Church History: Traducianism

Church History: Traducianism

A few days ago, we considered the origin of the soul. Biblically, I believe the source of both the human body and the human soul is the parents at the moment of conception. Historically, this view is called “traducianism,” from the Latin word tradux, meaning “to bring forth.” In this case, the “bringing forth” is both the human soul and body in procreation. This view appears very early in Church history, lending credence to traducianism.

This [act of procreation], then, must be the soul-producing seed, which arises at once from the out-drop of the soul, just as the fluid is the body-producing seed, which proceeds from the drainage of the flesh. … These two different and separate substance—the clay [body] and the breath [soul]—combined at the first creation in forming the individual man. They then both amalgamated and mixed their proper seminal rudiments in one and ever afterwards communicated to the human race the normal mode of its propagation, so that even now the substances, although diverse from each other, flow forth simultaneously in a united channel. Finding their way together into their appointed seed-plot, they fertilize with their combined vigor the human fruit of their respective natures. … Accordingly from the one, primeval man [Adam] comes the entire outflow and redundancy of men’s souls, nature proving herself true to the commandment of God, ‘Be fruitful, and multiply.’ Man’s whole posterity was declared and described in a plural sense, ‘Let them have dominion over the fish of the sea.’

Tertullian (2nd century), On the Soul, chapter 27

While traducianism is a historically viable option, it by no means was the universal view of the Church. This is confirmed by later writings in the Church.

It is not true to say either that the soul exists before the body or that the body exists without the soul, but there is one beginning of both, which according to the heavenly [creationist] view was laid as their foundation in the original will of God, but according to the other view [traducianism] came into existence on the occasion of generation. As we cannot discern the articulation of the limbs in that which is implanted for the conception of the body before it begins to take form, so neither is it possible to perceive in the same the properties of the soul before the advance to operation.

Gregory of Nyssa (4th century), On the Making of Man, chapter 29, paragraphs 3-4

The majority of the Western writers think that, as the body is born of the body, so the soul is born of the soul.

Jerome (4th century), Letter 126, chapter 1

While traducianism was the popular view in the ancient Church, it was not a foregone conclusion. The origin of the soul has always been a debatable issue in the Church. While the Church agreed that the soul and the body come into existence at the same time, and that the soul does not preexist the body, they did not agree as to the source of the soul’s existence. As I’ve said before, if the Church was never unified on a particular subject in the past, then it is best to be gracious when discussing that same subject in the present. This is especially true concerning a secondary issue, such as creationism vs traducianism. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *