Church History: Inscrutability of God

Church History: Inscrutability of God

God’s attribute of inscrutability–His inability to be completely comprehended–is one of the most appreciated attributes in church history. There is a beauty in admitting that you can’t totally grasp an infinite God, and Christians have been admitting this truth for millennia.

I say, then, that God is not born, not made, an ever-abiding nature without beginning and without end, immortal, perfect, and incomprehensible.

ARISTIDES OF ATHENS (AD ?-134), Apology, chapter 1

It seems to me that He is indeed unsearchable in His nature, and that I should argue as to the constancy of His government, so as to grasp it fully, is a vain effort for me, for it is not possible that a man should fully comprehend it.

Aristides, Apology, chapter 1

They [the Greeks] err in seeking to liken their gods to God, whom man has not at any time seen, nor can see into what He is like.

Aristides, Apology, chapter 13

Aristides not only confessed that God is incomprehensible and that mankind cannot understand what He is like entirely, but also that mankind cannot even understand His providence and how He governs the universe entirely. Of course, Aristides is correct, because God is inscrutable. His thoughts are higher than our thoughts, and His ways are higher than our ways.

You will say to me, ‘Do you, who see God, explain to me the appearance of God?’ Hear, O man, the appearance of God is ineffable and indescribable and cannot be seen by eyes of flesh, for in glory He is incomprehensible, in greatness unfathomable, in height inconceivable, in power incomparable, in wisdom unrivaled, in goodness inimitable, and in kindness unutterable.

Theophilus of Antioch (AD ?-183), To Autolycus, book 1, chapter 3

In beautiful poetic fashion, Theophilus describes our God in His many attributes, but the most relevant here is his statement that “in glory He is incomprehensible.” This statement clarifies the attribute of inscrutability, because some might interpret inscrutability as meaning God cannot be known. No, inscrutability means that God cannot be known entirely, particularly because He is so glorious, just as Theophilus and his contemporary, Marcus Minucius Felix, said.

[God] can neither be seen–He is brighter than light–nor can He be grasped–He is purer than touch–nor estimated–He is greater than all perceptions–infinite, immense, and how great is known to Himself alone.

Marcus Minucius Felix (c. AD 150-250), Octavius, chapter 18

Inscrutability cannot be defined more simply than that: God is greater than all perceptions and cannot be estimated. How great He is, only He knows.

The truth–that is, the secret of the Most High God, who created all things–cannot be attained by our own ability and perceptions. Otherwise, there would be no difference between God and man if human thought could reach the counsels and arrangements of that eternal majesty.

Lactantius (AD 250-325), Divine Institutes, book 1, preface

Can anyone doubt whether anything can be difficult or impossible for God, who by His providence designed, by His energy established, and by His judgment completed those works so great and wonderful, and even now sustains them by His Spirit and governs them by His power, being incomprehensible and unspeakable and fully known to no other than Himself?

Lactantius, Divine Institutes, book 1, chapter 8

Like Aristides, Lactantius confessed that even God’s providence is inscrutable, let alone His nature. He is known fully only with Himself. Only the Father fully comprehends the Son and the Spirit. Only the Son fully comprehends the Father and the Spirit, and only the Spirit fully comprehends the Father and the Son.

The gospel teaches us not to stand in awe of the visible parts of the cosmos and all that can be apprehended by fleshly sense, as they must be of perishable nature, but to marvel only at the mind which in all these exists unseen, and which creates both the whole and each several part, and to regard as God one sole divine Power pervading and ordering all things, being in its nature incorporeal and intelligent, or rather impossible to describe and to conceive.

Eusebius of Caesarea, (AD 260-339), Preparation of the Gospel, book 3, chapter 6

Like Lactantius, Eusebius declares that the gulf between what is created and physical cannot fully describe nor fully conceive of the incorporeal and omniscient God. Humans are wholly at the mercy of God to reveal Himself, because if He did not reveal Himself, then humanity’s knowledge of God would hit a very low ceiling. This is why the incarnation of the Son was so necessary.

God, who has the power over all things, when He was making the race of men through His own Word, seeing the weakness of their nature, that it was not sufficient of itself to know its Maker, nor to get any idea at all of God, because while He was uncreated, the creatures had been made from nothing, and while He was incorporeal, men had been fashioned in a lower way in the body, and because in every way the things made fell far short of being able to comprehend and know their Maker, taking pity–I say–on the race of men, inasmuch as He is good, He did not leave them destitute of the knowledge of Himself, lest they should find no profit in existing at all.

Athanasius of Alexandria (AD 396-373), On the Incarnation of the Word, chapter 11, section 1

Even before humanity fell, God knew their ability to know Him would be woefully low. The highest heights of mankind’s knowledge of God are woefully insufficient, and this is true even before the fall according to Athanasius. Consequently, the Father planned the incarnation of the Son from before the creation of the universe. It was always necessary and will always be necessary for us to know God more and more, and even then, He remains inscrutable.

God is inscrutable. No created being will ever fully comprehend His glorious nature. We can’t even fully comprehend His providential work behind the scenes. If God was anything less than inscrutable, He would not be God. That’s why we can find such joy in the fact that God is “incomprehensible,” “unsearchable,” “indescribable,” “ineffable,” “unfathomable,” “inconceivable,” “incomparable,” “unrivaled,” “inimitable,” “unutterable,” “inestimable,” “imperceivable,” “unspeakable,” and “impossible to describe and conceive.” This has been the confession of Christians for millennia now, and it will continue to be our confession for all of eternity. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *