Church History: Irresistible Grace

Church History: Irresistible Grace

One of the core tenets of Reformed Theology is irresistible grace, the teaching that when God calls someone to salvation, that individual will believe the gospel and be saved, guaranteed. Of course, irresistible grace, also known as “effectual calling,” is a controversial doctrine, but I believe it is profoundly biblical. Not only that, but the doctrine is historical as well, because it appears in the ancient writings of the Church too, even the earliest church father, Clement of Rome.

Seeing then that He desires all His beloved to be partakers of repentance, He confirmed it by an act of His almighty will.

Clemen of Rome (AD 35-99), 1 Clement 8:6

Finally, may the all-seeing God and Master of spirits and Lord of all flesh, who chose the Lord Jesus Christ and us through Him for a special people, grant to every soul that is called after His excellent and holy name faith, fear, peace, patience, long-suffering, temperance, chastity, and soberness, so that they may be well-pleasing to His name through our High Priest and Guardian, Jesus Christ.

Clement of Rome, 1 Clement 64:1

May the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with you and with all men in all places who have been called by God.

Clement of Rome, 1 CLement 65:2

Clement did not believe everyone is called by God. Otherwise, he would not have wished grace upon the church in Corinth as well as “all men in all places who have been called by God.” Clement clearly has Christians in mind when he offers these benedictions, and Clement believed another way to refer to Christians is by referring to them as those “who have been called by God” and His “almighty will.” To Clement, not everyone is called, and those who are called are all Christians because God’s will is almighty. This is a textbook definition of irresistible grace. This teaching originates from the earliest church father available to us today, though the Epistle of Barnabas is a close second.

Therefore, He circumcised our ears, so that hearing the word, we might believe.

Epistle of Barnabas (c. AD 100) 9:2

Immediately, someone might say that Barnabas (or pseudo-Barnabas) used the words “might believe,” not “will believe,” thereby saying that not everyone who has circumcised ears will guaranteed believe the gospel. However, this objection betrays an ignorance of the Greek language and syntax. In Koine Greek, when the author desires to denote purposes and results (“so that” or “in order that”), he would use the word hina and a verb in the subjunctive mood. While the subjunctive mood does ordinarily denote possibility or uncertainty, that is not the case when paired with the word hina. In the New Testament, whenever the word hina appears with a subjunctive mood to describe the purpose of God, the purpose is always accomplished without exception. Therefore, following the pattern of the New Testament, Barnabas wasn’t teaching that someone might believe the gospel, but it’s only a possibility. Rather, he taught that someone guaranteed would believe the gospel whenever his ears were circumcised. Therefore, Barnabas believed that whenever God circumcised someone’s ears, he or she would believe the gospel, guaranteed. Again, that is a textbook definition of irresistible grace from the two oldest church fathers, and this teaching continued over the centuries.

Therefore, when we who were in time past–as it were–blind and–as it were–shut up in the prison of folly, were sitting in darkness, ignorant of God and of the truth, we have been enlightened by Him, who adopted us into His covenant, and having freed us from cruel chains and brought us out to the light of wisdom, He admitted us to the inheritance of His heavenly kingdom.

Lactantius (AD 250-325), Divine Institutes, book 4, chapter 20

To Lactantius, what was the result of God enlightening the sinner? Adoption, freedom, wisdom, and citizenship in the kingdom. There was no room for failure in Lactantius’ mind. To Lactantius, there was no such thing as someone walking around, having been enlightened by God, but not adopted, not free, and not wise. Enlightenment wasn’t a possibility for salvation to him, but rather the cause of salvation. One of Lactantius’ contemporaries, Eusebius, echoed this sentiment, though he was admittedly inconsistent on this subject.

Thus, it is plain that the Helper, who comes down from the God of the universe, supplies to the teaching and the name of our Savior its irresistible and invincible force and its victorious power against its enemies.

Eusebius (AD 260-339), Preparation of the Gospel, book 1, chapter 4

Eusebius even uses the word “irresistible.” The Helper (the Holy Spirit), who comes from the God of the universe (the Father), empowered the teaching (the gospel) of our Savior (the Son) to make its effect irresistible. For those whom God the Holy Spirit chooses to save, He will save by His invincible force, to the point that the gospel is victorious and powerful over its enemies.

Many of the earliest and most renowned church fathers taught that the Holy Spirit irresistibly calls those whom the Father chose to believe in the Son for salvation. They used terms like “irresistible,” “invincible,” and “almighty” to describe God’s call on certain sinners. In fact, they even used the phrase “those who are called” as a synonym for “Christian,” implying that only Christians have been called. To many of the church fathers, there was no room for a potential salvation. There was no room for the Holy Spirit to try to save someone, but then to fail. Instead, they taught the Holy Spirit could conquer and enlighten the soul of any sinner He desired to save. This was the teaching of many early church fathers, and this teaching became codified in the teachings of Augustine, who championed the soteriology of Reformed Theology in the fifth century. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *