Presuppositional apologetics is the biblical strategy for dialoguing with non-believers. Instead of providing natural evidences to persuade the non-believer to become a Christian or adopt an aspect of the Christian worldview, and instead of pointing to amazing experiences to convince the sinner to believe the gospel, presuppositional apologetics says the Christian should simply use Scripture to convict the sinner and then offer grace in Jesus Christ. After all, the problem for non-believers is not a lack of information. They already believe there is a God according to Romans 1:18-20, and they already know they’re a sinner according to Romans 2:12-15. Their problem isn’t a lack of information, but a rebellious heart, and only Scripture can soften a rebellious heart. Naturalistic or experiential evidences aren’t divinely-appointed means of grace, and there are only two options when we argue naturalistically or experientially with a non-believer on topics like creation or the age of the earth. Either they will intellectually agree that the earth is young without believing the gospel (at which point they still have a hard heart and are spiritually lost), or they will reject what we say. This mentality is present within the early church, even among some of the earliest apologists.
Suppose I should show you a dead man raised and alive, even this you would disbelieve. God indeed exhibits to you many proofs that you may believe Him.
Theophilus of Antioch (2nd century), To Autolycus, book 1, chapter 13
With good reason, then, the Hebrew Scriptures at an earlier time require faith before either the understanding or the examination of the sacred writings, where it says, ‘If you will not believe, surely you will not understand,’ and again, ‘I believed, and therefore, I have spoken.’
Eusebius of Caesarea (260-339), Preparation of the Gospel, book 12, chapter 1
Theophilus and Eusebius were two of most well-known public apologists for Christianity, yet both of them affirmed presuppositional apologetics. Theophilus knew that if he appealed to his audience on the basis of miraculous experiences, it would be insufficient to save them. Likewise, Eusebius knew that someone must come to Jesus by faith, not reason. Therefore, our appeal to non-believers should not be merely a rational endeavor, but an authoritative proclamation from Scripture.
The early church’s apologists were brilliant men with impeccable logic, yet they placed Scripture at the forefront of their arguments. They knew logic does not have the ability to regenerate a sinner and is insufficient to save a sinner. They knew the sinner must have faith, which is the assurance that something is true, even you can’t see it or reason your way to it. Only by faith does a sinner come to be saved, and faith only comes by the preaching of the Word of God, particularly the gospel. The sinner’s problem is not a lack of information, but a rebellious heart, and that’s why we must let Scripture loose when we talk to non-believers and command them to have faith in Jesus. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments