This past Sunday, we saw Jesus say that He came “not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.” One way to apply this statement today is by being selective regarding who we call to repent and follow Jesus. If someone is self-righteous, like the Pharisees, then it is best to withhold the good news of the gospel. It is best to not cast our “pearls before swine.” Instead, they need to be convicted and rebuked, which is exactly how Jesus interacted with the Pharisees on so many occasions. On the other hand, for those who are broken, such as Matthew the tax collector, the good news should go to them. This is the biblical practice.
Peter convicted his arrogant Jewish audiences in Acts 2 and 3 by declaring them to be murderers, but he did not convict his humble Gentile audience in Acts 10. Stephen convicted his arrogant Jewish audience in Acts 7 by declaring from history their rebellion against God. Paul convicted his arrogant Jewish audience in Acts 13 by declaring them to be murderers. He also convicted the arrogant Gentile audience in Acts 17 by declaring them to be ignorant, but he did not convict the humble jailor in Acts 16. To preach the gospel biblically, we begin with bad news when someone is arrogant, but then shift to the good news when someone is humble. However, this philosophy could result in an accusation.
Hyper-Calvinism is a broad spectrum of theology held to by very zealous Calvinists, but every hyper-Calvinist has this in common: they do not believe you should preach the gospel to anyone until you see evidences of regeneration in his or her life. They do not believe in the indiscriminate preaching of the gospel, lest the non-believer trample on the good news. Thus, they wait until they see evidences of regeneration, and only then do they preach the gospel. It is possible for someone to read what I’ve said above and conclude I’m a hyper-Calvinist, but that would be a false accusation for multiple reasons.
The first and primary response to that accusation is that I do not believe regeneration can occur except when the gospel is preached. A hyper-Calvinist believes that regeneration can occur willy-nilly at a random time, and that it is our job as Christians to search for those who have already been regenerated, so that we can preach the gospel to them. However, this is unbiblical, because Scriptures teaches that people are only regenerated while hearing the gospel.
You have been born again, not of perishable seed, but of imperishable, through the living and abiding word of God, … and this word is the good news that was preached to you.
1 Peter 1:23, 25
No one can be born again until they hear the gospel. Anyone who affirms that statement is automatically disqualified from being a hyper-Calvinist. Furthermore, I do not believe that we should wait for evidences of regeneration before preaching the gospel. Rather, we are to simply gauge the individual’s receptiveness to the truth. If the individual is hostile, then end the conversation. However, if the individual is inquisitive and convicted, then tell them about Jesus and offer them forgiveness of sins. However, this advice only pertains to individuals. What about crowds?
A consistent hyper-Calvinist cannot preach the gospel to a crowd of non-believers. After all, how can he know if everyone in the crowd has been regenerated yet? On the contrary, normal Calvinists (like myself) highly encourage the preaching of the gospel in public forums. The more people who can hear the gospel, the better. In the case of a crowd, conviction is always the best place to start since there are likely arrogant sinners in the crowd. Nevertheless, this is something a hyper-Calvinist would not do.
In light of these distinctions, what was espoused yesterday is not hyper-Calvinism. We do not wait for someone to be regenerated before preaching the gospel, and we do not withhold the gospel from crowds. Rather, we preach the gospel indiscriminately with the goal of bringing about regeneration. After all, regeneration is the only means by which a spiritually dead sinner can come alive spiritually and believe the gospel. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments