Polemics: C. S. Lewis

Polemics: C. S. Lewis

There are two books I distinctly remember reading back in the day, two books that were almost considered mandatory reading for anyone who called themselves a Christian: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe and Mere Christianity. Both of these critically acclaimed books were written by none other than Clive Staples (C. S.) Lewis, an Anglican theologian who is referenced at some point from pretty much every pulpit it seems. However, just because a writer is critically acclaimed, and just because a writer is brilliant in his communication and imagination does not make him worth quoting.

The theology of C. S. Lewis is put on display in his book Mere Christianity. There, he drops the allegorical imagery that entranced us as children and switches to plain, systematic, theological language. However, this reveals a number of Lewis’ beliefs that might be surprising to the reader. First, Lewis was very opposed to the idea of penal substitutionary atonement:

Now, before I became a Christian, I was under the impression that the first thing Christians had to believe was one particular theory as to what the point of this dying [of Christ] was. According to that theory, God wanted to punish men for having deserted and joined the Great Rebel, but Christ volunteered to be punished instead, so that God let us off. Now, I admit that even this theory does not seem quite so immoral and silly as it used to. … The [theory] most people have heard is the one I mentioned before—the one about our being let off because Christ had volunteered to bear a punishment instead of us. Now, on the face of it, that is a very silly theory. If God was prepared to let us off, why on earth did He not do so? And what possible point could there be in punishing an innocent person? None at all that I can see, if you are thinking of punishment in the police-court sense.

Mere Christianity pages 57-59

The theory he scoffs at in Mere Christianity is penal substitutionary atonement, and while Lewis may think it to be silly, it would appear the Bible teaches this doctrine unashamedly:

He was pierced for our transgressions. He was crushed for our iniquities. Upon Him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and by His wounds we are healed.

Isaiah 53:5

It was the will of Yahweh to crush Him. He has put Him to grief. When His soul makes an offering for guilt, He shall see His offspring.

Isaiah 53:10

He became sin who knew no sin, so that we might become the righteousness of God.

2 Corinthians 5:21

He Himself bore our sins in His body on the tree, so that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. By His wounds you have been healed.

1 Peter 2:24

These verses all demonstrate that Jesus was pierced/crushed/chastised/wounded/grieved for our transgressions/iniquities/guilt/sin. That’s penal substitutionary atonement. That’s why Jesus begged the Father the night before His crucifixion:

My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from Me. Nevertheless, not as I will, but as You will.

Matthew 26:39

Jesus wasn’t dreading crucifixion. He wasn’t dreading death. He was dreading taking the wrath of the Father that sinners deserve, which is what the word “cup” symbolizes so many times in the Old and New Testaments (Isaiah 51:17, 22; Jeremiah 25:15-17, 28; 49:12; Ezekiel 23:31-33; Revelation 14:10; 16:19). Jesus knew His sacrificial death (atonement) to propitiate/satisfy the Father was going to include receiving punishment (penal) on behalf of sinners (substitutionary). That’s why He was in such distress before Good Friday. Lewis asked why God would do this though. Romans 3 provides a succinct answer.

God put forward [Jesus] as a propitiation by His blood to be received by faith. This was to show God’s righteousness because in His divine forbearance, He had passed over former sins. It was to show His righteousness at the present time, so that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.

Romans 3:25-26

That is the reason why God the Father had to punish Jesus, God the Son, in place of sinners. It was so He could be both just and the justifier of sinners. If God simply justified sinners without punishing a substitute, then He would not be just. He would be an abomination by His own standards (Proverbs 17:15). By punishing Jesus, the Father satisfied justice for those whom Jesus died in their place, thus allowing the Father to forgive them while still being the just God that He is by nature (Nahum 1:3).

In short, penal substitutionary atonement is the gospel. We can be forgiven because Jesus died on the cross in behalf of sin and rose from the dead (1 Corinthians 15:3-4). Does it make sense to positively quote someone who doesn’t understand the fundamentals of the gospel, like Lewis? This is especially true when he teaches other false doctrines like inclusivism, Purgatory, peccability of Jesus, errancy of Scripture. These are topics I don’t have time to refute, but I will provide quotes from Lewis to demonstrate that he did in fact teach these errors as well.

There are people who do not accept the full Christian doctrine about Christ, but who are so strongly attracted by Him that they are His on a much deeper sense than they themselves understand. There are people in other religions who are being led by God’s secret influence to concentrate on those parts of their religion which are in agreement with Christianity, and who thus belong to Christ without knowing it. For example, a Buddhist of good will may be led to concentrate more and more on the Buddhist teaching about mercy and to leave in the background (though might still say he believed in it) the Buddhist teaching on certain other points. Many of the good Pagans long before Christ’s birth may be in this position.

Mere Christianity page 178

Of course I pray for the dead. The action is so spontaneous, so all but inevitable, that only the most compulsive theological case against it would deter me. And I hardly know how the rest of my prayers would survive if those for the dead were forbidden. At our age, the majority of those we love best are dead. What sort of intercourse with God could I have if what I love best were unmentioned to him? I believe in Purgatory. Our souls demand Purgatory, don’t they? Would it not break the heart if God said to us, ‘It is true, my son, that your breath smells and your rags drip with mud and slime, but we are charitable here and no one will upbraid you with these things, nor draw away from you. Enter into the joy’? Should we not reply, ‘With submission, sir, and if there is no objection, I’d rather be cleansed first.’ ‘It may hurt you, you know’—‘Even so, sir.’

Letters to Malcom letter 20

Say what you like, the apocalyptic beliefs of the first Christians have been proved to be false. It is clear from the New Testament that they all expected the Second Coming in their own lifetime. And worse still, they had a reason, and one which you will find very embarrassing. Their Master has told them so. He shared, and indeed created, their delusion. He said in so many words, ‘This generation shall not pass till all these things be done.’ And he was wrong. He clearly knew no more about the end of the world than anyone else. It is certainly the most embarrassing verse in the Bible.

“The World’s Last Night”

The human qualities of the raw materials show through. Naivety, error, contradiction, even (as in the cursing Psalms) wickedness are not removed. The total result is not ‘the Word of God’ in the sense that every passage, in itself, gives impeccable science or history.

reflections on the Psalms pages 111-112

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *