Church History: Gospel Authors

Church History: Gospel Authors

While we saw a long time ago what books the early church recognized as canonical, that’s only have the discussion. Not only did the early church have to determine what was canonical/inspired, they had to determine who was canonical/inspired. These two discussions go hand-in-hand. After all, if an Apostle wrote a letter, then that letter was already on the fast track to being recognized as canon. Therefore, it is very important to recognize that the identity of the authors of the books of the New Testament is paramount to the Christian faith. If Matthew (an Apostle) wrote Matthew, and if Mark interviewed Peter (an Apostle) when he wrote Mark, and if Luke interviewed the Apostles when he wrote Luke, and if John (an Apostle) wrote John, then we must take what they wrote seriously. So, let’s see what the early church had to say on the subject of the Gospel authors’ identities.

The early church unanimously agreed that the Gospel According to Luke was, in fact, written by Luke, and the Gospel According to John was, in fact, written by John.

The third book of the Gospel is that according to Luke. Luke, the well-known physician, after the ascension of Christ, when Paul had taken with him as one zealous for the Law, composed in his own name according to faith. Yet, he himself had not yet seen the Lord in the flesh, and, therefore, as he was able to ascertain events, so indeed he begins to tell the story from the birth of John. The fourth of the Gospels is that of John, one of the disciples. To his fellow disciples and overseers, who had been urging him, he said, ‘Fast with me from today to three days, and what will be revealed to each one, let us tell it to one another.’ In the same night, it was revealed to Andrew, one of the Apostles, that John should write down all things in his own name, while all of them should review it.

Muratorian Canon (2nd century), lines 2-16

Luke began from Zechariah, the priest, so that he would declare the divinity of Christ to the Gentiles by the miracles of the birth of his son and by the office of so many preachers. John, based in Ephesus, made the beginning of the Gospel from the reason of our redemption for us who from the Gentiles as it were did not know the Law, which reason is evident from him that God wished His Son to be incarnated for our salvation.

Polycarp of Smyrna (69-155 AD), Fragments from Victor of Capua, section 3

Clearly, the early church affirmed that Luke and John actually wrote their Gospels. These Gospels were not written by pseudonymous writers pretending to be Luke and John. These Gospels were not written by random men in the latter part of the first century whom the Church later ascribed to Luke and John. No, that would be impossible in light of how early and unanimously the early church recognized Luke and John as the genuine authors of their respective Gospels, and the same is true of Matthew and Mark.

While the Muratorian Canon is missing its first line, the fact that it identifies Luke and John as the third and fourth authors, respectively, implicitly supports the fact that Matthew and Mark authored the first and second Gospels, respectively. Outside of the Muratorian Canon, the early church unanimously agreed that the Gospel According to Matthew was, in fact, written by Matthew, and the Gospel According to Mark was, in fact, written by Mark.

Reasonably, the evangelists used different beginnings, although the one and the same purpose of evangelization is represented. Matthew, as writing to Hebrews, composed the order of the genealogy of Christ, so that he would show that Christ had descended from this progeny, from which all the prophets had foretold him to be born. Mark too declares the ancient qualifications of the prophet mystery of the coming of Christ, so that His preaching had been proven not to be new, but uttered from ancient times on account of that.

Polycarp of Smyrna (69-155 AD), Fragments from Victor Capua, section 3

‘This also [John] the Elder said, “Mark, having become the interpreter [scribe] of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he [Peter] remembered of the things said or done by Christ, for he [Mark] neither heard the Lord nor followed Him. However, afterward, as I said, he followed Peter, who adapted his teaching to the needs of the hearers, but with no intention of giving a connected account of the Lord’s discourses, so that Mark committed no error while he thus wrote some things as he [Peter] remembered them, for he [Peter] was careful of one thing, not to omit any of the things which he had heard and to not state any of them falsely.”’ These things are related by Papias concerning Mark. But, concerning Matthew, he [Papias] writes as follows, ‘So then, Matthew wrote the oracles in the Hebrew language, and everyone interpreted them as he was able.’

Eusebius of Caesarea (260-339 AD), quoting Papias of Hierapolis (c. 60-130 AD) in Church History, book 3, chapter 39, sections 15-16

It doesn’t get any older than that in church history. You have the Muratorian Fragment, Polycarp, and Papias all saying in the early second century (at the latest) that Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John are the authors of the Gospels. Matthew and John were Apostles. Mark interviewed Peter, an Apostle, and Luke interviewed multiple eyewitnesses of Jesus’ ministry, which undoubtedly would’ve included some Apostles. Therefore, the idea that men pseudonymously claimed to be Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John and wrote Gospels in their names in the latter half of the first century (or even in the second century) is, frankly, absurd. Likewise, the idea that random men wrote Gospels decades after Jesus’ ministry, and the Church deceptively ascribed these Gospels to the Apostles is, frankly, absurd.

The early Church identified the authors of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John only a few decades (early 2nd century AD) after they wrote their Gospels (50s and 60s AD). I can guarantee that if I wrote a book and claimed to be Martyn Lloyd-Jones, no one would believe me. I can also guarantee that if I wrote a book, no one could get away with ascribing my work to Martyn Lloyd-Jones. Why? Because I live only a few decades after Martyn Lloyd-Jones died. The corpus of his writings is complete and known, and thinking that someone could add to his corpus a couple decades later and get away with it is as absurd as thinking men pretended to be the Apostles a few decades after their deaths and got away with it. It’s a conspiracy theory of elephantine proportions to think Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were written by anyone other than the Apostles and their contemporaries. Their accounts of Jesus the Messiah are 100% reliable. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *