This past Sunday, we concluded the Sermon on the Mount by briefly discussing the proper response to believing that Jesus is the Christ for the first time, which is baptism. We saw how John the Baptist baptized those who responded to his sermons by repenting. We saw how Jesus had His disciples baptize those who responded to His sermons by repenting, and we saw how the Apostles baptized those who responded to their sermons by repenting. Baptizing someone only after they repent and make a credible profession of faith is called credobaptism, or believers baptism. This is opposed to infant baptism. I’ve actually already addressed the concept of infant baptism in a previous post, but never from a historical standpoint.
Before getting into history, I want to mention that being a paedobaptist, those who baptize infants, is perfectly orthodox. I think it’s dangerous, but I’ve said to others multiple times that if there isn’t a Reformed Baptist church in the city where I live, then I’m probably going to join an OPC (Orthodox Presbyterian Church) or a PCA (Presbyterian Church of America) church, all of whom baptize babies. Even though I would disagree with their view of baptism, I would agree with them far more than with the average Baptist church on the topics of covenant theology, the millennium, the doctrines of grace, the means of grace in the Lord’s Supper, and the regulative principle of worship. Nevertheless, I will not baptize infants primarily for biblical reasons, but those biblical reasons are reinforced by historical reasons.
Concerning baptism, thus baptize: having first said these things [the Apostles’ Creed], baptize into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit in running water. If you do not have running water, [then baptize] in other water. If you cannot [baptize] in cold water, [then baptize] in warm [water]. If you do not have either [running water or other water], [then] pour out water three times upon the head into the name of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit. Before the baptism, let the baptizer and any who are able fast, and you will order the baptized to fast one or two days before.
The Didache (1st century) 7:1-4
Besides all this, he [Novatian] rejects the holy baptism and overturns the faith and confession, which precede it.
Eusebius of Caesarea (4th century), Church History, book 7, chapter 8, section 1
When reading Eusebius, you could miss his view of baptism if you’re reading quickly. He says that baptism occurs after someone believes and confesses faith in Jesus Christ. This does not allow for baptism of infants. Likewise, the Didache, which is probably the oldest non-inspired Christian letter we have, says to ideally baptize people in cold and running water, though warm and standing water is fine. First, that is baptism by immersion, especially since the Didache also said to pour water three times over someone’s head if there is no body of water available. The idea is to completely cover someone in water. However, they only did this after someone fasted for one or two days beforehand and after the individual recited the Apostles’ Creed. A baby cannot and should not fast. A baby cannot recite the Apostles’ Creed. Therefore, it appears the earliest churches were credobaptists.
I will say that there is a lot of support in the early church for infant baptism as well. Many, many church fathers practiced it. However, I can’t find any examples of paedobaptism before the turn of the 3rd century. I can find examples of credobaptism even in the 1st century, however. Thus, I think the historical support leans slightly in favor of the credobaptist position, though both are perfectly orthodox and historical. We at PCC baptize people only after they make a profession of faith in Jesus Christ because only then have they entered the New Covenant. Soli Deo Gloria.
0 Comments