When we read Scripture and formulate our theology and our view of the world, it’s always good to make sure we’re not going off the beaten path of church history. Church history does not establish doctrine. Rather, it acts as guide rails to make sure the doctrines you believe Scripture teaches are true. If you’re the only person in 2,000 years of church history who believes something, then you’re almost guaranteed wrong. The Holy Spirit would’ve revealed that truth to someone along the way. This concept is relevant to the topic of the past few sermons, which is perseverance.
Are good works necessary to demonstrate that someone is a true disciple of Christ and not just a false convert? If PCC and the rest of the Reformed churches are correct, then the answer to that question is a boldfaced “Yes!” However, if church history (especially the church fathers of the first five centuries of the Church) universally taught the opposite—that someone who professes faith in Jesus Christ can also continually sin, not do good works, and deny Jesus and still be a true disciple of Christ—then the Reformed community would have to pause and reevaluate. Thankfully, it’s the other way around. The early church uniformly taught that good works are a necessary evidence of saving faith. It is those who affirm the doctrine of free/cheap grace that must pause and reevaluate in light of church history.
Every prophet who teaches the truth but fails to practice what he preaches is a false prophet.
The Didache 11:10
The Didache is arguably the earliest non-inspired writing of the Church that we have, and it affirmed the concept of false converts based on works. Even if someone has perfect theology, even if someone has a correct gospel, even if someone is a great preacher but does not have good works, then his confession of faith does not matter. It is an illegitimate confession. He is a false convert. Clement of Rome argued a similar concept for the layperson in his epistle to the Corinthians, which is arguably the second-oldest non-inspired writing of the Church that we have.
We should clothe ourselves with concord, being humble, self-controlled, far removed from all gossiping and slandering, and justified by our deeds, not by words.
1 Clement 30:3
Lest you think that Clement actually taught that our obedience to the Law justifies us, let me provide another quote from him and from James to show how the word “justified” can be used.
We, having been called through His will in Jesus Christ, are not justified through ourselves or through our own wisdom or understanding or piety or works, which we wrought in holiness of heart, but through faith, whereby the Almighty God justified all men that have been [called] from the beginning, to Whom be the glory forever and ever.
1 Clement 32:4
How could Clement have said we “are justified … through faith,” and we are “justified by our deeds” in the same letter? The answer lies in how James used the word “justification”.
Was not Abraham, our father, justified by works when he offered up Isaac on the altar? You see that faith was active along with his works, and faith was completed by his works. The Scripture was fulfilled that says, ‘Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him as righteousness,’ and he was a friend of God. You see that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.
James 2:21-24
James does not teach that someone is forgiven of his/her sins based on works. Rather, in the context, he is saying that works are what justify someone’s claim to believing in Jesus (cf. James 2:14). Someone is justified when they claim to believe in Jesus if they also have good works. If someone claims to be justified by faith, but they have no works, then their claim to faith is illegitimate. Works are necessary for faith to be legitimate. Therefore, a person’s faith is justified/vindicated by works. This is why I said yesterday that justification is completely unrelated to nor dependent on works, but faith is. That is what James taught, and that is what Clement taught too. Those who are humble, self-controlled, and removed from gossip and slander behave in such a way that their profession of faith is justified. On the flip side, if those qualities are not present in a person, then Clement would say that individual is not justified. Their profession of faith would be illegitimate. Fast forwarding to the second century, the same concept is taught.
It’s not just that the early teachers in the church taught that good works are a necessary evidence of saving faith, AKA Lordship salvation/perseverance of the saints. It’s also that to my knowledge, no one in the first 500 years of the Church taught that someone can profess faith in Jesus Christ, continue in unrepentant sin, and still have a legitimate confession of faith, AKA free/cheap grace. These are just three of the early Christian teachers too. I could cite early church fathers, like Aristides of Athens, Theophilus of Antioch, Lactantius of North Africa, and Eusebius of Caesarea, as well as the Apostolic Traditions document. I could cite the Reformers, like John Calvin, William Farel, Theodore Beza, John Knox, and so on. When the Church has spoken so consistently in the church fathers and the Reformation, it’s probably best that we listen. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments