Systematic Theology: Origin of the Soul

Systematic Theology: Origin of the Soul

Last week, we saw that humans are comprised of a soul/spirit and a body. There is an immaterial aspect to each one of us, and we are spiritual and physical creatures by nature. This means that humans are made in the image of God, something I’ve written about before. I also mentioned last week that the debate regarding whether humanity is comprised of a body and a soul/spirit (two parts) or a body and a soul and a spirit (three parts) is a secondary debate and not worth dividing over. The same is true of today’s topic, which involves a question you might not have ever asked yourself. Where do souls come from?

Before beginning, I must mention at the outset that human souls are not kept in some kind of “soul playpen” in heaven waiting to be assigned to a conceived body on earth. God did not create a bunch of souls and store them in heaven. Souls do not preexist the conception of the body. In fact, that is the view of the Mormon “church,” and it has been condemned as heresy since the Second Council of Constantinople in AD 553. This leaves only two options. Either God creates souls ex nihilo (from nothing) at the moment of bodily conception by the parents, or God oversees the bodily conception and spiritual conception of an individual by the parents. Basically, either God makes souls, or parents make souls.

I’ll remind you that this debate is the definition of a secondary doctrine. So long as you do not believe that souls preexist the body in heaven, you’re orthodox. However, it is an interesting discussion, and Scripture may provide us the answer. When God finished creating everything on day six, He rested according to Genesis 2. God does not create ex nihilo anymore. However, if God creates souls at the moment of conception, then He is still creating ex nihilo and has been doing so for a very long time. This isn’t a strong argument, but I believe God resting after the creation week hints that He does not create souls ex nihilo.

Also, when God created Adam in His image during the creation week, He created both Adam’s body and soul. This is very important, because Genesis 5:1-3 says this:

This is the book of the generations of Adam. When God created man, He made him in the likeness of God. Male and female, He created them, and He blessed them and named them Man when they were created. When Adam had lived 130 years, he fathered a son in his own likeness, after his image, and named him Seth.

Genesis 5:1-3

If God made Adam in His image by creating both his body and soul, and if Adam made/conceived Seth in his image, then Adam must have been the source of Seth’s body and soul. Again, this isn’t a be-all-end-all argument, but I believe it gives us a hint that our parents are the immediate sources of our souls, not God.

Immediately, someone will point to verses that say God creates the soul, but there are plenty of verses that say God creates the body too. We know that God does not create the body ex nihilo though. Rather, He oversees the union of the father’s sperm and the mother’s egg and oversees the formation of the physical nature of each of us in the womb. I would say the same is true of the soul’s creation. God oversees the union of the father’s soul and the mother’s soul and the formation of the spiritual nature of each of us in the womb. Just as God providentially controls our hair color, eye color, height, etc., so too does God providentially control our personalities and spiritual nature. This is an important distinction, because souls are created evil, and God cannot create evil.

When God creates ex nihilo, the result is always “good” in Genesis 1-2. However, we know that all souls are born spiritually dead and sinful (Psalm 51:5; 58:3). Therefore, this hints that God does not create souls ex nihilo, but rather oversees the union of sinful individuals as they create the body and the soul of their child in procreation. Again, this is not the definitive answer to the debate, but it is something worth pondering. I believe the strongest case for my view though comes from Hebrews.

One might even say that Levi himself, who receives tithes, paid tithes through Abraham, for he was still in the loins of his ancestor when Melchizedek met him.

Hebrews 7:9

Levi, the progenitor of the Levitical priests (who received tithes from Israel), was in the loins of his forefather, Abraham, when Abraham tithed to Melchizedek. How can Levi be in the loins of Abraham if Levi’s soul, which is the most fundamental aspect of Levi, was created ex nihilo by God centuries after Abraham. I believe this verse teaches that in a sense, all of our progeny are in us already—body and soul—because our bodies will give rise to their bodies, and because our souls will give rise to their souls. That’s the only way to consistently say that Levi as a person was, technically speaking, in Abraham when Abraham tithed to Melchizedek. Therefore, I believe parents are the source of both the body and soul in the act of procreation.

Where do souls come from? Have they always existed in heaven since creation? Does God create them ex nihilo/from nothing at the moment of conception? Do parents create both bodies and souls in the act of procreation, which is overseen by God? I believe that parents are the source of both the bodies and souls of their children. This explains how God can truly rest after day six, how souls can be sinful, and how children can so obviously mirror both the physical and spiritual aspects of their parents. This view historically has been called traducianism, and it’s like a lit match. Adam’s body was like a match, lit alight by God breathing a soul into him on day six. When Adam’s match lit Seth’s match by creating Seth’s body and soul with Eve, Adam’s match didn’t go out. Rather, his match continued to stay lit until he died, until his body failed. In this way, humanity has been creating more and more humans in both the image of their parents and in God’s image. This isn’t a major doctrine, but it is an interesting doctrine, one worth pondering. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *