Current Events: Beth Moore & White Supremacy

Current Events: Beth Moore & White Supremacy

It’s one of those weeks where most of us can agree that it would be better if Twitter didn’t exist. I guess that’s true of every week if you think about it. There’s something about limiting tweets/replies to 280 characters that makes conversations more prone to vitriol. One of the few positives to Twitter, however, is that some people brazenly throw their ideas out there for the world to see and take note of. That’s exactly what happened this past week with Beth Moore.

Beth Moore caused quite a stir just the other day. As of now, the first tweet of that thread alone has received a whopping 1,208 comments, 3,130 retweets, and 13,200+ likes, enough to make even Donald Trump’s social media rep green with envy. What did she say that caused such a stir?

The shoutout from Lecrae was just icing on the cake for this Relevant Saturday. You know it’s relevant if Lecrae gets involved. Basically, to summarize, here’s the stir she caused. Moore decries white supremacy and racism in the church and tells her audience to brace themselves because the white supremacists and racists will call them names. What names will they be called? “Marxist,” “liberal,” and “leftist.” She calls for her listeners to read the Old Testament prophets and what they have to say about injustice. She then says the white supremacists/racists who call people Marxists, liberals, and leftists produce terrible fruit. Why did this cause such a stir? Simple. Beth Moore has labeled anyone who disagrees with “woke” theology as a white supremacist and a racist.

That’s called poisoning the well by the way. When someone leads off their argument by labeling their opponent with pejoratives that haven’t been substantiated, they’ve poisoned the well. It’d be like me opening this blog post by saying, “Beth Moore, that crazy feminist sycophant, said this today…” That’s a true statement, but if I don’t substantiate it, then I’m only poisoning the well. If I did that, then I would be attempting to bias you against her without actually proving why you should be against her before we even analyze what she said. Let’s look at the facts, and then we’ll see if what Moore said is up to snuff.

White supremacists believe the Caucasian ethnicity is the superior ethnicity. Racists believe that their ethnicity (there is only one race) is the superiority ethnicity. It’s like a square and a rectangle. All white supremacists are racists, but not all racists are white supremacists. Yes, an African American can be racist. Some of the most racist people I know are African Americans, and the fact that many people today think minority ethnicities cannot be racist because they do not have social power is absurd. That’s neither here nor there though. With that definition of white supremacy and racism in mind, let’s see if what Moore said is true.

Who are the most well-known pastors and theologians who are decrying neo-Marxism, leftism, and liberalism infiltrating the church? Well, first, we have to see what those words even mean. Marxism is the idea that the social structures of society must be torn down because those in power have rigged the system in their favor. In the case of neo-Marxism, those in power today in America are straight, white, male, Christians, who must be deposed. Leftism is simply political support of the political left in America, as is liberalism, though liberalism also includes theological aspects, such as women pastors. I could prove that Beth Moore does in fact teach Marxism, leftism, and liberalism, but that’s not the point here. What is the point is her accusations, or rather, her false accusations.

Pastors and theologians who rail against those ideologies creeping into the church include John MacArthur, Phil Johnson, Todd Friel, James White, Voddie Baucham, Tom Buck, Tom Ascol, Josh Buice, Anthony Mathenia, Justin Peters, and many more. You know, “the good guys” who drafted “The Statement on Social Justice and the Gospel” back in 2018. Whether or not what they say is correct (it is), let’s just simply look at the character of these men. Are they white supremacists or racists? No. I challenge anyone to find me a quote from any one of these men that proves he is a white supremacist/racist. You’ll look long and hard, but you won’t find proof.

Therefore, when Moore says, “Don’t listen to anyone who calls you a Marxist, leftist, or a liberal because he is a white supremacist and a racist,” she is wrong. She is poisoning the well because she knows that she has no real response to the arguments levied against her. Consequently, she is forced by necessity to poison the well, to bias her readers against the critics who have very valid points.

May this be a reminder to let truth do the talking in a discussion. It tends to be more persuasive to the honest person than logical fallacies like poisoning the well, ad hominem, and the like. Plus, it’s not slander, which is always a good thing. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *