Systematic Theology: Annihilationism

Systematic Theology: Annihilationism

Over the past few months, I’ve been chugging along through systematic theology systematically (shocking). We saw what the Bible is, and we’re finishing up who God is. However, I want to deviate this week to talk about a different topic, and Lord willing, you’ll see why I deviated in the near future. I want to deviate by talking about annihilationism. Annihilationism is the idea that both the body and soul of a person are only conditionally immortal (hence, why annihilationism can also be referred to as conditional immortality). Essentially, annihilationism teaches that unless God intervenes with providential sustenance, then both the body and soul would cease to exist on judgment day. Thus, to an annihilationist, the dichotomy is between eternal life (becoming immortal in the kingdom by God’s sustenance) and eternal punishment (ceasing to exist after being cast into hell in the final judgment in God’s wrath). That’s basically how annihilationists would explain the nature of human immortality and the final judgment. Humans are conditionally immortal, and since God does not continue to sustain the wicked on judgment day, but rather kills them, the wicked will cease to exist. They will be annihilated in hell, hence, annihilationism. This is in contrast with the traditional view today (which I and anyone who affirms the 1689 LBCF believe), which says hell will be a place of eternal conscious torment for the wicked, whose suffering will never cease. I want to give my relatively brief, preliminary (though thorough) thoughts on why I not only reject annihilationism, but consider it incompatible with the gospel and, therefore, heresy.

One of the best arguments that annihilationists will use is the concept of “death” in the Scriptures. The final judgment and the final state of the wicked are frequently referred to as a “death” experience (Isaiah 66 comes to mind). The annihilationist sees “death” as a strong argument for cessation from existence, taking the term more literally. They say death today happens in a moment and brings your current bodily existence to an end, and so will the final death bring you to a bodily and spiritual end. However, those of us who affirm that hell will be an experience of eternal conscious torment for the wicked, we believe “death” refers more to the eternal experience and relationship the wicked have with God, rather than to finality and cessation from existence. I believe there is good reason to take “death” in the final judgment as referring to one’s experience and relationship with God in hell for eternity, rather than one’s final cessation from existence in hell. John 8 and 10 and Koine Greek are where I would go to prove this.

Truly, truly, I say to you, if anyone keeps My word, then he will never see death.

John 8:51

I give them eternal life, and they will never perish.

John 10:28

In both of those verses, the same construction is used in Koine Greek. In both, John uses the negative particles ou and mé together. In Greek, a double negative does not make a positive. Rather, a double negative makes an emphatic negative, and that’s what John did in both verses. Not only that, but John also used a verb in the subjunctive mood in both contexts. In Greek, this is one of the most emphatic ways to communicate that something will never happen, in this case, that the righteous sheep could die. This is explained best by renowned New Testament scholar, Daniel Wallace.

One might think that the negative with the subjunctive could not be as strong as the negative with the indicative. However, while ou + the indative denies a certainty, ou mé + the subjunctive denies the potentiality. The negative is not weaker; rather, the affirmative that is being negatived is less firm with the subjunctive. Ou mé rule out even the idea as being a possibility.

Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics, page 468 [emphasis his]

This is problematic for the annihilationist, who says “death” does not refer to the spiritual separation and hostility between God and man in the eternal state, but rather refers to a person’s cessation of existence in the eternal state. Why is this problematic for them? Because Jesus says that His people will “never perish” and “never see death.” Obviously, Jesus’ people will see death. We die all the time in the physical sense. Therefore, Jesus must be referring to spiritual death. The righteous will never come under God’s wrath nor be separated from Him relationally. That statement is absolutely true. Therefore, in light of these two verses, we can conclude that “death” in the context of the final judgment does not refer to dying in a more literal sense, but rather to dying relationally and experientially under the wrath of God in a spiritual sense. This fits with the experiential contrasts between the righteous and the wicked on judgment day too.

Many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awaken, some to everlasting life, and some to everlasting shame and everlasting contempt.

Daniel 12:2

These [the wicked] will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.

Matthew 25:46

Notice the contrasts between the righteous’ and the wicked’s experiences on judgment day. The righteous will be resurrected to eternal life, whereas the wicked will be resurrected to eternal shame, punishment, and contempt. The annihilationist would say that “eternal life” refers to the righteous being granted the ability to be immortal, whereas the “eternal punishment/contempt/shame” for the wicked simply describes the finality and eternality of their verdict, rather than the eternality of their experience. After all, if the annihilationist is right, then the wicked can’t experience “shame,” “contempt,” and “punishment” forever because they will cease to exist after judgment day. These two verses are best understood the traditional way, however, as referring to eternal conscious torment.

We’ve already seen that “death” in the final judgment does not refer to traditional death. Otherwise, what Jesus said in John 8 and 10 makes no sense. Therefore, the contrast for the wicked and the righteous is not between traditional death and traditional life, but rather spiritual death and spiritual life. The eternal state is much more about how people experience it, rather than for how long they experience it. On judgment day, the wicked will “die” spiritually. How so? They will be under the punishment and contempt and shame of the Godhead for eternity, which is experiential death. However, for the righteous they will be under the love and grace and mercy of the Godhead for eternity, which is experiential life. This is how these verses are best understood, and these verses are just a microcosm of why I am not an annihilationist.

Why do I believe annihilationism is not compatible with the gospel though? There’s a few reasons, some more straightforward than others. Let’s start with the gospel. The gospel is the message of salvation, and we cannot change it, lest we demonstrate that we are not actually justified, not actually part of the people of God.

Even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, then let him be accursed. As we have said before, so now I say again: If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, then let him be accursed.

Galatians 1:8-9

Anyone who preaches a different gospel than the true gospel of Jesus Christ is accursed, doomed to condemnation on the final day. Annihilationists and the rest of us affirm that truth. Therefore, if something is heresy, then it must explicitly or implicitly deny a fundamental tenant of the gospel. For example, the Judaizers in the book of Galatians were heretics because they explicitly denied a fundamental tenant of the gospel. They said justification is by circumcision and keeping the Law and faith, rather than the truth, which is that justification is by grace alone through faith alone. Therefore, they were heretics for denying the gospel explicitly. However, you can also be a heretic by denying the gospel implicitly.

If you talked to the ancient heretics Nestorius, Arius, Apollinarius, and Eutychus, their gospels probably would’ve sounded the same as the true gospel. They affirmed the explicit tenants of the gospel. However, each of them implicitly denied the gospel by changing the definition of a fundamental tenant to such an extent that they no longer actually affirmed that fundamental tenant. In their case, they all changed something about Jesus’ humanity or divinity to the point that Jesus was no longer the Son of God or the Son of Man. Arius detracted from Jesus’ deity by saying He wasn’t eternal like the Father. Eutychus detracted from Jesus’ deity by saying His human nature and His divine nature came together to form a third nature. Apollinarius detracted from Jesus’ humanity by saying He was essentially “God in a bod,” without a human mind. Nestorius detracted from Jesus’ divinity by saying the man Jesus is not the same person as God the Son.

What’s the point? Those men so misdefined who Jesus is that it resulted in them having different gospels implicitly. Sure, they might’ve said the same words as us when we preach the gospel, but in reality, they were speaking a different language. Jesus was a far different person than what is taught in Scripture. The same is true of annihilationism. Rather than misdefining Jesus (though I think there is a much greater propensity for annihilationists to change the nature of Jesus than the rest of us), they misdefine the final judgment to such an extent that it is unrecognizable from its biblical form, from the fundamental tenant taught in the gospel. Yes, the final judgment is part of the gospel.

Their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them on that day, when according to my gospel, God judges the secrets of men by Jesus Christ.

Romans 2:15-16

Here, Paul is referring to the final judgment, and he explicitly says the final judgment is part of “his gospel.” Paul’s gospel is no different than the gospel of Jesus Christ. Therefore, we must get the final judgment right, and I believe annihilationists have so misdefined the fundamental tenant of the final judgment that it is unrecognizable. In the same way Arius, Nestorius, Eutychus, and Apollinarius so misdefined Jesus that He was unrecognizable, so too do annihilationists misdefine the final judgment to the point of being heretics. They might use the same lingo, but that does not absolve them when you get down to the nitty gritty. Let me show you why by a few examples.

Mormons use very similar lingo to true Christianity. They talk about grace, faith, Jesus, and so on. However, have you ever studied their eschatology, their view of last things? They think the righteous can become their own version of God the Father with their own planet and their own creation. However, the wicked must remain single and despondent for eternity. Now, I hope everyone reading this can say, “That’s heresy.” But why? I propose to you that the Mormons have so misdefined the nature of the final judgment that they don’t actually affirm it, no matter how much they say they do. The final judgment is a fundamental tenant of the gospel, and to misdefine its nature is heresy, just as it’s heresy to misdefine the nature of Jesus Christ. That being said, what is the nature of the final judgment?

The final judgment according to Scripture is where Jesus returns from heaven, He resurrects the living and the dead, He enters into judgment with the living and the dead, He grants the righteous entrance into His kingdom forever, but He condemns the wicked to hell for an eternity of conscious torment. You might be thinking, “How can hell be eternal if sins are temporal?” To that, I say, “Why do you assume that people will stop sinning in hell?” Hell is described as a place of “weeping and gnashing of teeth” over and over again in Scripture. What does “gnashing of teeth” mean? It means hatred in Scripture.

He has torn me in his wrath and hated me. He has gnashed his teeth at me. My adversary sharpens his eyes against me.

Job 16:9

Like profane mockers at a feast, they gnash at me with their teeth.

Psalm 35:16

The wicked plots against the righteous and gnashes his teeth at him.

Psalm 37:12

The wicked man sees it and is angry. He gnashes his teeth and melts away. The desire of the wicked will perish!

Psalm 112:10

All your enemies rail against you. They hiss. They gnash their teeth.

Lamentations 2:16

Why is hell eternal? Because the wicked never repent. They continue to hate God and gnash their teeth at Him, even as they weep under the excruciating pain He is causing them. Why is hell eternal? Because justice will never be satisfied against the wicked. The punishment will always be playing catch-up to their sin. The wicked will continue to sin by hating God for all eternity, and that is why God will continue to punish them in hell for all eternity.

God doesn’t suspend His justice for sins that aren’t committed on earth. God can’t acquit the guilty, even in hell. Satan’s sins weren’t all committed on earth after all. I mean, the very first sin ever committed was not committed in a body nor committed on earth, and yet that sin was sufficient to damn Satan and his demons. If Satan’s first disembodied sin in heaven is punishable, then so are the sins committed by wicked in hell. Hell is a place of eternal torment where God’s justice and wrath and power will always be on full display. However, annihilationist deny this truth. They think the wicked will simply cease to exist. They believe it would be unjust for the wicked to be punished experientially forever. They think justice is simply death, cessation from existence. However, that fundamentally changes the nature of the final judgment. Let me give you an extreme example to prove my point.

I’m not aware of anyone who believes this, but let’s say someone said this: “‘Eternal life’ doesn’t mean you live forever in the kingdom. ‘Eternal life’ simply means you experience the bliss of God’s life temporarily after the final judgment before you cease to exist.” I hope everyone reading this concludes, “That would be heresy.” Why though? It’s heresy because it so fundamentally changes the final judgment that it is unrecognizable. Now, some of you will say, “But the Bible obviously doesn’t teach that the righteous cease to exist!” I know, but if someone asserted that’s what the Bible taught, then they’d be a heretic. The same is true of annihilationists, who pervert the other half of the final judgment. They do the exact same thing. I know they want to be biblical, but they turn eternal conscious torment into momentary torment and cessation. If it’s heretical to turn eternal conscious bliss into momentary bliss and cessation, then it is also heretical to turn eternal conscious torment into momentary torment and cessation.

Hell is a real place and a real and present threat to all who do not call upon the name of the Lord to be saved. I believe those who believe in annihilationism are heretics. They misdefine the final judgment to the point that it’s unrecognizable. The final judgment is a fundamental tenant of the gospel. Therefore, annihilationism is not compatible with the gospel. I believe their view of God’s justice and their view of human nature also potentially cause them to be heretical in other areas of the gospel, but this post is long enough as it is. I respect annihilationists. I know they think they’re being biblical, but so did Arius, Nestorius, Eutychus, and Apollinarius. We must get the gospel right, both explicitly and implicitly. Salvation and Jesus’ ascribed glory are at stake. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *