Since we recently studied Jesus’ teaching on church discipline from Matthew 18:15-20, it’s fitting that we now study the application of excommunication (the final step of church discipline) in church history. Excommunication may seem harsh in our postmodern age where hurting someone’s feelings is seemingly a capital offense, but if we Christians are to be biblical and–as we’ll see today–historical, we must be ready and willing to excommunicate and shun those who fail to repent under church disciple.
Polycarp himself, when Marcion once met him and said, ‘Do you know us?’ replied, ‘I know the firstborn of Satan.’ Such caution did the Apostles and their disciples exercise that they might not even converse with any of those who perverted the truth, as Paul also said, ‘A man that is a heretic, after the first and second admonition, reject, knowing that he that is such is subverted and sins, being condemned of himself.’
Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History, book 4, chapter 14, section 7
There, upon a very large synod assembled at Rome of bishops in number of sixty and a great many more elders and deacons, while the pastors of the remaining provinces deliberated in their place privately concerning what ought to be done. A decree was confirmed by all that Novatus and those who joined with him and those who adopted his brother-hating and inhuman opinion should be considered by the church as strangers, but that they should heal such of the brethren as had fallen into misfortune and should minister to them with the medicines of repentance.
Eusebius, Church History, book 6, chapter 43, section 2
Other epistles written in the Latin language of Cyprian and those with him in Africa show that they agreed as to the necessity of succoring those who had been tempted and of cutting off from the universal church the leader of the heresy and all that joined him.
Eusebius, Church History, book 6, chapter 43, section 3
Then, after saying some things concerning all the heresies, Dionysius adds, ‘I received this rule and ordinance from our blessed father, Heraclas, for those who came over from heresies, although they had apostatized from the church, … when he had expelled them from the church, he did not receive them back, though they entreated for it, until they had publicly reported all things which they had heard from their adversaries.
Eusebius, Church History, book 7, chapter 7, section 4
We decided that if anyone should appear and make themselves a corruptive influence by teaching contrary to these statements, they should be cast out of the church, so that they cannot drag down some of the simpler church members by remaining in our midst.
Synod of Antioch, line 7
So that you might know this, we write to you, so that you too can be on guard against having fellowship with these men, and that you may not write to them or receive letters of fellowship from them.
Synod of Antioch, line 15
Even family members were not exempted from excommunication in the early church.
Although Origen was under the necessity of associating with him [his adopted brother, Paul], he nevertheless gave from this time on strong evidences of his orthodoxy in the faith, for when on account of the apparent skill in argument of Paul–for this was the man’s name–a great multitude came to him, not only of heretics, but also of our people. Origen could never be induced to join with him in prayer, for he held, although a boy, the rule of the church and abomination, as he somewhere expresses it, heretical teachings.
Eusebius, Church History, book 6, chapter 2, section 14
Furthermore, the excommunication of an individual wasn’t only from one local church either, but rather from all local churches.
Concerning those–whether the clergy or the laity–who have been excommunicated in the several provinces, let the provision of the canon be observed by the bishops which provides that persons cast out by some be not readmitted by others.
Council of Nicaea, canon 5
If anyone has been excommunicated by his own bishop, let him not be received by others until he has either been restored by his own bishop or until, when a synod is held, he shall have appeared and made his defense and, having convinced the synod, shall have received a different sentence. Let this decree apply to the laity and to elders and deacons and all who are enrolled in the clergy list.
Synod of Antioch in Encaeniss, canon 6
That’s how serious the early church took excommunication. In fact, excommunicating someone was so serious that those who fraternized with the excommunicated were excommunicated themselves.
If any one of the bishops, elders, deacons, or anyone of the canon shall be found communicating with excommunicated persons, let him also be excommunicated as one who brings confusion on the order of the church.
Synod of Antioch in Encaeniss, canon 2
Church discipline is necessary to maintain the purity of the local church. Those who claim to be Christians but refuse to repent when confronted must be removed not only from that specific local church, but from all local churches. Furthermore, those who are Christians must have nothing to do with them while they are excommunicated, including (but not limited to) praying with them, fellowshipping with them, or even conversing with them. However, should the sinner repent, then the local church must receive the sinner back into fellowship and restore him or her. This is the balanced and historical approach of church disciple, where the purity of the church and the justice of God and the mercy of God are all on display. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments