temptation, because God cannot and will not tempt anyone, including David and Job. Therefore, God tests people’s faithfulness by having Satan tempt them. God’s intentions are good, while Satan’s intentions are evil, and ironically, by doing evil, Satan is accomplishing what God intends. I believe this principle explains why Jesus taught us to pray in this way:

Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one.

Matthew 6:13

God is in full control over temptation. He Himself tempts no one, and Satan can only tempt someone when God allows it, just as He allowed Satan to incite David to hold a census in 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21. In light of this, it is good to ask God to spare us from temptation. After all, temptation can only occur when God allows it, so it makes sense to ask God to not allow us to be tempted, since we know we are so weak. However, since we know we don’t live in a greenhouse of perfection, and since we know God will inevitably allow us to be tempted at times in order to test our faithfulness, we should also ask God to deliver us from Satan, the agent of temptation. Christians should consistently ask God to keep them from temptation, to give them strength once tempted, and to forgive them when they succumb to temptation based on the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *