This past Sunday, we read Jesus’ words in Matthew 7:11, “If you, then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, then how much more will your Father, who is in heaven, give good things to those who ask Him?” I’ve heard many people use this verse to deny the teaching of total depravity, which teaches that the non-believer is completely incapable of doing anything good before God.
We saw biblically that this verse does not undermine total depravity. Romans 3:10-12 affirms that every single person prior to conversion is incapable of doing good, doing righteousness, or seeking God. We also saw contextually that the word “good” modifies the gift (fish and bread in this context), not the person or his intentions. Scripture affirms total depravity, and so does church history. Even one renowned pastor in church history, Augustine, addressed the topic of total depravity in Matthew 7:11.
‘If you, then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more shall your Father, who is in heaven, give good gifts to those who ask Him?’ How do the evil give good things? Now, He has called those ‘evil’ who are as yet the lovers of this world and sinners. In fact, the good things are to be called good according to their feeling because they reckon these to be good things. Although in the nature of these things [fish and bread] such things are good, but temporal, and pertain to this feeble life, and whoever that is evil gives them does not give of his own [nature], for the earth and the fullness thereof is the Lord’s, who made heaven and earth and the sea and all that is therein.
Augustine of Hippo (5th century), On the Sermon on the Mount, book 2, chapter 21, section 73
Augustine nails this explanation. It’s not the people who are good. After all, Jesus says they are evil. It’s not their actions that are good either. Rather, it is the gift itself that is good because of its source and nature. It’s nature is sustenance, which is good for humanity. It’s source is God, who created the world and everything in it. Therefore, the only thing that could possibly be considered “good” is the gift of bread and fish, even though these are temporal and temporary sustenance. Matthew 7:11 does not undermine total depravity at all. Rather, this doctrine was affirmed by many church fathers.
Those who are carnal cannot do things that are spiritual, nor can those who spiritual do things that are carnal, even as faith cannot do the works of unbelief, nor unbelief the works of faith.
Ignatius of Antioch (1st century), Epistle to the Ephesians, chapter 8
Man [Adam], who was by nature capable of receiving good and evil as soil of the earth and capable of receiving seeds from both sides, welcomed the hostile and greedy counselor [Satan]. Having touched that tree [of the knowledge of good and evil], he transgressed the command and disobeyed God. … When he [Adam] had fathered many children [humanity] and had grown very old and had returned to the earth [died] through having tasted of the tree [of the knowledge of good and evil], an inheritance was left behind by him for his children. Indeed, he left his children an inheritance, not of chastity but of us unchastity, not of immortality but of corruptibility, not of honor but of dishonor, not of freedom but of slavery, not of sovereignty but of tyranny, not of life but of death, and not of salvation but of destruction.
Melito of Sardis (2nd century), On the Passover verses 48-50
Few make use of this heavenly benefit and gift [the gospel] because the truth lies hidden, veiled in obscurity, and is either an object of contempt to the learned because it does not have suitable defenders, or is hated by the unlearned on account of its natural severity, which the nature of men, who are inclined to vices, cannot endure, because there is a bitterness mingled with virtues, while vices are seasoned with pleasure, offended by the former and soothed by the latter. They are borne headlong and deceived by the appearance of good things. They embrace evil for good.
Lactantius of North Africa (3rd century), Divine Institutes, book 1, preface
The devil wrought sin from the beginning in the rational and understanding nature of man. For which reason, it is impossible for the [human] nature, being rational, willing, and under the condemnation of death, to restore itself to liberty.
Athanasius of Alexandria (4th century), Orations Against the Arians, oration 2, volume 1, page 358
Clearly, many foundational theologians of the early church affirmed total depravity. They affirmed that the natural person can only do that which is “carnal”, “unchaste”, “corruptible”, “dishonorable”, and “works of unbelief”, and they cannot do “spiritual works”, “the works of faith”, that which is “chaste”, that which is “honorable”, nor believe the gospel. Humanity is a slave to sin and completely incapable of freeing himself. Total depravity is the black background to the beautiful diamond that is God the Father’s grace dispensed only in His Son by His Spirit. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments