Difficult Passage: Matthew 23:37

Difficult Passage: Matthew 23:37

Last week, we saw that 1 Timothy 2:3-4 doesn’t actually teach that God wants to save all people without exception. Rather, God wants to save all people without distinction, meaning Jews or Gentiles and rich or poor and rulers or citizens. 1 Timothy 2:3-4 is just one of many verses that people cite in order to prove their belief that God wants to save every single person who’s ever existed on planet Earth. 1 Timothy 2:3-4 is probably the most commonly cited. It’s a close second between Matthew 23:37 and 2 Peter 3:9 though, so let’s address Matthew 23:37 first before addressing 2 Peter 3:9 next week. Why is Matthew 23:37 cited so frequently by those trying to prove that God wants to save everyone without exception and leaves the decision of salvation up to an individual’s free will? Let’s start by looking at the verse itself.

O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it, how often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!

Matthew 23:37

One of the reasons why this verse seems so compelling to those who believe God wants to save every individual who’s ever lived is because it’s often misquoted. There are many examples in the free-will camp who misquote the verse, including Jacob Arminius (Works, volume 3, allegation 4) and John Wesley (Sermon 128) and Charles Finney (Sermon 8). That’s unsurprising though, since these men affirm free will and have incentive to find verses that support their view. However, there are even Reformed men who misquote the verse (though they don’t misapply it, thankfully), including Matthew Henry (Commentary on the Whole Bible, commentary on Exodus 6:10-13) and Charles Spurgeon (Sermons 76, 386, 1031). How do people misquote this verse? It almost comes out this way:

O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it, how often would I have gathered you together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!

Matthew 23:37

Did you catch the two missing words in the misquote? When people misquote this verse, they almost always leave out the words “your children,” which might not seem like a big deal. However, in context, it is a massive deal. If the words “your children” were missing, then this verse would be incredibly problematic for those who do not believe God is trying to save every single individual (myself included). This verse would be teaching that Jesus is trying to save people, but their lack of cooperation thwarts His efforts. However, the presence of the words “your children” shifts the meaning in a surprising way.

Just as with 1 Timothy 2:3-4, the real extent of God’s desire to save people is found in the context. Matthew 23:37 does not exist in a vacuum. It follows Jesus’ very lengthy lambast of the Pharisees and scribes (the hypocritical, self-righteous religious leaders of Israel who hated Jesus). Between Matthew 23:13 and Matthew 23:36, Jesus calls the Pharisees and scribes hypocrites no less than eight times and condemns them for various reasons. The first reason is the most important in this discussion though, when Jesus says this:

Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you shut the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. You neither enter yourselves nor allow those who would enter to go in.

Matthew 23:13

If you pay attention to how men in Scripture outline their points, they often employ a style called “bookending.” What this means is this: they begin and end on the same topic to bring the argument full circle. It’s very effective and is probably something I should use more in my sermons because it’s very punchy. I believe that’s what Jesus is doing in Matthew 23. Matthew 23:13 begins by rebuking the Pharisees and scribes for attempting to hinder the laypeople of Israel from entering the kingdom, from being saved. At the end of Jesus’ rebuke, Matthew 23:37 ends by rebuking Jerusalem (the Pharisees and scribes, who led Jerusalem) for attempting to hinder the children of Jerusalem (the laypeople of Israel) from gathering to Jesus (entering the kingdom/being saved). Let me go through Matthew 23:37 with this parallel in mind, so that it can make more sense.

When Jesus rebukes “Jerusalem” in Matthew 23:37, He is continuing His rebuke of the Pharisees and scribes. The context supports this. Furthermore, the Pharisees and scribes were the religious leaders of Israel who led from the city of Jerusalem. Therefore, it makes sense for Jesus’ rebuke of “Jerusalem” to be aimed at the Pharisees and scribes. That’s the first party referenced in Matthew 23:37: the scribes and Pharisees, who led Jerusalem. The second party referenced in Matthew 23:37 is Jesus. There’s no debate about this. When Jesus says, “How often would I have gathered your children together,” everyone agrees that “I” refers to Jesus. Where there is debate (or rather, a lack of recognition on the part of those who affirm free will) is over the identity of “your children.”

Those who affirm free will either ignore the phrase “your children” or simply lump “your children” together with “Jerusalem” and define them as “all Jews.” They would say “Jerusalem” and “your children” both refer to the object of Jesus’ desire to save. Thus, they think Jesus wants to save all Jews, but since many Jews use their free will to reject Jesus, He can’t save them. However, I do not believe that is a fair interpretation of the text. That interpretation ignores the delineation that Jesus makes between “Jerusalem” and Jerusalem’s “children.” If “Jerusalem” and Jerusalem’s “children” refer to the same group, then why does Jesus differentiate them? I believe it’s because He’s making a distinction.

Jesus distinguished between the laypeople of Israel (Jerusalem’s children) and the religious leaders of Israel (Jerusalem). In Matthew 23:37, He is rebuking the religious leaders (Jerusalem) for not being willing to allow the laypeople of Israel (Jerusalem’s children) to gather to Jesus (to enter the kingdom/be saved). Therefore, this verse has nothing to do with whether or not human free will can thwart God’s will to save people. It simply says that the Pharisees and scribes tried to stop the laypeople of Israel from being saved by Jesus. It doesn’t say anything about how successful they are at thwarting salvation, and it doesn’t say anything about how successful Jesus is at saving people. It doesn’t say anything about free will or whether or not our free will can stop God from saving those He wants to save. That’s not the point of the passage. The point of the passage is simply to rebuke the religious leaders for not wanting the masses to be saved.

This is the danger of prooftexting. When we are determined to prove our own position, we want to find verses that support our position. This is a good desire. After all, Christians want to be biblical. However, if we begin with our own position and go to the Bible to prove it (rather than letting the Bible speak for itself), we can easily fall into the trap of taking a verse out of context. We can even go to the extent of misquoting and misreading Scripture in order to make it fit with our own preconceived notions. Instead of trying to conform Jesus’ teachings to our own beliefs, we need to make sure that we conform our beliefs to what Jesus teaches, even if it means we might have to adjust our theology a little. It’s worth it. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *