Church History: Inclusivism

Church History: Inclusivism

Last week, we saw how the early church affirmed exclusivism, the idea that there is no salvation without conscious faith in Jesus Christ. However, there’s another side of the coin. There’s another use of church history. We can read the early Christians and see how they correctly interpreted the Bible in order to emulate their faith, or we can read the early Christians and see how they incorrectly interpreted the Bible in order to avoid their ”faith“. In this case, we need to recognize that the early church affirmed exclusivism, while also recognizing that some false teachers taught inclusivism as well.

What is inclusivism? It’s the opposite of exclusivism. Inclusivism teaches that there is salvation without conscious faith in Jesus Christ. Inclusivism offers a back door to salvation. Inclusivism says a person can be saved another way other than conscious faith in Jesus Christ, such as doing the best with the revelation they have, such as living as justly as possible, or some other lowered standard. This is a common teaching today, and it was a common teaching in the early church too.

We have been taught that Christ is the firstborn of God, and we have declared above that He is the Word of whom every race of men were partakers. Those who lived reasonably are Christians, even though they have been thought atheists, as among the Greeks, Socrates and Heraclitus and men like them, and among the barbarians, Abraham and Ananias and Azarias and Misael and Elias and many others.

Justin Martyr (2nd century), First Apology chapter 46

Accordingly, before the advent of the Lord, philosophy was necessary to the Greeks for righteousness, and now it become conducive to piety, being a kind of preparatory training to those who attain to faith through demonstration. ‘For your foot,’ it is said, ‘will not stumble if you do what is good, whether belong to the Greeks or to us, to Providence.’ For God is the cause of all good things, but of some primarily, as of the Old and New Testament, and of others by consequence, as philosophy. Perchance too philosophy was given to the Greeks directly and primarily until the Lord should call the Greeks, for this was a schoolmaster to bring the Hellenistic mind—as the Law to the Hebrews—to Christ. Therefore, philosophy was a preparation, paving the way for him who is perfected in Christ.

Clement of Alexandria (2nd-3rd century), Stromata book 1, chapter 5

I reply that there was never a time when God did not want men to be just. He was always concerned about that. Indeed, He always provided beings endowed with reason with occasions for practicing virtue and doing what is right. In every generation, the Wisdom of God descended into those souls which He found holy and made them to be prophets and friends of God.

Origen of Alexandria (3rd century), Against Celsus chapter 7

This teaching of inclusivism was relatively common in the early church. It even appeared in the teachings of the Reformers.

Whoever fulfills the Law is in Christ, and he receives grace because, as much as he is able, he has prepared himself for it. God could forgive them [those who never hear the gospel] of original sin (even though they may not have recognized it and confessed it) on account of some act of humility towards God as the highest Being that they know. Neither were they bound to the gospel and to Christ as specifically recognized, as the Jews [in the Old Testament] were not either. One can say that all people of this type have been given so much light and grace by an act of preventive therapy [and] mercy of God as is sufficient for their salvation in their situation, as in the case of Job, Naaman, Jethro, and others. … They have therefore fulfilled the Law. Whatever was lacking (and for this lack, they are excused on account of their invincible ignorance) God in His forbearance without doubt supplied to it, that it might be made perfect through Christ in the future. This is not different from what He did for the children who were uncircumcised for His sake (Matt. 2:16). He does the same thing today for our children.

Martin Luther, Commentary on Romans 2:10

I believe then that the souls of the faithful fly to heaven as soon as they leave the body, come into the presence of God, and rejoice forever. Here, most pious king, if you govern the state entrusted to you by God like David, Hezekiah, and Josiah did, then you may hope to see first God Himself in His very substance, in His nature, and with all His endowments and powers. … You may hope to see the whole company and assemblage of all the saints, the wise, the faithful, the brave, and the good who have lived since the world began. Here, you will see the two Adams, the redeemed and the Redeemer, Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Judah, Moses, Joshua, Gideon, Samuel, Phineas, Elijah, Elisha, Isaiah, and the virgin Mother of God whom he prophesies, David, Hezekiah, Josiah, [John] the Baptist, Peter, and Paul. Here too [are] Hercules, Theseus, Socrates, Aristides, Antigonus, Numa, Camillus, the Catos, and the Scipios. Here [are] Louis the Pious and your predecessors, Louis, the Phillips, the Pepins, and all your ancestors who have gone hence in faith. In short, there has not been a good man and will not be a holy heart or faithful soul from the beginning of the world to the end thereof that you will not see in heaven with God. What can be imaged more glad, what more delightful, and finally what more honorable than such a sight? To what can all our souls more justly bend all their strength than to the attainment of such a life? So it is with the damnation of unbelievers. Those only are understood who have heard and not believed. About others, we cannot pronounce an opinion because we do not know about the election of any, partly because Paul promises that if the uncircumcised [the Gentiles] do the works of the Law, then it shall become circumcision (for they show the Law of God written upon their heart), and because Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, the virgin Mother of God, Peter, and Paul were elected of God when they were still infants and had not faith, nay, before the world was made. It is not, therefore, a universal rule that he who has not faith is damned, but him who has heard the doctrine of faith expounded and remains and dies in unbelief, we can perhaps count among the wretched. … Nothing prevents God from choosing from among the heathen men to revere Him, to honor Him, and after death to be united to Him, for election is free. I certainly, if the choice were given to me, would prefer to choose the lot of Socrates and Seneca, who, though they knew not the one Deity, yet busied themselves with serving Him in purity of heart, than that of the Roman pontiff who would offer Himself to God if there were only a bidder at hand, or the lot of any king, emperor, or prince who serves as defender of such a little tiny god. Though these heathens knew not religion in the letter of it and what pertains to the sacraments, yet as far as the real thing is concerned, I say, they were holier and more religious than all the little Dominicans and Franciscans that ever lived.

Huldrych Zwingli (16th century), On Providence and Other Essays pages 199-201

These five men affirmed something that Scripture repudiates, that men can be righteous because of their efforts. Justin said atheists could be saved by living reasonably, even without faith in Jesus. Clement said the Greeks could attain righteousness by studying philosophy, even without faith in Jesus. Origen said anyone can be saved by being holy, even without faith in Jesus. Martin Luther and Huldrych Zwingli said those who fulfill the Law by obeying the Law of their consciences are actually righteous and in heaven. Zwingli even said the only people we can guarantee are lost and destined for hell are those who have openly rejected the gospel.

To say this teaching is dangerous is an understatement. If Zwingli is correct when he says only those who openly reject the gospel are guaranteed going to hell, then what’s the worst thing you can do for the pagan? Preach the gospel. After all, if Zwingli is correct, if you don’t preach the gospel to the pagan, then he has a fighting change of being righteous on his own. However, if you preach the gospel to the pagan, and if he rejects it, then you just guaranteed that his soul will be condemned to hell. Of course, this is the opposite teaching of Scripture. We’re told in Scripture that the only way someone can be justified is by faith in Jesus Christ, and the only way to have faith in Jesus Christ is by hearing the gospel plainly taught in some way, shape, or form.

If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, then you will be saved, for with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved, … for ‘Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.’ How then will they call on Him in whom they have not believed? How are they to believe in Him of whom they have never heard? How are they to hear without someone preaching? How are they to preach unless they are sent? … So, faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.

Romans 10:9-10, 13-15, 17

There has never been a sinner saved by “doing the best with what they have.” There has never been a sinner saved by philosophy. There have only ever been sinners saved by faith in the Messiah, the Christ, the Chosen One, the King who took away sin forever and rose from the dead. We know Him as Jesus Christ, and there’s no other name under heaven by which we must be saved. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *