Church History: Early Church Downgrade

Church History: Early Church Downgrade

Tuesday’s blog posts are usually encouraging. They are usually posts that cite some of the earliest leaders in the Church with the purpose of demonstrating the historical validity of what we believe as Protestants at PCC. However, we cannot pretend that there wasn’t a Reformation. We cannot pretend that the visible church has always been faithful, because it hasn’t. In fact, for about 1,000 years, the visible church was dominated by cults, the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church. This begs the question: How did the visible church get to the point of needing a Reformation? As most downgrades in life, the process was slow and steady.

When looking at the errors of the Roman Catholic Church, they vary in severity. Not coincidentally, the less severe errors appeared in church history first. For example, the early church very early on adopted the unbiblical position of bishop. Basically, the early church erroneously created a division the titles “overseer/bishop” and “elder/pastor,” resulting in the bishop having authority over multiple churches. This error appeared very early.

See that you follow the bishop, even as Jesus Christ follows the Father, and the elders as you would [follow] the Apostles. Revere the deacons as being instituted by God.

Ignatius of Antioch (c. 100), Epistle to the Smyrnaeans, chapter 8

The deacon holding the mixed cup of the oblation shall say a Psalm from among those in which is written, ‘Hallelujah.’ Then, if the elder orders it, more from the same Psalms. After this, the bishop shall offer the cup, saying one of those Psalms appropriate to the cup, all of which should include, ‘Hallelujah.’

Apostolic Tradition (c. 200) 25:12-13

It should be known that Eusebius, whom [Dionysius] calls a deacon, shortly afterward became bishop of the church of Laodicea in Syria, and Maximus, of whom he speaks as being then an elder, succeeded Dionysius himself as bishop of Alexandria.

Eusebius of Caesarea (260-340), Church History, book 7, chapter 11, section 26

Bishops, elders, and deacons, once they have taken their place in the ministry, shall not be given communion even at the time of death if they are guilty of sexual immorality.

Council of Elvia (c. 309), Canon 18

By the fourth century, almost everyone in the visible church wrongfully differentiated between the bishop and the elders. To my knowledge, the only church leader after the 4th century to reject the bishopric was Jerome. Of course, the office of bishop is instrumental to Roman Catholic Church polity. Their entire religion hangs upon the bishop of Rome, the Pope. It should be noted that all of the earliest church fathers (Clement, Polycarp, and the Didache) all equated the office of elder with the office of bishop and recognized only two church offices (pastor and deacon).

Creating an unbiblical hierarchy of leadership gradually allowed the bishops (especially the bishop of Rome) to assert unbiblical authority over local churches, effectually ruining church autonomy. Likewise, the church early on abandoned not the biblical teaching regarding who leads the New Covenant people of God, but also how someone enters the New Covenant people of God. Specifically, infant baptism became popular very early in church history.

The Church received from the Apostles the tradition of giving baptism even to infants. For the Apostles, to whom were committed the secrets of divine mysteries, knew that there is in everyone the innate stain of sin, which are washed away through water and the Spirit.

Origen of Alexandria (185-254), Commentaries on Romans 5:9

The children shall be baptized first. All of the children who can answer for themselves, let them answer. If there are any children who cannot answer for themselves, let their parents answer for them or someone else from their family.

APostolic Tradition (c. 200) 21:4

The early church eventually accepted the practice of infant baptism. In fact, to my knowledge, I can’t find a church leader from the 5th century onward who affirmed believer’s baptism by immersion. It should be noted that the earliest church fathers (the Didache) affirmed only baptism of believers by immersion. These two errors are not grievous though. They do not necessarily result in grave error in a church. However, these two seemingly innocent errors gave rise to the heretical errors of the Roman Catholic Church, including their affirmation of baptismal regeneration.

Baptismal regeneration is the idea that the act of getting someone wet is the agent by which a sinner becomes justified. Basically, it teaches that until someone is baptized, they are not and cannot be justified, regardless of the presence of faith. Unfortunately, this is a fundamental tenant of Roman Catholicism, and it is also present in the early church.

I said, ‘I have heard, sir, from certain teachers that there is no other repentance except that which took place when we went down into the water and obtained remission of our former sins.’ He said to me, ‘You have heard well, for so it is. He that has received remission of sins ought to sin no longer, but to dwell in purity.’

Shepherd of Hermas (2nd century) 31:1-2

The prescript is laid down that ‘without baptism, salvation is attainable by none,’ chiefly on the ground of the declaration of the Lord, who says, ‘Unless one is born of water, he has no life.’

Tertullian (155-240), On Baptism, chapter 12, section 1

In baptism and in the dissolution of death, the flesh is raised up and returns to salvation by being recalled to the condition of innocence when the mortality of guilt is put away.

Novatian (200-258), On the Trinity, chapter 10

The early church began to put too much emphasis on the efficacy of the waters of baptism, and this led to the Roman Catholic Church teaching the heresy of baptismal regeneration. It is worth noting that plenty of early church fathers (Eusebius of Caesarea, Basil of Caesarea, Gregory of Nazianzus, and the Council of Elvira) explicitly rejected baptismal regeneration. The Roman Catholic Church gave their church leaders too much authority by saying they can forgive sins by baptizing babies and adults, and they also gave their leaders too much authority to forgive sins in penance.

If a woman beats her servant and causes death within three days, then she shall undergo seven years of penance if the injury was inflicted on purpose and five years if it was accidental. She shall not receive communion during this penance unless she becomes ill. If so, she may receive communion.

Council of Elvia (c. 309), canon 5

If a Christian completes penance for a sexual offense and then again commits fornication, then he or she may not receive communion even when death approaches.

Council of Elvia (c. 309), canon 7

I could give many, many examples from councils in the 4th century and onward describing penance as the means of obtaining forgiveness for sins committed after baptism. Basically, the early church’s overemphasis on the leadership of the church resulted in the leadership being given wrongful authority to determine how someone comes to be forgiven. With that in mind, it’s easy to see how the Roman Catholic Church came to practice confession to a priest and penance, such as saying ten “Hail Marys” and ten “Our Fathers.” There are many errors of the Roman Catholic Church, but these (baptismal regeneration and penance) are two of the more egregious. It’s encouraging to be able to look at church history and see exactly how these two heresies arose. They were not what the Apostles and church fathers originally taught. Rather, they arose from simple errors, but the earliest church fathers were (relatively) pure doctrinally. Their gospel was unstained and recovered by the Reformers. Soli Deo Gloria.

0 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *