If someone asked you, “In what ways was Jesus human and divine?” what would you say? Thankfully, you don’t have to reinvent the wheel in order to answer that question. There was a massive debate back in the day regarding the relationship between Jesus’ divine and human natures. The names are tricky, and the teachings can be even trickier.
Eutyches (c. 380-456) taught that Jesus’ divine nature took on a human nature and became an all new nature. This is called Eutychianism or Monophysitism because this teaching says Jesus only has one (mono) nature (physis), a new nature that blended His divine and human natures.
Nestorius (c. 386-450) taught that Jesus’ divine nature and human nature stayed so separate that He was actually two persons controlling one body. This is called Nestorianism or Radical Dyophysitism because this teaching says Jesus has two (duo) natures (physis) that are so radically separate that Jesus is two persons, one divine and one human.
Apollinaris (c. ?-382) taught that Jesus’ divine nature assumed a human nature and remained distinct, but Jesus’ human nature consisted only of a physical body. This is called Apollinarism or, somewhat amusingly, “God in a bod” since Apollinarism says Jesus was a divine spirit in a human body.
How would you refute these teachings? Would you refute them, or do you agree with one of them? These teachings might surprise you today, but they were immensely divisive one-and-a-half millennia ago. In fact, they were so divisive that they warranted their own retaliatory council and creed, the Chalcedonian Creed.
Following, then, the holy fathers, we all unanimously teach that our Lord Jesus Christ is to us one and the same Son, the self-same perfect in Godhead, the self-same perfect in Manhood, truly God and truly man, the self-same a rational soul and body, co-essential with the Father according to the Godhead, the self-same co-essential with us according to Manhood, like us in all things apart from sin, begotten before the ages by the Father as to the Godhead, but in the last days for us and for our salvation the self-same [was begotten] by Mary the virgin, mother of God as to the Manhood, one and the same Christ and Son and Lord only-begotten, acknowledged in two natures unconfusedly and unchangeably and indivisibly and inseparably, the difference of the natures being in no way removed because of the union, but rather the properties of each nature being preserved, concurring into one person and one hypostasis, not as though He was parted or divided into two persons, but one and the self-same Son and only-begotten God and Word and Lord, Jesus Christ, even as from the beginning the prophets have taught concerning Him, and as the Lord Jesus Christ Himself has taught us, and as the symbol of the fathers has handed down to us.
Chalcedonian Creed
Do you see how this creed singlehandedly precludes any orthodox Christian today from being an Apollinarian, Eutychian, or Nestorian? Do you see how this creed answers the question, “In what ways was Jesus divine and human?”
These phrases preclude someone from believing Jesus’ divine and human natures blended into a new nature:
- “Truly God and truly man.”
- ”Acknowledged in two natures unconfusedly and unchangeably and indivisibly and inseparably.”
- ”The differences of the natures being in no way removed because of the union, but rather the properties of each nature being preserved.”
These phrases preclude someone from believing Jesus’ divine and human natures resulted in two separate persons:
- “Our Lord Jesus Christ is to us one and the same Son.”
- ”The self-same perfect in Godhead, the self-same perfect in Manhood.”
- ”Co-essential with the Father according to the Godhead, the self-same co-essential with us according to the Manhood.”
- ”Before the ages begotten of the Father as to the Godhead, but in the last days for us and for our salvation the self-same [was begotten] by Mary the virgin.”
- ”Mother of God as to the Manhood, one and the same Christ and Son and Lord, only-begotten.”
- ”One and the self-same Son and only-begotten God and Word and Lord, Jesus Christ.”
- ”Concurring into one person and one hypostasis, not as though He was parted or divided into two persons.”
These phrases preclude someone from believing Jesus’ human nature consisted only of a body:
- “The self-same of a rational soul and body.”
- ”Like us in all things apart from sin.”
To be a Christian, you must affirm these truths. Jesus has two natures, one truly divine and one truly human. Jesus’ two natures did not blend in any way, but rather remained distinct yet eternally unified in one person. To be truly God, Jesus partakes of the same perfections as the Father and Spirit. To be truly human, Jesus partakes of the same physical body and immaterial soul as humanity. This is the only way He could affect the salvation of humans in the sight of God in these last days. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments