Protestants often celebrate Reformation Day on October 31st because that’s the day when Martin Luther nailed his 95 theses to the door of the chapel in Wittenberg, Germany, in 1517. This event was the catalyst that began what is called the Protestant Reformation, which revived a love for the Five Solas, that justification is by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone as taught in Scripture alone to the glory of God alone, after a thousand years of Catholic oppression. I don’t have time to explain what exactly we mean by the Five Solas, especially since I’ve already written on the subject here. What I want to address today is this question: Are Baptists Protestants? The answer is unequivocally “Yes”.
There is a growing trend in American evangelicalism that says Baptists are not Protestants. The logic goes something like this: There were people who taught that believer’s baptism by immersion is the correct doctrine, and they were unaffiliated with the Protestant Reformers (Martin Luther, Huldrych Zwingli, and John Calvin) in the 1500s. These people were called “Anabaptists,” or “again baptizers,” and they were persecuted by the Lutherans, Zwinglians, and the Calvinists in Germany and Switzerland. Therefore, those Christians today who hold to believer’s baptism by immersion are not Protestants. That’s the logic used to say Baptists aren’t Protestants, and it sounds good at first. However, it is historically inaccurate.
Baptists today in America and the United Kingdom cannot trace their roots to the Anabaptists. The only denominations that can trace their roots to the Anabaptists are the Amish, the Mennonites, and Hutterites. The Grace Brethren denomination (which is the denomination of the college I attended) can technically trace its roots back to the Anabaptists too, but they’re more of an amalgamation of Anabaptists and Baptists at this point. My point is this: Historically, Baptists in America and the United Kingdom cannot trace their roots to the Anabaptists. If that’s the case, then who can we trace our roots back to? The Protestants.
If you’re nerdy like me, then I recommend the book The Baptist Heritage by H. Leon McBeth. It’s lengthy, but it explains the origin of the Baptists in great detail. Let me summarize his explanation of Baptists’ origin. In England, a state church known as the Anglican Church emerged during the Protestant Reformation motivated by both theology (the Five Solas) and politics (Henry VIII wanted to be able to divorce his wife, something the Catholics wouldn’t allow). However, there was a group of Christians in England in the latter part of the 1500s and into the 1600s known as the Separatists. They were Christians who didn’t appreciate the state church telling them what to believe. Eventually this disapproval came to include the doctrine of infant baptism by sprinkling, and thus, the first Baptists were born in England.
There were two groups of Baptists in England, the General Baptists and the Particular Baptists. The General Baptists believed the atonement’s intent was general and, consequently, held to Arminian theology. The Particular Baptists believed the atonement’s intent was particular and, consequently, held to Calvinist theology. To briefly summarize, the General Baptists mostly died out when their leaders became obsessed with being baptized by men who could trace their baptisms back to the Apostles through something called “apostolic succession.” As you can imagine, no one could prove that their baptism went all the way back to the Apostles, and the movement died out. However, the Particular Baptists thrived in England and eventually thrived in America as well.
What’s my point? Pretty much all Baptist churches in the United Kingdom and America today can trace their origins to Baptists from England, most likely the Particular Baptists. The Particular Baptists evolved out of the Separatist movement in England in the 1600s, and the Separatist movement evolved out of the Anglican Church in England in the 1500s. From what movement did the Anglican Church find its origin? The Protestant Reformation. Therefore, your average Baptist in America is in fact a Protestant. Not only that, but much to the dismay of many Baptists, most Baptist churches in America can trace their roots back to Calvinist Baptists from England as well.
Don’t let anyone tell you that Baptists aren’t Protestants. Unless you’re Mennonite, Amish, or maybe Grace Brethren, then you are not an Anabaptist. Therefore, if you’re a Baptist, then celebrate Reformation Day. This Reformation Day, take some time to thank God for giving us the Protestant Reformation. Thank Him for how He was at work in the past in Luther, Calvin, and Zwingli and how He is at work today in faithful Reformed Baptist, Presbyterian, Lutheran, and Anglican churches. Also, this Reformation Day, don’t forget to evaluate yourself. There is just as much of a need for a Reformation today as there was back in the 1500s, and that’s why this Reformation Day we need to remember to be always reforming (semper reformanda) according to the Scriptures. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments