I mentioned that some pastors do not encourage Christians to look for typologies on their own when they read the Old Testament. They discourage looking for typologies in the Old Testament because that could result in allegorical interpretations. I didn’t have time to get into the differences and relationship between allegory and typology, which is why I want to correlate them here.
Allegory is defined this way:
A representation of an abstract or spiritual meaning through concrete or material forms; figurative treatment of one subject under guise of another.
Typology, on the other hand, is defined this way:
The doctrine or study of types or pure figurative symbols, especially in scriptural literature.
In a sense, all typological interpretations are a form of allegory, but not all allegorical interpretations are typologies. Typology is a specific type of allegory. For example, when I interpreted the story of David and Goliath as a typology, it was an allegorical interpretation. Seeing David as a type of Christ, Goliath as a type of sin, and the cowering Israelites as a type of the reader fits the definition of allegory. That interpretation is abstract (not clearly taught in the text). That interpretation unearths a spiritual meaning (Jesus’ spiritual victory over sin and death). That spiritual interpretation is based on material forms (David killing Goliath). Thus, typology is a form of allegory.
However, I would never tell someone plainly that I endorse allegorical interpretations. There is a simple reason why. Allegory extends beyond typology. Let me give you another example of an allegorical interpretation that is not a typological interpretation.
Augustine is famous for his allegorical interpretation of the parable of the Good Samaritan. To summarize, here’s how he interpreted the details:
- The wounded man represents the sinner
- The Samaritan represents Christ
- The robbers are Satan and his demons
- The inn represents the Church
- The innkeeper represents Paul
You might be thinking, “Isn’t that typology?” First, typology can only be found in the Old Testament. The New Testament plainly teaches about Jesus. Second, the context of the parable of the Good Samaritan precludes Augustine’s allegorical interpretation. The point of the parable is to prove to a scribe that he isn’t righteous enough on his own. The Samaritan in the parable is meant to symbolize the sinner, who must love every single person (even his enemies) in order to obey God’s Law. Parables are already symbolic by nature. It doesn’t make sense to symbolize the symbols in a parable.
Typology is an interpretation of the Old Testament that always points to Christ. Allegory is an interpretation of the New or Old Testaments that sometimes points to Christ (when it does, it is typology), but allegory sometimes points to other things. Typology never contradicts the context, but allegory sometimes contradicts the context. Thus, I support typology, but I do not support all forms of allegory.
As I said yesterday, I highly encourage you to fall down the rabbit hole that is typology. It radically changed how I interpret the Old Testament, and it caused me to both appreciate Jesus more (by seeing Him and His work everywhere) and the Holy Spirit more (by seeing how coherently He wrote the Scriptures through dozens of men over thousands of years). Lord willing, it will be beneficial for you as well. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments