Systematic Theology: Foreknowledge

Systematic Theology: Foreknowledge

Now that we know the basic order of salvation according to Scripture, it only makes sense to start with the first act of God in the long chain of redemption. Specifically, I’m referring to God “foreknowing” people. This act of God comes logically even before God’s act of election–which according to Ephesians 1:4 occurred “before the foundation of the world”–because Romans 8:29 says, “Those whom [God] foreknew, He also predestined.” Therefore, since God’s act of foreknowing is the very first element of salvation, we must define it correctly. If we incorrectly define “foreknow” in Romans 8:29 and “foreknowledge” in 1 Peter 1:2, then the rest of our soteriology–our doctrine of salvation–will be askew. Just as a house with a slanted foundation is doomed to be off kilter, so too is our theology doomed to be off kilter if our foundation of soteriology is incorrect. With that said, what does it mean when Romans 8:29 says, “Those whom He foreknew, He predestined,” and when 1 Peter 1:2 says we are elect “according to the foreknowledge of God the Father”?

Some would have you believe that the extent of God’s foreknowledge is actions. Put simply, many people say, “Since God is eternal and timeless, He foreknew that I would freely choose to believe the gospel, so He consequently chose to save me.” To use a dated analogy to describe this view, God analyzed the VHS’s magnetic tape to see what would happen in the movie, then rewound the VHS’s tape back to the start and hit play. In this theory, God didn’t determine the events that happen in the movie, the events that happen in time. Rather, He knew what we would do and acted accordingly. This view is common among those who insist on libertarian free will, which is the belief that people can only be held accountable for their actions if their actions are not predestined by God. Ignoring the logical inconsistencies of asserting that God looked forward into time to see what would happen, then decided to let what He saw happen (as if time and space can teach God before He even created it), this definition of “foreknow” is unfaithful to the text.

Whenever Scripture uses the verb “to foreknow” with God as the subject, the object of the verb is always a person or people. Romans 8:29 doesn’t say that God foreknew what people would do. Instead, it says He foreknew people. Likewise, 1 Peter 1:20 and Romans 11:2 use the verb “foreknow” to describe God’s relationship with people.

God has not rejected His people whom He foreknew. Do you not know what the Scripture says of Elijah, how he appeals to God against Israel? ‘Lord, they have killed your prophets. They have demolished your altars. I alone am left, and they seek my life.’ However, what is God’s reply to him? ‘I have kept for myself seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to Baal.’ So too, at the present time, there is a remnant, chosen by grace.

Romans 11:2-5

[Jesus] was foreknown before the foundation of the world, but was made manifest at the last times for your sake.

1 Peter 1:20

These two texts shed much light on the definition of “foreknow” when God is the subject. God the Father didn’t look down the corridors of time, see what Jesus would do, and then go, “Sweet! I’ll run with that plan.” No, Scripture tells us that everything Jesus did was foreordained by the Father, not the Son. Therefore, we can conclude that 1 Peter 1:20 isn’t teaching that God foreknows actions, but rather that He foreknows people, specifically Jesus. Likewise, Paul says that God “foreknew” the remnant of Israel in Elijah’s time.

We know that he cannot be saying, “God foreknew that these people would stay faithful to Him by their own free will,” because of how Paul and God describe the remnant’s relationship with God. Paul says the remnant were only the remnant because they were “chosen by grace.” God says the remnant were only the remnant because He “kept for [Him]self seven thousand.” Could there have been 7,001 if another person had freely chosen to stay faithful? How about 6,999? Was the number of the remnant fluid and dependent upon the individuals, or set in stone and dependent upon God? The answer is obviously God. Otherwise, He could not say, “I have kept for Myself seven thousand.” Instead, He would have to say, “I have been allowed to keep seven thousand people because they cooperated.” Once again, we’re left with the conclusion that “foreknow” does not refer to actions. Instead, God “foreknowing” the remnant is what caused them to be the remnant, “chosen by grace.” With all that said, what does it mean for God to “foreknow”? The answer is found in a Jewish idiom. Jews frequently used the verb “know” in a special, covenantal sense.

Adam knew his wife, Eve, and she conceived and bore Cain.

Genesis 4:1

The verb “to know” in Hebrew can mean merely intellectual ascent, but in specific contexts, it can mean “covenantal love,” such as a husband’s love for his wife in Genesis 4:1. This concept is further established by how the Old Testament uses the verb “to know” with God. Whenever He is the subject, and when people are the object, the text is describing an intimate, covenantal love that God has for the individual/people.

Yahweh said to Moses, ‘I will do this very thing that you have spoken, for you have found favor in My sight, and I know you by name.’

Exodus 33:17

You [Israel] only have I known of all the families of the earth.

Amos 3:2

Clearly, the verb “to know” does not refer to intellectual ascent here. After all, God is intellectually aware of all the nations of the earth, not just Israel. God is omniscient of course. Likewise, if intellectual ascent is all that’s in view of the verb “to know,” then God’s comment that He knows Moses by name is unimpressive and meaningless. God is intellectually aware of everyone’s name who’s ever existed. Therefore, we know that “know” must mean more than intellectual ascent when God is the subject and people are the object. I propose it is best to define “know” when God is the subject and people are the object as “love.” This makes perfect sense with what we just read. “Israel, you alone have I loved of all the families of the earth.” “Adam love his wife, Eve, and she conceived and bore Cain.” It makes perfect sense.

With this conclusion in mind, we can start to formulate a robust definition of the verb “to foreknow.” I propose that when God is the subject, and when people are the object, the concept of “fore-love” is in view. When God “foreknew” Jesus in 1 Peter 1:20, He loved the man Jesus before He was even incarnate. When God “foreknew” the remnant of Israel in Romans 11:2-5, He loved them beforehand, and that’s why He chose to keep them as His remnant. This isn’t a new concept either. The idea of God loving people in a covenantal way before they even exist is an Old Testament concept too.

Before I formed you [Jeremiah] in the womb, I knew you.

Jeremiah 1:5

Again, this statement is absolutely meaningless if God only meant, “Before you were born, I was intellectually aware that you, Jeremiah, would exist.” God could say that to any person that’s ever been born. The whole point of Jeremiah 1:5 is to establish that God’s special, covenantal love with Jeremiah has always existed. That’s why God can say He knew/loved Jeremiah before he was even born. Therefore, it is best to define the verbs “to know” and “to foreknow” when God is the subject as “to love” and to “fore-love.” With this definition in mind, we can interpret Romans 8:29.

When Romans 8:29 says, “Those whom He foreknew, He predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son,” it’s not teaching that God predestines people to be like Jesus because He intellectually knows that’s what they want. Rather, it’s teaching that God predestines people to be like Jesus because of His covenantal, intimate love for them. Romans 8:29 teaches that God’s foreknowing of individuals is the cause of them believing the gospel, rather than the alternate interpretation, which is that God’s foreknowing of individuals is the response to them believing the gospel.

God foreknowing His people is the foundation of salvation according to Romans 8:29, and when we correctly define “foreknow” as “fore-love,” we see that salvation is a result of God’s sovereign choice to love certain individuals with a covenantal love. In Scripture, whenever God “knows” a person, it’s a description of His intimate love toward them. Therefore, whenever God “foreknows” a person/people, it’s a description of His intimate love toward them before they even existed. Our salvation as the elect is certain because God has loved us before He created the universe. That is the foundation of soteriology on which all other aspects are built, such as the doctrine of election, as we’ll see next week. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published.