Difficult Passage: Romans 9:14-18

Difficult Passage: Romans 9:14-18

In our study through Romans 9:6-13, we saw Paul’s response to the objection, “If Jesus is the Christ, then why do majority of Jews, the supposed ‘people of God,’ reject Him as their Savior and King?” His response was, “Why do you expect the Jews to be saved? After all, Abraham’s firstborn son, Ishmael, wasn’t saved, and neither was Jacob’s twin brother, Esau. Salvation has always depended upon God’s sovereign and unconditional election and effectual calling.” However, Paul’s answer to that objection undoubtedly raised another objection in the minds of his opponents, and that objection is what Paul had to deal with in Romans 9:14.

What shall we say then? Is there injustice on God’s part? By no means!

Romans 9:14

In response to unconditional election and irresistible grace, the natural response of the natural man is, “That’s not fair!” That’s true today, and that was true in Paul’s day. The sinful human nature despises the idea that salvation is entirely dependent upon God’s grace, not our cooperation. Upon hearing that whether or not someone is saved is based entirely on God’s sovereign grace, the non-believer reacts instinctually by saying, “That’s unjust!” To that accusation, Paul said the most emphatic form of denial in Greek (mē genētai, “Absolutely not!”), and then said this in verse 15:

For He says to Moses, ‘I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.’

Romans 9:15

Paul’s response to the accusation of injustice was a simple citation from the Old Testament that demonstrates the nature of grace, mercy, and compassion. Ironically, while Paul’s opponents seemingly wanted justice, they really didn’t. After all, if God were simply just, then every single individual who has ever been conceived would be condemned to eternal torment in hell. We don’t want justice in that sense, and thankfully, grace and mercy and compassion transcend justice. God can have mercy and compassion (literally, “I mercy whom I mercy, and I compassion whom I compassion”) on whomever He chooses. The question is not, “How can God be so unfair by only showing grace and mercy to some but not all?!” The real question is, “How can God be so unfair by showing grace and mercy to anyone?!” No one deserves grace after all. Grace, mercy, and compassion cannot be demanded. There is nothing constraining God to be gracious and merciful and compassionate. Rather, He is free to demonstrate those attributes as He wills, just as Romans 9:16 says.

So then, it does not depend on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy.

Romans 9:16

Whether or not God shows mercy, grace, and compassion on someone has nothing to do with the individual. It doesn’t depend on whether or not the person desires mercy (literally “the one willing”). It doesn’t depend on whether or not the person strives for mercy (literally, “the one running”). Whether or not someone receives mercy is entirely dependent upon God’s choice. He can show mercy to anyone He desires in order to magnify His grace, and He can harden anyone He desires in order to magnify His justice, just as Romans 9:17 says.

For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I have raised you up, so that I might show My power in you, and so that My name might be proclaimed in all the earth.’

Romans 9:17

If you think about it, Pharaoh got the rough end of the deal. He drew the proverbial short straw. God sent Moses and Aaron to rebuke him. God sent plagues upon his nation, including the death of his firstborn son. God hardened his heart, so that he would refuse to let the Jews go, and God destroyed his army in the Red Sea. At this point, there are two questions we must ask: Was it just for God to do that to Pharaoh, and why did God do that to him?

Was it just for God to do what He did to Pharaoh? Absolutely, it was. Pharaoh was a sinner after all. He deserved God’s wrath, justice, and death. Therefore, God was free to punish him in whatever way He saw fit. As we read in Exodus, God saw fit to punish Pharaoh by rebuking him via Moses and Aaron, by sending the ten plagues on Egypt, by hardening his heart, and by destroying his army, which would’ve been the most powerful standing army in the world at that time. Yes, it was just for God to humiliate Pharaoh in that way, but why did God do that to him? The answer is simple: to glorify Himself. God glorified His power and justice by what transpired in Egypt some 3,500 years ago. Ultimately, that is the answer to the question, “Why does God show mercy to some and justice to others?” The answer is simply that God’s will is to glorify Himself in both demonstrating mercy and justice, just as verse 18 says.

So then, He has mercy on whomever He wills, and He hardens whomever He wills.

Romans 9:18

God is free to lavish His mercy on anyone He desires, and He is free to dispense His justice on anyone He desires. Whether or not someone receives mercy or grace is entirely dependent on God’s choice, not ours. If someone asked us the question, “Why are you saved, but that guy isn’t?” and if we responded by saying, “Well, God wants to save everyone but leaves the decision up to each individual,” then we’ve actually robbed God of the ascribed glory He deserves. By answering that way, we’re saying that God is not free to show mercy or justice on whomever He desires. In essence, we’re saying that God is a slave to the human will by answering that way. Instead, we should answer that question by saying, “God for some reason saw fit to show mercy on me, a sinner, who deserves nothing but justice and wrath.” That is the proper answer to the question, “Why are some saved, but not all?”

Undoubtedly, there are many who read that explanation and gnash their teeth at God. There are many who read that answer and decry God as being unfair and unjust. Ironically, they’re not alone, and it’s those kinds of objections that Paul will deal with in next week’s installment of Difficult Passages when we finish up Romans 9. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *